SoldMay 11, 2026

46 Newcastle St, East Maitland, NSW, 2323

$820,000

4
2
0 m²
1827 m²

House

21 days on the market

Sold: May 11, 2026

What's around 46 Newcastle St

A Landmark 1840s Residence on 1,827sqm – Rich in History, Ready for Its Next Chapter

Positioned on an expansive and rarely offered 1,827.1sqm parcel in a prime East Maitland location, 46 Newcastle Street presents an exceptional opportunity to secure a property of remarkable historical significance, scale, and future potential. Rich in local heritage, the property was originally established as the “Rose Inn” before later becoming known as the “Black Horse Inn,” forming an important part of East Maitland's early development and community story. At the heart of the property stands the original 1840s double brick residence, a striking example of early colonial architecture that continues to showcase its enduring craftsmanship. Defined by soaring cathedral ceilings, ornate period features, and grand proportions, the home retains a sense of character and authenticity rarely found today. Recent improvements, including a new iron roof and updated gutters, provide a solid foundation for restoration, ensuring the property is well-positioned for its next chapter. Spanning two storeys, the residence offers a flexible and evolving floorplan. A portion of the home has already been thoughtfully renovated to create a comfortable and functional living space, seamlessly integrating modern convenience within the historic setting. This updated section comprises a well-appointed kitchen, bathroom, internal laundry, spacious bedroom, and light-filled living and dining areas, along with a versatile activities or study room—ideal for those working from home or requiring additional living space. The remaining section of the residence offers an exciting opportunity for further enhancement, restoration, or redesign (STCA). Whether you choose to honour and restore the home's original character or undertake a more contemporary transformation, the scale and layout of the property provide endless possibilities to create a truly unique residence. The substantial landholding further enhances the appeal, offering ample space for future extensions, landscaping, or additional improvements, all within a highly sought-after and convenient location. Surrounded by quality homes and within close proximity to local schools, shops, transport, and essential amenities, the property combines historical charm with everyday practicality. A rare offering of this calibre, 46 Newcastle Street is a property that invites vision and creativity—perfect for those seeking to restore a piece of history or craft a landmark residence for generations to come. Disclaimer: Information contained on any marketing material, website or other portal should not be relied upon and you should make your own enquiries and seek your own independent advice with respect to any property advertised or the information about the property.

Looking for more information on 46 Newcastle St?

Explore comparables, sales history and growth for this property.
Learn more

Similar properties sold nearby

SoldMay 18, 2026
$829,000
1 Holt Close
East Maitland NSW 2323
4
2
4
House
SoldMay 17, 2026
$1,170,000
222 High Street
East Maitland NSW 2323
4
3
2
House
SoldMay 13, 2026

Other properties sold by Reece Thompson

SoldMay 12, 2026
$1,350,000
14 Lerra Rd
Windella NSW 2320
5
2
8
House
SoldMay 11, 2026
Price not available
3 Park View Crescent
Mcdougalls Hill NSW 2330
4
2
2
House
SoldMay 10, 2026
$765,000
53 Curtin Street
East Maitland NSW 2323
3
1
2
House

Browse properties sold in nearby areas

Email
© 2026 RateMyAgent