Carl's profile

Carl's reviews

  4.9  
Carl has 128 reviewsacross 18 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Carl's qualities as told by our client reviews: reliable, friendly, honest, supportive, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Incredible market knowledge
almost 3 years ago
Incredible market knowledge

We recently worked with Carl and Donna to sell our home in Gordon. They sold it within 2 weeks for a good price. Throughout the entire process, Carl and his team were incredible. Very calm on auction day and kept us informed everyday throughout the selling process.

Seller review
Carl and his team did a great job and were lovely to deal with.
almost 3 years ago
Carl and his team did a great job and were lovely to deal with.

The team at MCY were knowledgeable, friendly and professional. Selling your much loved home will always be an emotionally fraught process. Carl, Donna, Jordan and the team showed empathy and understanding. All things considered, I think it was as relatively seamless and straight forward as we could have hoped.

Seller review
First class agent, first class person.
almost 3 years ago
First class agent, first class person.

Prior to listing our home with him, we had not had any dealings with Carl. We met him as a result of a recommendation from a friend. From start to finish Carl provided a first class, professional service that culminated in an excellent auction result. Carl's campaign strategy for our property, built on his in-depth local market knowledge and experience showcased our property to a large audience of buyers, delivered a high number of parties attending open homes and ultimately delivered a high number of registered bidders at auction, and ultimately a great auction result. Throughout the campaign Carl communicated openly and honestly with us and gave us great confidence in his ability to execute on the campaign plan. Carl was a pleasure to have around the house, his confident and positive personality greatly reduced the stress that inevitably when selling your home. We would unreservedly recommend Carl, Donna and Jordan if you're considering selling your home in the Turramurra, Pymble or Gordon area.

Seller review
I couldnt be happpier
almost 3 years ago
I couldnt be happpier

Carl, Donna, and their team were wonderful. They were on the ball completely and always supportive. They were very knowledgeable regarding the market and their advice re styling the house was exceptional. They kept me up to date with regular feedback and statistics after every open house I would like to thank Carl and Donna for their expertise, conscientiousness, support, and the excellent price they achieved for me. I feel very confident in highly recommending Carl to you.

Seller review
Highly recommend
almost 3 years ago
Highly recommend

Carl is knowledgeable, professional and thorough. He and the team obtained an outstanding result, highly recommend.

Seller review
Great experience
over 3 years ago
Great experience

When we first met Carl we felt immediately comfortable with him and that continued throughout the sale campaign and even after sale. He is very personable and easygoing but also displayed impressive knowledge of our market. It was a challenging sale given the market and the condition of our house but Carl and his team went above and beyond to market our place and came up with various strategies to ensure we sold. After our sale, he continued to be very supportive and went out of his way to assist us to try to find a new home in a different area. One thing in particular stood out to us about Carl, despite how busy he is, he treated us like we were his only client and was always quick to respond to our calls and messages. I would highly recommend him to any potential vendor in the area.

Seller review
Thank you Carl & Donna
over 3 years ago
Thank you Carl & Donna

Thank you Carl and Donna What a.team! Your professionalism and efficiency are outstanding! You are both thoughtful and kind and take everything in consideration down to the very last detail for both sides! Another Agent ? Wouldn't think of it! Thank you both!

Seller review
Amazing result, very quickly
over 3 years ago
Amazing result, very quickly

This is the second time for us, and on both occasions Carl and Donna have been amazing. Thsi time sold in 6 days, at our hoped-for price. Very thorough, honest, trustworthy and working so hard to achieve our goals. I cant imagine wanting to use any other agents. Thanks Carl; thanks Donna.

Buyer review
Exceptional
over 3 years ago
Exceptional

I am leaving this comment as a buyer and I rarely leave comments for anyone- but Carl and his team are just fantastic. Carl helped us to get our beautiful home in our desired location. He is upfront, has a great knowledge of market, build and renovations. Carl even helped us with securing tradesman to do work on time and with high quality. We have already discussed ideas on how we can improve our new home. The team's communication is second to none. They ultimately make sure all parties are happy with the outcome, unique to their business. I would highly recommend Carl and his team to any buyer, vendor and owner, you can trust you are in good hands.

Seller review
Clear and easy to understand advice
over 3 years ago
Clear and easy to understand advice

Carl and Donna always provide clear and easy to understand advice. Very accurate price guide and economical marketing campaign. All through the campaign, Carl and Donna’s advice was reassuring and very interpretive of the week to week inspection results. Very happy with the final result.

Buyer review
Reliable and Trustworthy!
over 3 years ago
Reliable and Trustworthy!

Dealing with Carl has been a seamless, honest and quick process. Carl was honest with us from day one and gave us valuable insight into the home and market conditions. We are grateful for the information shared which helped move the process along seamlessly. Carl is responsive and dynamic, he will support you to the very end well after the deal is done. It has been a pleasure working with him!

Buyer review
Great experience
over 3 years ago
Great experience

Carl was fantastic and friendly. Definitely made the experience more easier

37 - 48 of 128
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent