Andrew's profile

Andrew's reviews

  5  
Andrew has 507 reviewsacross 38 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Andrew's qualities as told by our client reviews: stress-free process, honest, reliable, supportive, responsive, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Consistently above and beyond
about 4 years ago
Consistently above and beyond

Throughout the process of selling our first home Andrew and his team have all gone above and beyond to ensure we had a smooth sale of our property. He is always available and genuinely happy to help even helping us by removing shelving prior to settlement. I cannot thank Andrew and his team enough for everything they have done and would absolutely recommend him to anyone thinking about selling a property!

Buyer review
Professional with good knowledge of area
about 4 years ago
Professional with good knowledge of area

Andrew is very professional with good knowledge of area. As a buyer I was new to the suburb and Andrew explained me all the query I asked. Responded my call/ email promptly and all questions answered to satisfaction. His service and professionalism is more than five star.I recommend Andrew for both buying and selling.

Buyer review
Above and beyond
about 4 years ago
Above and beyond

Andrew went above and beyond in helping us with an complicated purchase. Thanks Andrew.

Buyer review
An agent that goes above and beyond!
about 4 years ago
An agent that goes above and beyond!

Andrew’s professionalism, care and determination to get the best outcome for both the seller and buyer is second to none. It has been a pleasure working with him and we have no hesitation recommending him for future property transactions. Andrew went above and beyond to make sure that our purchase was successful, even doing the job of three people to get it over the line. He is fantastic to deal with and stands out from the crowd.

Seller review
Best in the Macarthur/Camden region
about 4 years ago
Best in the Macarthur/Camden region

Andrew has always been exceptional at managing our properties so it was no surprise with the service we received when selling our property. Given it was our first home we purchased as 20 year olds meant a great deal to us. As a result, Andrew was very understanding with our requests. Andrew liaised with our conveyancer and all communication was transparent with us being cc’ed into any correspondence. Andrew is a high level operator who understands the needs for both the vendor and purchaser. Highly recommend Andrew and the First National Collective team to people who want to sell their home and/or want their properties managed by a team of experts. Again, thanks Andrew Cartilla family

Seller review
Professional, trustworthy and dedicated
about 4 years ago
Professional, trustworthy and dedicated

Andrew has, hands down, been the best agent I've ever worked with. His dedication to achieving the best possible outcome for his clients is second to none, and all done with integrity and a calm and professional attitude. I wouldn't hesitate to recommend Andrew to anyone looking to sell their property (or buy one!), as the experience will be unmatched. Thanks Andrew, and your team at First National Collective Narellan, for everything you have done for my family and I, it will not be forgotten.

Buyer review
Absolute pleasure to work with.
over 4 years ago
Absolute pleasure to work with.

Andrew is an absolutely wonderful and pleasant guy. His got vast knowledge and experience in the real estate industry and it can be seen through his work and commitment towards his clients. I would recommend him to anyone as he makes processes seemless and effortless. He makes thinks happen in a click. Thank you again for all your help Andrew, all the best!

Buyer review
An absolute pleasure to deal with
over 4 years ago
An absolute pleasure to deal with

As a buyer, our experience with Andrew and the First National team was wonderful. Andrew was such a pleasure to deal with and being a local himself, his knowledge of the area was invaluable. Andrew was always very quick to respond to our enquiries and kept us updated every step of the way. We have dealt with many agents in the area however our experience with Andrew was more personable and it always felt like we were chatting with a friend rather than a real estate agent. Thank you Andrew and team for helping us find our forever home!

Seller review
Ultimate professional
over 4 years ago
Ultimate professional

Andrew has been great from start to finish. Always goes above and beyond.

Seller review
A gentleman. advocate and skilled salesman
over 4 years ago
A gentleman. advocate and skilled salesman

We found Andrew on ratemyagent and his numbers spoke for themselves initially. He met us promptly in person and we were impressed with his skills as a communicator and salesman and was the standout from all the agents we had met up to that point. My mother was selling her place and in assisting her, we were looking for someone who could represent her well. Andrew was able to communicate effectively with my mother, talk her language and spoke with respect. He was confident of his strategy and in his knowledge of the market. His pricing was competitive and we felt he brought much more value than what he asked for. Throughout the process there was prompt communication and he was accessible for a busy working family. Andrew really shone when he was able to navigate obstacles outside of all our control and he stayed cool and calm in these settings. In the end it was Andrew's expertise and advice led us to the best outcome and we can't thank him enough. We're so glad that we chose him and he represented us. It is our absolute pleasure to be able to recommend him to any prospective vendor.

Buyer review
Very professional and trustworthy!
over 4 years ago
Very professional and trustworthy!

Andrew was very professional, always helped with enquires during and after work hours. Andrew always returned calls which we appreciated! We highly recommend Andrew!

Buyer review
Very easy to deal with
over 4 years ago
Very easy to deal with

Andrew kept me informed during the whole process of purchasing the property. As I was purchasing an investment property, Andrew and his team were very informative about the renting process also. Would highly recommend Andrew.

325 - 336 of 507
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent