James' profile

James' reviews

  4.7  
James has 72 reviewsacross 12 different locations, showing 12.
over 9 years ago
Wow, a great result.

James and his wonderful team made a very difficult time so easy with their professional but very personal attention to detail. Their excellent presentation brought wonderful results for our family. Definitely five stars from us.

over 9 years ago
Sale of property

From our first meeting with James, Billy and Zack, it was clear that they were honest people and knew the market well. We wanted an agent that was going to give us genuine feedback about our house and how the campaign was going, and James and the Buxton team were able to meet our needs. They kept us up to date with reports, feedback, and how open inspections were going. On auction day, about 6 Buxton team members assisted with the sale of our house and successfully achieved a price we were happy with. Keep up the good work, James and the team!

over 9 years ago
Thanks James

We did our homework before signing with James to sell our family home. It was clear that James was No.1 in our area so the decision was not hard. We were impressed by James confidence and communication skills. He is surrounded you a great team at Buxtons. Thanks to Rachel who put in a big effort. Also, the Buxton team on the day of the auction worked so hard to get a good price for us. We'll done James and team.

over 9 years ago
James Karontonis - Buxton Ashburton

James not only did a brilliant job of selling my property, but also helped me negotiate the purchase of a new property in a completely different area. At all times he was available, supportive and professional and kept me fully informed. He is a skilled auctioneer, a kind person and at all times coducts himself with sincerity and integrity. I could not recommend anyone more highly.

over 9 years ago
Rating an agent

We found James to be a knowledgeable and honest agent, he conducted himself the utmost decorum. We were very happy with him and believe that has done a great job in selling our house for us. We hope that he has many years as a successful agent.

over 9 years ago
Ashwood home

James is both a fantastic agent and personable guy. As I was selling the family home in difficult circumstances, James was patient, caring and always reliable. James communication skills are of the highest level, which were extremely valuable during the sale campaign and at auction. James was always honest about achieving the results I wanted and with a great outcome on auction day, I can say he was very accurate in his predictions. Great outcome.

over 9 years ago
James Karatonis

James assisted me with a recent purchase prior to listing on the market. He nurtured a balanced and relaxed negotiation between myself and the vendor which resulted in an advantageous outcome for both parties. Thank you to the team at Buxton, namely also to Rachel and Jerry along with Bianca and Tina from property management.

over 9 years ago
Sale Experience

Thanks to James, but especially the hard work of Rachel and Billy in James absence. Really was not the opportunity for James to complete the sale, but I was amZed at the work Rachel and Billy put in. I had my nephew drown in my spa some years ago, sorry I refused a sign, it's a bad memory and selling my house certainly revived the memories. Hope the charges for advertising reflect the absence of a sign. I would always recommend Buxton.

almost 10 years ago
Sale of 8 Maroondah Road, Ashwood

James Karantonis and Brent McHugh were highly professional throughout the whole campaign. Brent took the lead whilst James was absent - we were very pleased with his professionalism and levels of communication. We were pleased with both representatives. best wishes, Kate Goodman

almost 10 years ago
Thanks James for a great result!

James conducted himself professionally at all times throughout our meetings prior to the sale of our property and on the day of the auction. He worked tirelessly to get the job done and at no point did we feel that he could've done more. We thank James and the Buxton team for their commitment and sincerity throughout the whole process.

about 10 years ago
James K - review

James went out of his way to sell the house, but also help us move into another place and provide recommendations and advice. If you want an agent you can actually trust - James is a good choice.

37 - 48 of 72
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent