Paul Sibley

Paul Sibley

Director / Auctioneer / Licensed Real Estate Agent at Buxton Hampton East
  •   4.9   (313 reviews)

About Paul

An expert agent and energetic Auctioneer with qualifications in Finance and Real Estate, Paul Sibley understands what makes markets tick and properties sell. One of the Buxton Group's youngest Directors when appointed, Paul's strong local knowledge and deep understanding of the wider market make him one of the area's most informed and trusted property professionals - able to offer his clients warm and enthusiastic service backed by strong strategic understanding. Personally involved in every stage of the selling process, from the initial meeting, marketing, open-for-inspections, buyer follow up, negotiating, auctioning and post-sale service, Paul's personal service allows him to tailor his approach to every client's individual needs. A tenacious operator who refuses to give an inch on sale day, Paul brings this same personal approach to his auctioneering – getting eye-to-eye with the potential buyers he's been meeting each week at inspections and pulling them over the line with the fall of the hammer! A local resident with a young family, Paul has a strong understanding of the reasons home-buyers, investors and developers buy in the area. Warm, welcoming and exceptionally talented at making connections, Paul is a true local agent whose genuine enthusiasm for the area is contagious …particularly amongst buyers! This local connection extends throughout the community. With networks linked to business, sport, family and friends, Paul is adept at selling the lifestyle of the area alongside the benefits of the property! Family-focused, easy-going and always-approachable, Paul's days as a keen amateur footballer and sportsman have given way to a more relaxed pace, as his life revolves around his three fast-growing daughters. A real ambassador for the area, it's not unusual to see Paul, his girls and their dog out keeping active…and actively engaging with the people and properties of the Bayside and Kingston area.

Paul's reviews

  4.9  
Paul has 313 reviewsacross 17 different locations, showing 6.
Review Paul
3 months ago
Excellent communicator, Bayside knowledge and network, third time engaging in Paul

I first engaged Paul some time ago to sell my parents’ property, and after that experience I was keen to have him involved in selling my own apartment. Paul and Nat - what a dynamic duo. From the first couple of phone calls to arrange an initial meeting right through to the sale, everything was exceptional. Our contracts were signed within two weeks of going to market, which was an incredible outcome. I couldn’t be happier. Communication throughout the process was fantastic. We received updates straight after every inspection, and I really appreciated the proactive approach and transparency. Paul has been looking after the Bayside area for a long time, and it truly shows in his professionalism, knowledge and results. I would highly recommend Paul and his team. You won’t be disappointed ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

3 months ago
Excellent Communicator and Experienced Team

Paul, Natalie and Team, Thank you for not only helping us buy this house but now for guiding us through the selling process. Thank you for your professionalism in working with our Vendor advocate and making the whole process run smoothly and most importantly, successfully!

3 months ago
Excellent Communicator and very professional.

Paul was excellent to deal with, things ran smooth from start to finish. The buying process was definately made easier with Pauls display of professionalism and knowlesge throughout. Paul also displayed great transparency and follow up at key moments only cementing my trust in him to finalise buying my first property. Would recommend Paul when looking to buy your next property.

4 months ago
Excellence backed by a formidable team at Buxton Hampton East.

Our Experience with Paul Sibley at Buxton Hampton East Initial Recommendation and Background Paul was recommended to us via Open Agent when we began searching for high-performing agents in our area to sell an apartment in Highett. From the very first contact by text message, it was evident that Paul had a sound knowledge of our building and after conducting my own analysis of Paul’s sales within our building, I discovered he had sold half of the apartments in the building, with some even sold more than once. First Impressions and Readiness to List At our initial meeting with Paul, it quickly became apparent he was the right agent for us. Since our apartment had just been renovated and staging was already completed, we were in a strong position to list the property straight away. Support from the Buxton Hampton East Team Paul, Natalie and the entire team at Buxton Hampton East were incredibly helpful in every aspect of getting our property to market within just a few days. Paul and his team acted swiftly and efficiently, ensuring everything proceeded smoothly. Throughout the process, we were kept informed of all progress and advised whenever the property was shown to potential buyers, even outside scheduled open for inspections. Successful Sale and Recommendation Paul’s expertise and professionalism were instrumental in achieving a sale in just three weeks. If you are considering selling in Highett, we highly recommend Paul as your agent.

6 months ago
Responsive and great outcome

Could not fault Paul and Nat throughout our sales Campaign. They were efficient, responsive and true subject matter experts. Made a busy time as seamless as it could be. Got us a great outcome too, prior to auction!

Show all 313 reviews

Paul's properties

Paul has 8 properties for sale and sold 59 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

SoldMay 22, 2026
$1,505,000
3 Grandview Grove
Moorabbin VIC 3189
4
2
2
House
For Sale
$1,750,000 - $1,850,000
6A Rose Street
Highett VIC 3190
4
3
1
Townhouse
SoldMay 8, 2026
$950,000
1/1149 Nepean Hwy
Highett VIC 3190
3
1
3
Townhouse
For Sale
$850,000 - $890,000
32 Golf View Road
Heatherton VIC 3202
3
1
2
House
Show all 67 properties
EmailSMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent