Carl's profile

Carl's reviews

  5  
Carl has 242 reviewsacross 29 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Seller review
Carl was Fantastic!
about 6 years ago
Carl was Fantastic!

I am so glad we engaged Carl as our Real Estate Agent for the sale of our house. It was a problem-free and stress-free sale from our point of view because Carl was fantastic and handled everything from start to finish in a calm, professional and timely way. He guided us, and let us know what was happening, at each step of the sale process and looking back now that settlement has been achieved we both think "Wow, that was so much easier than we expected." Thanks to you and your team Carl. PS: Carl was also our agent when we bought this same property 20 years ago.

Seller review
Fabulous agent
about 6 years ago
Fabulous agent

Carl is always looking out for his clients.

Seller review
undefined
about 6 years ago

Carl is honest, reliable and hardworking and consistently went above and beyond what was expected of him. He was extremely considerate and caring when dealing with my elderly mother whose property was being sold for the first time in nearly 60 years. His advice and expertise is second to none and we knew we could rely on him to get us the best offer, which he did. We would highly recommend him!

Buyer review
Carl was honest & easy to deal with.
about 6 years ago
Carl was honest & easy to deal with.

It was a pleasure working with Carl, I strongly recommend him to others looking to buy or sell!

Buyer review
Excellence
about 6 years ago
Excellence

Carl was an awesome realestate agent, he had extensive knowledge of the area and was very flexible when organising viewing times sometimes 2 in a day. He was not pushy with his opinion and did not treat us like we knew nothing. He is by far and away the best realestate agent we have ever felt with, friendly and professional.

Seller review
As good as it gets
over 6 years ago
As good as it gets

Carl was excellent. His style is genuine and his approach is a old school - which is probably why he is so effective. He knew his stuff which instilled confidence in the information he was providing without being overbearing.

Seller review
Very Pleased
over 6 years ago
Very Pleased

As always with our dealings with Carl Calio he was professional, has a large knowledge of the area and relentless in open house inspections and the selling our property.

Buyer review
The best real estate agent!
over 6 years ago
The best real estate agent!

It was an absolute pleasure dealing with Carl when buying my new property. He is very knowledgeable about the area and the real estate process, professional, personable, well-mannered, and understanding. He was not at all pushy but an experienced negotiator between seller and buyer. He was so helpful (beyond expectation) and he was always available and happy to answer my many questions and concerns. I have dealt with many real estate agents over the years and I rate Carl as the very best. He is a genuine, honest, and kind person.

Buyer review
Dealing with Carl was unexpectedly an enjoyable experience
over 6 years ago
Dealing with Carl was unexpectedly an enjoyable experience

Carl's been in this family business in this area for years, knows the area and tries to make sure that people are happy with what they get. You feel he has a deservedly good reputation to keep up. We are grateful to him for his service to us. As a person he is patient and informative. Nothing was too much trouble. In short, we hold him in high regard and strongly recommend his services.

Seller review
Calio & Scott Real Estate is the best in the business for the customer experience
over 6 years ago
Calio & Scott Real Estate is the best in the business for the customer experience

Carl has now sold two of my properties and there is a reason I will keep coming back. Carl will always be my number one choice and I recommend him and his team for all you buying, selling and rental needs. The customer service is outstanding and Calio and Scott always go above and beyond to assist you in all your property needs.

Seller review
List It With Carl And Get On With Life
over 6 years ago
List It With Carl And Get On With Life

We listed our property with Carl for several reasons :- His office is located very close to the property we had decided to sell. Carlio and Scott have been operating in Brighton and surrounding suburbs for many years. We didn't personally know Carl but a friend who does assured us that we would be impressed by Carl, he suggested you'll like Carl he's a good bloke. We listed the property on Saturday and found Carl to be knowledgeable and a thorough gentleman. He placed a value on the property which was significantly higher than what our uneducated estimate was. We left home the next day on a caravanning holiday through SA, VIC and NSW. Carl had 2 offers on our property at the full listed price by Tuesday. The property sold and Carl kept us informed by phone, text and email for every step of the sale process. We believe that a standout aspect of Carl's method of conducting business is that unlike the majority of agents these days who respond to enquiries by telling potential purchasers that there will be an open house this Saturday, Carl arranges a property inspection as soon as it suits all parties involved. In our case we gave Carl the keys and hit the road which made it a lot easier to meet potential buyers requests for inspections.

Buyer review
Professional and trustworthy
over 6 years ago
Professional and trustworthy

Carl was a pleasure to deal with. He was always available to answer any queries, even when on holiday, and made the whole process as stress free as possible. Honest, open and professional: three words that mean I have absolutely no hesitation in recommending him.

193 - 204 of 242
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent