Carl's profile

Carl's reviews

  5  
Carl has 242 reviewsacross 29 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Buyer review
Carl is an absolute gem!
about 1 year ago
Carl is an absolute gem!

We recently purchased a property through Carl and we cannot recommend him enough. As first time buyers, he made this process so simple for us. He was always quick to respond to any questions we had about the property and was incredibly helpful with local recommendations. He truly is an amazing agent and we are so grateful we crossed paths with him. As buyers, we’ve found this process incredibly daunting with so many agents just pushing the sell without really caring about the buyers (which is fine - we know they’re working for the sellers! Haha), but Carl really was different. We consider ourselves incredibly lucky!

Buyer review
Best Agent in Brighton
over 1 year ago
Best Agent in Brighton

We recently purchased a property off Carl Calio from Calio & Scott Realty. Carl’s kind and gentle demeanor made the whole process a dream. If you’re looking for an honest, trustworthy agent with exemplary communication skills, look no further. Thank you for making what is normally a very stressful experience feel so stress-free and pleasant.

Seller review
Outstanding
over 1 year ago
Outstanding

I cannot speak more highly of Carl and Linda. They are the ultimate professionals and leave no stone unturned. They answered my questions promptly and with patience, and communicated with me about all aspects of the sale. Highly recommend!

Seller review
Sale of property
over 1 year ago
Sale of property

I had a property for sale and Carl Calio took on the task to obtain the best price. He was very friendly, and nothing was too much trouble. He kept me informed every step of the way with what was happening. Because of the excellent communication there were no hiccups or misunderstandings and everyone knew what was going on. He was a good negotiator, and we were very happy with the sale price. If you are looking for a great estate agent, then I would recommend having a talk to Carl.

Buyer review
Professional & Easy to deal
over 1 year ago
Professional & Easy to deal

Carl has been very professional and easy to deal with all throughout the process. We would highly recommend!

Seller review
Very professional.
over 1 year ago
Very professional.

I went with Carl Calio because he was local and was recommended to me by friends. He was very hard working, professional and honest. I would recommend him to anyone who is anticipating selling their home.

Buyer review
Land Purchase
over 1 year ago
Land Purchase

A simple, no fuss transaction. A greater personal experience compared to other larger corporate RE agents I've transacted with in the past. Well recommend Carl and the team.

Buyer review
A pleasure to work with.
over 1 year ago
A pleasure to work with.

I spent several months researching and inspecting properties before stumbling accoss Carl at an open home. I quickly came to realise Carl was a stand-out against the majority of agents I had crossed paths with. Carl was politely honest, to both myself and his seller. Exceptionally prompt and professional, even messaging and calling me with responses when he was off work. I'm very happy with the end result of Carl's negotiation, as I'm sure his seller was as well. I can highly recommend Carl to anyone who is considering selling or buying in the Brighton region.

Seller review
Professional
over 1 year ago
Professional

Carl & his team were nothing short of professional. With a personal & caring attitude, taking great care to ensure I was looked after extremely well from start to finish. Having used his services before I would highly recommend them & engage with them again without hesitation.

Seller review
Best real estate agent ever
over 1 year ago
Best real estate agent ever

Communication was exceptional in keeping us up to date Knowledge of local area superb Extremely Professional in words and actions Advertising was first class Carl was caring and respectful in dealing with the family of a deceased estate, and we thank him very much

Seller review
A quick no fuss sale.
over 1 year ago
A quick no fuss sale.

Carl presented as honest and straight forward. We had a quick no fuss sale at a reasonable price. By contrast, other agents had contacted us promising higher than expected value followed by measures to see where the market is (and lower expectations). This playbook is used my many agents, it is predictable and dishonest. Carl did not rely on any of these manipulations. He simply gave us a reasonable estimate and quickly sold the property. A refreshing alternative.

Buyer review
Professional and Transparent
over 1 year ago
Professional and Transparent

Linda and Carl were terrific. We contacted Carl and he responded immediately. He explained the property and we contracted it immediately. Also transparent with communications and the expectations of the vendors. A seemless transition to settlement. Well done Mark and Peter

13 - 24 of 242
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent