Craig's profile

Craig's reviews

  4.9  
Craig has 333 reviewsacross 22 different locations, showing 12.
Seller review
Made a stressful experience even worse.
over 8 years ago
Made a stressful experience even worse.

Smooth talker, promised the world. Communication was a major issue, he could go 5-7 days without answering or returning any messages. For a week prior to our open house the house was not advertised online, and despite bringing this to his attention, it took him another week to rectify it. He managed to push potential buyers away by having an indifferent and superior attitude to them. Offered a flexible rate, "seller to decide" upon completion of contract - he then deducted what he thought was appropriate and has refused to refund the difference. After all our negotiations with our buyer, he erroneously gave them the wrong contract to sign - ultimately rectified it when we realised. Despite the house selling after 6 months, overall Craig made the whole experience very stressful for us, and left a bitter aftertaste at the end. I would not recommend Craig Gardener.

Seller review
Excellent agent, highly recommended!
over 8 years ago
Excellent agent, highly recommended!

Craig found a buyer for our home within one week of it going on the market. He stayed in constant communication with us throughout the entire process, was extremely knowledgeable and prepared at all times. We’d recommend Craig in a heartbeat.

Seller review
Craig great agent with lots of relative local knowledge
over 8 years ago
Craig great agent with lots of relative local knowledge

Craig demonstrated lots of energy and drive. Most importantly he listened to exactly what you want with price, presentation and management of the sale processes. of course he offered sound advice and was splendidly supported by his sales associate Felicia Reith. Felicia offered the woman's perspective to the potential purchases. She provided an insight to prospective buyers and offered suggestions on potential uses for aspects of the home. She is a girl relatively new to the area with great flair and style to assist in presentation. Craig is a seasoned and experienced Real Estate Agent with a wealth of suggestions in presentation. We had a few open homes for the word to get around and my property was sold to the very first person that arranged a private appointment. How good is that ? Thank you Craig and Felicia .

Seller review
Excellent agent 10/10
over 8 years ago
Excellent agent 10/10

Excellent communication skills and knowledge of real estate business

Seller review
First class service
over 8 years ago
First class service

The help and assistance I received from both Craig and Felicia was exceptional.. They kept me informed throughout the entire process and the level of customer service I received was beyond my expectations. I would highly recommend utilising their knowledge, skill and expertise to anyone. Pete Ziesig

Seller review
Professional, knowledgeable and excellent agent!
over 8 years ago
Professional, knowledgeable and excellent agent!

We found Craig Gardner very professional and great to deal with. His communication was excellent at all times. We found him to have great knowledge and expertise when it came to marketing and selling our property. We would not hesitate to recommend Craig or to deal with him again in the future.

Seller review
Excellent local knowledge
almost 9 years ago
Excellent local knowledge

Craig and Felicia did a brilliant job of selling our house! They were professional, courteous at all times & communication was nothing short of excellent, keeping us updated at every step of the journey. Craig's knowledge of the local market was a real asset to us in selling our property & I cannot recommend him highly enough.

Seller review
Great Agent
almost 9 years ago
Great Agent

Craig was confident he could sell our property in the price bracket we were after and in the time frame we anticipated. We could contact him when needed and we received regular updates.We are very happy with the results.

Seller review
Great Agent
almost 9 years ago
Great Agent

Craig was very understanding in a very difficult area as my ex husband was not cooperating in selling the house Craig Gardener used great compassion and went beyond extreme limits to help me Very appreciative and forever greatful Sharyn Wrigley

Seller review
Best Agent in the district
almost 9 years ago
Best Agent in the district

Pleasantly suprised by their attitude, listened to me, suggested the advertising program, kept their appointments on time, and carefully vetted the prospective buyers, in such a short time we had a buyer, at the full asking price with a settlement period of 35 days. I would recommend Nolans and more particularly Craig Gardner and Felicia Rieth to market your home with the same professionalism they gave me. Beryl Burke

Buyer review
Understanding and Professional
almost 9 years ago
Understanding and Professional

Craig and Felicia are a very professional team demonstrating great integrity and honesty. In this instance Craig was very patient and accommodating of our position in buying this property. I would not hesitate to call Craig and Felicia if I were to sell a property in the future.

Buyer review
Overall we give this man 10/10
almost 9 years ago
Overall we give this man 10/10

We sold our home & then purchased a house from Craig. We still find it hard to believe that this has happened so efficiently, so professionally and stress-free. We are recommending Craig & Felicia to our family & friends.

277 - 288 of 333
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent