Cathy's profile

Cathy's reviews

  4.8  
Cathy has 310 reviewsacross 37 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Seller review
Very Positive
4 months ago
Very Positive

Cathy was always very positive, helpful and straightforward. I was kept up to date on any progress and felt that Cathy was always in my corner.

Seller review
I have dealt with Cathy and here team for a number of purchases and sales.
7 months ago
I have dealt with Cathy and here team for a number of purchases and sales.

Cathy and here team have always been nothing but amazing. They are always lovely and very professional. Cathy has been my go to for purchasers and sales for over 20 years now. Thank you Cathy & team for your hard work and support over the years. Marty

Seller review
Great job, sold before had to have an open house.
7 months ago
Great job, sold before had to have an open house.

Cathy was the ultimate professional. Always right on time, and called with any feedback from prospective buyers. She got us what we wanted with no fuss, just got on with the job. Place was sold quickly and quietly.

Seller review
Goes above and beyond what’s needed!
7 months ago
Goes above and beyond what’s needed!

Cath knew what we wanted and had someone in mind almost straight away. That in itself is amazing! She communicated at least once a day to let us know how things were going. As she has been in the real estate industry for quite a while, she was the ultimate professional. We are very happy with the results and I hope the new purchaser’s will love the place as much as we do!

Seller review
Cath was completely honest and upfront about...
7 months ago
Cath was completely honest and upfront about...

Cath was completely honest and upfront about what to expect when selling. We valued her advice and she gave us feedback from prospective buyers, good and bad! Our place sold quickly and we got pretty mush what we wanted! Could not be happier!

Buyer review
Belle Property Killcare - great team
8 months ago
Belle Property Killcare - great team

Cathy Baker is a good communicator, with a great and friendly team and lots of local knowledge which is helpful as well.

Buyer review
Simon was absolutely brilliant! 
Not just an...
8 months ago
Simon was absolutely brilliant! Not just an...

Simon was absolutely brilliant! Not just an agent looking for a sold sticker, but actually listened to me as a buyer moving from the city, gave me insights into the area and was available at any time to answer ALL of my questions.

Seller review
Brilliant all round service
10 months ago
Brilliant all round service

Cathy’s team performed so far above and beyond, presenting the property to all its advantages. Simon and Laura were a joy to work with, and achieved a good result in a difficult market. I have no hesitation recommending Belle Properties, and especially the team led by Simon and Laura, for selling properties in the Hardys Bay/Killcare area.

Seller review
Terrible Experience
10 months ago
Terrible Experience

Selling our home using Cathy Baker was an absolutely terrible experience.When voicing our concerns Cathy didn’t listen,from marketing to our availability to show our home at its best, also checking that the buyers were qualified , we felt she just let anyone in, which became disruptive and felt pointless.We lost total faith in Cathy’s ability to sell our home, communication broke down and the whole experience gave us anxiety. We would not recommend Cathy Baker under any circumstances

Seller review
Terrible Agent, Unfortunate Experience!
10 months ago
Terrible Agent, Unfortunate Experience!

My overall experience with Cathy was unsatisfactory. After experiencing lengthy delays by the buyer, as an incentive I suggested a price reduction of $20,000 only if the buyer exchanged by Thursday 5:00pm. This exchange did not take place on that day and no further communication by Cathy took place for period of 3 weeks. Against my word, Cathy facilitated the exchange much later at the reduced price and I forfeited $20,000 to get nothing in return. I found overall that Cathy never answered her phone. Professionalism was non existent. They were only on the side of the buyer, when I (the vendor) hired them. Also they advertised under my expected price. They didn’t answer my calls, only text message when they wanted to. I was not kept in the picture and overall the experience was horrendous.

1 - 12 of 310
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent