For Sale

43 Pagan Street, Jerrys Plains, NSW, 2330

1
1
102 m²
6042 m²

House

1 day on the market

Inspection times

Inspections are by appointment only.

What's around 43 Pagan Street

Historic Church, transformed into a stunning home!

Formerly St Matthew's Catholic Church, this remarkable building was constructed in 1890 and has been beautifully converted into a unique one-bedroom home. Set across three separate titles, it combines historic character, modern comfort and exciting future potential. The impressive open-plan living, dining and kitchen area features soaring cathedral ceilings, exposed beams, original leadlight windows and arched architectural details. The spacious bedroom opens through original cedar doors to a private courtyard, while the combined bathroom and laundry includes a shower, WC and pedestal basin. Set among established lawns and mature trees, the property also includes a powered, air-conditioned shed with an attached growing enclosure. An adjoining half-acre allotment is held on its own title and may offer further subdivision potential (STCA). Property highlights: * Historic former church, constructed circa 1890 * Beautifully converted one-bedroom home * Set across three separate titles * Open-plan living, dining and modern kitchen * Cathedral ceilings, exposed beams and leadlight windows * Bedroom plus Study area opening to a private courtyard * Combined bathroom and laundry * Air conditioning & ceiling fans * Powered, air-conditioned shed * Town water * Adjoining half-acre allotment on a separate title Potential for short-term accommodation, café, commercial use or further subdivision (STCA) A rare opportunity to secure an exceptional local landmark with history, character and endless possibilities. Situated 30 mins from Singleton & Muswellbrook Enjoy local facilities such as Jerrys Plains Tavern, Jerrys Plains Public School, Anglican church & Hollydene Estate winery! ** If you're viewing this stunning property on your phone, tap Floorplan to access the property video **

Looking for more information on 43 Pagan Street?

Explore comparables, sales history and growth for this property.
Learn more

Contact

Other properties for sale by One Agency Lindy Harris

For Sale
Price not available
89 Castlereagh Street
Singleton NSW 2330
4
2
3
House
For Sale
Price not available
26 Lloyd Jones Drive
Singleton Heights NSW 2330
4
2
3
House
For Sale
Price not available
5 Allsop Place
Hunterview NSW 2330
4
2
2
House

Browse properties sold in nearby areas

See more details about this listing on
© 2026 RateMyAgent