Donna's profile

Donna's reviews

  4.8  
Donna has 147 reviewsacross 15 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Buyer review
If you want honest, this is your agent
almost 3 years ago
If you want honest, this is your agent

I've been buying real estate for a very, very long time. So as far as agents are concerned, I've seen good, bad, and everything in between. Donna and Sue are honest, experienced, and actively look to help people. Highly recommended.

Seller review
SUE IS A LEGEND
almost 3 years ago
SUE IS A LEGEND

Had a great experience with Sue...she communicates well and it was a quick sale! Really pleased! Verified by RateMyAgent

Buyer review
Great agent
almost 3 years ago
Great agent

Great dealing with local agents on the island fast and informed

Seller review
Efficient, knowledgeable and informative
almost 3 years ago
Efficient, knowledgeable and informative

Donna was prompt with calls and return emails. When appointment times were set Donna was always on time, jovial and upbeat. Her knowledge of the Bay Islands and surrounds and property prices in and around the area is exceptional. Additionally as she lives on the islands helps to have her thumb on the pulse. Always honest and exceptionally pleasant to deal with. 2nd property i have sold via Donna and will use again when required without hesitation.

Seller review
9 bay drive
almost 3 years ago
9 bay drive

Just received a nasty surprise on settlement.the agreement with Donna was for commission only and now find $600 charge for advertising. Not happy at all quite deceptive.would think you will be correcting this matter John Dwyer

Buyer review
Quick sale.
about 3 years ago
Quick sale.

We cannot thank Donna enough on the quick sale of our house! So professional and down to earth. Thankyou so much. πŸ˜€

Seller review
Happy Outcome
about 3 years ago
Happy Outcome

At a tricky time for selling, Donna showed perseverance and determination. Her experience and professionalism were what drew me to choosing her for the sale of my unique property, and it proved invaluable. The advertising and brochures were wonderful. Very pleased with my experience with Donna and will happily recommend her to anyone looking at selling or buying on the islands.

Buyer review
Good communication and fair negotiation
about 3 years ago
Good communication and fair negotiation

Donna was acting on behalf of the seller (we are the buyers). She was very helpful supplying information, getting back to us in a timely manner and working through a fair negotiation on price.

Seller review
A professional Estate Agent who has assisted greatly in the sale of a unique property on Russel Isdi
about 3 years ago
A professional Estate Agent who has assisted greatly in the sale of a unique property on Russel Isdi

Donna Pinkerton was engaged to manage the sale process for land that our families had owned for many years on Russel Island. Although we the owners had researched a number of Agents in the Redlands Shire, one thing that directed us to utilize Donna was the fact she lives on the island and had, what we believed, to be the best local knowledge of the agents we contacted. She was very realistic in her market appraisal of the property, and of all the price guesstimates provided by the agents we canvassed, hers was the most accurate. She worked to overcome some issues in the final phases of the sales process and was proactive in the interface with the Buyers, Owners and their respective legal teams.

Seller review
Donna's handling of our property sale made it a great experience
about 3 years ago
Donna's handling of our property sale made it a great experience

Donna was knowledgeable, professional and best of all was actually approachable and willing to talk to us to answer questions and offer suggestions and solutions that suited our preferences. She listens (and returns calls promptly). Donna really worked hard for us in the final stages of sale negotiation and secured a good result for us.

73 - 84 of 147
SMS
Β© 2026 RateMyAgent