Andrew's profile

Andrew's reviews

  4.9  
Andrew has 284 reviewsacross 38 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Buyer review
Professional and fair- a trusted agent for buyers and sellers.
5 days ago
Professional and fair- a trusted agent for buyers and sellers.

I recently purchased a property through Andrew Magro, who was acting for the vendor, and found him to be consistently professional, calm and easy to deal with throughout a very challenging transaction. His communication was always clear and timely, and he took the time to explain each step of the process, so I knew exactly where things stood at all times. Despite some difficult moments, he remained firm while still being respectful to all parties, and stayed focused on getting the deal done fairly. As a buyer, I really appreciated his integrity, responsiveness and ability to keep the process on track. I would strongly recommend Andrew to both buyers and sellers looking for an agent who is trustworthy and easy to deal with. Thank you Andrew!

Seller review
Great agent with wealth of knowledge
20 days ago
Great agent with wealth of knowledge

Andrew helped sell my townhouse. Both he and his team went above and beyond always keeping me informed and assisting where needed. So grateful and appreciative for his hard work.

Seller review
Excellent communication
3 months ago
Excellent communication

He really knows the local area inside out. When it came to signing the contract, he walked me through every detail and made everything so easy to understand. I was actually out of the country when we hit the market, but he kept me in the loop the whole time, so I never felt out of touch.

Buyer review
First agent in 30+ years I rate as 5*
3 months ago
First agent in 30+ years I rate as 5*

Andrew is the first agent I can honestly say is worthy of 5*. He worked overtime to get a sale across the line with a stubborn seller and incompetent sellers solicitor. The extra work involved made at least 5 times the normal workload for a sale yet there was never a word of complaint. From both a seller and buyers perspective he went the extra mile and after dozens of real estate purchases I know many agents wouldn’t have done what he did. He runs a very tight ship at Harcourts Exclusive and would be an asset for sellers or buyers to have him on your side.

Seller review
Andrew's persevering attitude and calm yet positive words of encouragement and advice put us at ease
3 months ago
Andrew's persevering attitude and calm yet positive words of encouragement and advice put us at ease

My family and I are so grateful and appreciative of Andrew's efforts in assisting us with the sale of our family home. He turned a stressful situation on our part into an extraordinary experience because of his calm, confident and positive advice with regards to his knowledge of previous sales in our suburb and surrounding areas. We never had any doubts or concerns once he agreed to handle the sale and we were kept updated and reassured with timeframes and expectations. He meticulously explained the stages and processes involved and communicated the completion of every stage accordingly via email and text messages. We highly recommend Andrew and his team as our family have experienced an unprecedented level of professionalism, honesty, humility and negotiation skills that surpassed our expectations. Thank you very much!

Seller review
Professional, reliable real estate agent
3 months ago
Professional, reliable real estate agent

I have known Andrew for around 20 years, so I had no hesitation in using him to sell my mother’s house. He handled the sale very professionally from start to finish and was always honest and transparent throughout the process. He kept me updated every step of the way, regularly calling to let me know what was happening, what offers were being made, and where things stood with potential buyers. The house sold within a few weeks of going on the market, and although the final price was not exactly everything I had hoped for, it was still a very favourable result and I was content. I would gladly recommend Andrew to anyone looking for a professional and reliable real estate agent.

Seller review
From my first c
3 months ago
From my first c

My first phone introduction with Andrew Margo was all that i needed.Andrew literally took the steering wheel and all we did was followed his instructions and it all worked out according to our plans.My wife and i are very thankful that we chose to run with Harcourts realestate Carlingford. Professionalism 10/10 Overall 10/10 ❤️💯

Buyer review
Good communicator
4 months ago
Good communicator

Very responsive answered or returned call within a few hours.

Buyer review
Highly Professional and Knowledgeable Agent
5 months ago
Highly Professional and Knowledgeable Agent

We purchased our property through Andrew Magro and we found him to be professional, responsive, and well-informed throughout the entire process. Andrew has extensive knowledge of the real estate market and was able to clearly explain everything we asked about the property. He kept us informed at every stage and made the purchase process smooth and stress-free. Highly recommend.

Seller review
Excellent
6 months ago
Excellent

Excellent knowledge of the real estate market and gives 100% enthusiasm to the sale.

1 - 12 of 284
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent