Andrew's profile

Andrew's reviews

  4.9  
Andrew has 39 reviewsacross 11 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Andrew's qualities as told by our client reviews: great negotiation, empathetic, supportive, honest, reliable, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Excellent communicator who kept me informed during the entire journey
about 1 month ago
Excellent communicator who kept me informed during the entire journey

Right from the outset I felt entirely comfortable with Andrew. He explained the process fully and we met regularly for updates. He gave me his estimate on the expected outcome and ultimately his opinion on what price to expect on auction day. A sale was achieved at auction; the price achieved was within Andrew’s estimate and I was delighted with the outcome. Andrew is a very experienced agent, is friendly and has a calm nature without any “hard sell”. He made me feel as if I was his most important customer. Would strongly recommend Andrew to anyone wishing to sell their home in the Bentleigh and surrounding suburbs.

Seller review
Andrew was very good and professional.
5 months ago
Andrew was very good and professional.

Andrew was very good and professional. He was a pleasure to work with and made our selling experience a good one.

Seller review
An excellent experience
6 months ago
An excellent experience

Andrew was very easy to communicate with and gave me excellent advice. This I followed to my great advantage. He has excellent local knowledge and is a very experienced estate agent. I would highly recommend Andrew to any buyer or seller.

Seller review
A true Gentleman
6 months ago
A true Gentleman

Andrew is always understanding and sensitive to the emotional state of his client (me). Honest in his assessments, no exaggerations, no bulls..t! Punctual for appointments. I am so fortunate to have had Andrew managing my sale

Seller review
Wonderful experience selling in Bentleigh
7 months ago
Wonderful experience selling in Bentleigh

Andrew was fantastic throughout the process of selling our investment property. His knowledge of the local market was impeccable, and his communication throughout was so reassuring and consistent – we were always kept up to date with progress, enquiries, opens, everything! The final sale price well and truly exceeded our expectations (and had it not been for Andrew's advice on pricing, we would have short-changed ourselves)! We would highly recommend Andrew and the team at Buxton if you're selling in Bentleigh and the surrounds.

Seller review
Excellent Service and Result
8 months ago
Excellent Service and Result

We had a great experience selling our home with Andrew and his team. They were professional, knowledgeable, and fantastic at communication throughout the entire process. The outcome well and truly exceeded our expectations, and we couldn’t be happier with the result. Thanks, Andrew and Buxton!

Seller review
Straight to the top
9 months ago
Straight to the top

Not many words required. If you want the very best in experience and quality to achieve the optimum outcome for the sale of your property in any location Andrew will see it is done. A no brainer.

Seller review
Exceptional advocacy and guidance!
about 1 year ago
Exceptional advocacy and guidance!

It was obvious from the beginning of our sale journey that we were in very capable hands! Andrew’s experience and leadership was invaluable! His guidance was reassuring and his professional manner ensured we received maximum results. Every discussion was perfectly captured and all dates and steps delivered. He cannot be faulted!

Seller review
ULTIMATE PROFFE
about 1 year ago
ULTIMATE PROFFE

Ultimate professional in his field of work. great communication skills & top bloke

Seller review
Buxton's under the leadership of Andrew Chisholm provided a complete professional service
over 1 year ago
Buxton's under the leadership of Andrew Chisholm provided a complete professional service

My family were very pleased with all aspects of the House Sale process communicated expertly by Andrew and executed to the plan by his team As siblings we were selling our family home after our parents bought in 1965 so it was an emotional time and Andrew right from our first meeting put us at ease and assured us that timing was right for a positive sales result . Andrew provided regularly progress and updates of all steps along the way and was very helpful to me as family executor of probate giving sound advise on how to proceed . I would highly recommend Andrew and his team at Buxton's to prospective sellers/buyers as they can look forward in confidence to receiving an informed and fair appraisal of the market delivered in an informative and professional manner.

Seller review
Experienced, professional and personable
over 1 year ago
Experienced, professional and personable

"We are so grateful to Andrew Chisholm for his exceptional service in selling our home. From start to finish, Andrew was professional, attentive, and always available to answer our questions. He provided us with valuable advice and guidance throughout the campaign. We truly appreciate Andrew’s dedication and hard work, and we highly recommend him to anyone looking to buy or sell a home.

Seller review
Excellent guidance
over 1 year ago
Excellent guidance

Every dealing with Andrew, throughout our consideration of potential lead agents and then upon us confirming to run with him, we found him to be unfailingly courteous, listened carefully to our considerations and then gave options and guidance that kept us informed and at ease with our choice. Leading up to and including the auction day his advice was calm and well based. We are veryu thankful for the part he played in our successful sale.

1 - 12 of 39
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent