Aaron's profile

Aaron's reviews

  4.8  
Aaron has 168 reviewsacross 7 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Aaron's qualities as told by our client reviews: supportive, reliable, pleasant, responsive, honest, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Shire Realty exceeded our expectations
12 days ago
Shire Realty exceeded our expectations

When we wanted to sell our Arcadia property, we contacted several Real Estate Agents. Shire Realty was a standout from our first meeting with Aaron Godfrey. We felt confident that the entire process would be handled well by Shire. This turned out to be correct, and, our expectations were not only met, but exceeded. We were given a fair and honest valuation that turned out to be correct and we were delighted with the outcome. Aaron was very attentive to all of our needs and requests and was punctual for all appointments which was appreciated. He was able to identify the genuine buyers from the time-wasters. We had a sale after only 8 weeks that went without a hitch. There are several other properties near us listed with other agents that have been on the market for months. If you want the best in the business go no further than Shire Realty. Aaron and Shire Realty are a standout in our opinion and we could not be happier.

Seller review
Highly Recommend the Team at Shire Realty
6 months ago
Highly Recommend the Team at Shire Realty

Aaron was a pleasure to work with. We have worked with a few agencies on the past year and a half and were very frustrated with their service and so called results. He worked with us and kept us informed about our open homes and work with us on suitable times. They looked after our home during inspections and helped potential owners see how our home would suit their needs. Having met the new owners, we could see how happy they and their family were with their new home. I would highly recommend both Aaron and Harrison to family and friends.

Seller review
Professional, Calm & Highly Knowledgeable
6 months ago
Professional, Calm & Highly Knowledgeable

We recently sold our home with Shire Realty Castle Hill and were thoroughly impressed. Aaron and Harrison were professional, calm, and highly knowledgeable, guiding us through every step of the sales and auction process. Their support ensured we were well prepared, and the final result exceeded our expectations. We highly recommend Aaron and Harrison for their outstanding service, genuine care, and commitment to achieving the best outcome.

Seller review
Standout sales success story!
6 months ago
Standout sales success story!

Aaron and his team are a standout sales success story; our house sold in 30 days in a buyers’ market at a top end price (clearance rates low 70’s%). The behavioral examples of his professional approach differentiated him from his competitors; he was selected from a field of 6 and it was his case studies and statistics demonstrating how he achieved top end sales performance that made the difference. On Auction Day the quality in the selling process kicked in and the tactics applied delivered.

Seller review
Professional and a great communicator!
over 1 year ago
Professional and a great communicator!

Aaron has an excellent knowledge of the market and was able to guide us through every step of the sale process. Aaron is professional, a great communicator and made the entire sale process progress seamlessly. I have no hesitation in recommending Aaron and will definitely use Aaron in future.

Seller review
Professional; and a great communicator!
over 1 year ago
Professional; and a great communicator!

Aaron has an excellent knowledge of the market and was able to guide us through every step of the sale process. Aaron is professional, a great communicator and made the entire sale process progress seamlessly. I have no hesitation in recommending Aaron and will definitely use Aaron in future.

Seller review
Seamless & Stress-Free
over 1 year ago
Seamless & Stress-Free

Aaron made selling my property seamless and stress-free. His expert pricing, strategic marketing, and proactive communication attracted serious buyers quickly. Aaron provided daily updates, answered all questions promptly, and negotiated fiercely, securing a sale above expectations. A true 5-star professional—highly recommended!

Seller review
Castle Hill Home Owner
almost 3 years ago
Castle Hill Home Owner

The team at Guardian Realty at Castle Hill are professional and knowledgeable about The Hills District. Aaron, Sam and Benjamin were extremely helpful and always available with advice and assistance with the sale of my home. They are locals who know the area well and I highly recommend them for their genuine commitment to achieving the best outcome for their clients.

Seller review
Highly Recommended Agent!
almost 3 years ago
Highly Recommended Agent!

Having previously bought a property through Aaron, I knew he was the agent I wanted to then sell my property. My experience with Aaron on both the purchase and sale was excellent. His knowledge of the local market is exceptional and he ensured my expectations were managed realistically. His communication is open and transparent and nothing was ever a problem. I would highly recommend Aaron and his team.

Seller review
Transparent & Helpful - Highly Recommended
about 3 years ago
Transparent & Helpful - Highly Recommended

My wife and I were very happy with Aaron and his team with all the aspects involved with the selling of our property. They were very transparent and helpful with the whole process. Aaron was able to obtain a price that we were very happy with in this difficult market. We would recommend Aaron and his team to anyone selling their property in the Hills area.

Seller review
Highly Recommend Aaron & his team!
about 3 years ago
Highly Recommend Aaron & his team!

Aaron and his team worked tirelessly to obtain the result we wanted to achieve for our home. Aaron kept us informed throughout the whole process and was always available whenever we needed him. He has a deep knowledge of the Hills District and certainly knows how to put a deal together! We have recommended him to many of our friends and family and assure you that you would be happy with his service and Sales ability also.

Seller review
Service very good
about 3 years ago
Service very good

From Day One we found the service to be very good. Aaron and Sam from Guardian Realty Castle Hill were very informative and had great knowledge of what was to be expected with the sale of our property. The many times I would call there was never a problem with them answering and guiding me through the questions I had. Always polite and nothing seemed too hard. Our property was only on the market for three weeks and had 3 home opens. We were very happy with the price . We would highly recommend Guardian Realty

1 - 12 of 168
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent