Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
502 reviewsacross 24 different locations, showing 12.
over 8 years ago
Highly recommend Paul

Paul was great, very professional, comprehensive and up to date knowledge of the local market and was able to offer lots of relevant and useful advice. He wasn't super "salesy" like most other agents we met with and far more credible than the others. He also has a nice personable style and doesn't push and call you 800 times trying to get signed up like other agents. And most importantly we were very happy with the price he got us at auction!

Paul Sibley

Paul Sibley

  4.9   (313 reviews)
over 8 years ago
Highly Recommended Agent

Good communicator, knowledgeable and matter of fact. Paul’s professional and welcoming demeanor was appreciated and his compassion after a difficult post auction negotiation greatly appreciated.

Paul Sibley

Paul Sibley

  4.9   (313 reviews)
over 8 years ago
Great Agent

Paul was a very friendly and approachable agent. He helped us buy our first home and we couldn't be happier!

Paul Sibley

Paul Sibley

  4.9   (313 reviews)
over 8 years ago
Competent, genuine, honest, savvy, expert, knowledgeable and professional - thats Paul!

We had met Paul about 8 years ago when we were looking to buy a home in the Highett /Moorabbin area. He came over late one evening as it was the only time we could manage and we were left feeling optimistic, excited and realistic about where we were at. We purchased a house which Paul was the auctioneer and were looked after all the way through the process by Paul and the Buxtons Team. Several years later and the time had come for us to move out of Australia and we didn't even consider any other agent other than Paul. He kept us up to date with where our house was positioned in the market and he gave us regular updates via email. Catherine has been great at managing the property and our lovely tenants in our absence and Natalie has been a wonderful communicator and support during the sale period of our house. As we reside overseas, the whole team communicated daily and efficiently with us and we thoroughly enjoyed the process. Paul and his team worked tirelessly on our campaign, re-assured us at every turn when we had questions and we have been thrilled with the results. We were also impressed at how well the tenants have been look after during the process. Thank you Paul, Natalie and Catherine.

Paul Sibley

Paul Sibley

  4.9   (313 reviews)
over 8 years ago
Excellent Agent

I would like to thank Paul for the Excellent Sales Campaign he initiated and ran for the sale of my property. The figure we achieved was top of the range that he first advised. His sincerity and professionalism really came to the fore when we experienced a sudden death in the family on the eve of the Auction. Nothing could have prepared me for the roller coaster ride of emotions on that day and Paul proved to be very caring and understanding and helped me through the whole process. I have recommended him to friends and family and one family have already listed with Buxton. Thank you, Jennie Robertson

Paul Sibley

Paul Sibley

  4.9   (313 reviews)
over 8 years ago
Recommend this agent

Very professional, friendly and helpful.

Paul Sibley

Paul Sibley

  4.9   (313 reviews)
over 8 years ago
Excellent Agent

We identified Sharon via the 'RateMyAgent' website and are glad we did. Due to the surplus of apartments in Melbourne we were facing an uphill battle in selling our 6 year old apartment in Highett, having seen many others remain unsold for 6 months and more. Sharon managed to sell our apartment for a great price in far shorter time frame, saving us a lot of stress. Probably the best thing about Sharon is her communication skills. I like to be kept up to date and that is what I got, always being kept in the loop regarding open days, offers, etc. Sharon id friendly, professional, approachable and definitely experienced (her knowledge and recommendations show that). I would most certainly use Sharon again, to sell or purchase, and we highly recommend her to anyone out there needing an agent. Thanks Sharon for all your hard work, much appreciated. Warren & Veronika

Sharon Quick

Sharon Quick

  4.9   (47 reviews)
over 8 years ago
Great Agent

Noel is a very professional agent and is an amazing communicator. He is consistently communicating throughout the sale process to achieve the best result for all parties. We would not hesitate in recommending Noel as a trustworthy and honest agent!

Noel Susay

Noel Susay

  4.8   (138 reviews)
over 8 years ago
Great Agent

Paul and his colleagues did a great job from start to finish. The whole selling process from first interview with Paul to auction day was mapped out and worked very well. Clear and regular communication... Great job...

Paul Sibley

Paul Sibley

  4.9   (313 reviews)
over 8 years ago
Highly competent and professional

We found Noel to be highly competent and professional throughout the selling process. Noel was in regular communication with us; and we always felt he had our best interests at heart. We would recommend Noel.

Noel Susay

Noel Susay

  4.8   (138 reviews)
almost 9 years ago
Tenacious, persistent and committed

Paul did a brilliant job of selling my apartment in a market which feels like it is on the decline (adding a degree of difficulty for him!). He didn't let up at any point, his communication was clear and constant and he pushed right to the very end to achieve a satisfactory result for me.

Paul Sibley

Paul Sibley

  4.9   (313 reviews)
almost 9 years ago
Highly recommended agent

Paul was a pleasure to work with in selling our property. A great communicator, he displayed patience and knowledge whenever he was asked questions regarding the process and the market. Paul conducted our sale in a very professional yet freindly manner, he is highly recommended.

Paul Sibley

Paul Sibley

  4.9   (313 reviews)
349 - 360 of 502
© 2026 RateMyAgent