Jay's profile

Jay's reviews

  4.9  
Jay has 563 reviewsacross 25 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Jay's qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, supportive, reliable, responsive, honest, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Eye for Detail .
over 3 years ago
Eye for Detail .

Jay came to our house to give us a market appraisal. The first thing I noticed was his keen eye for detail and his appreciation of the quality of work we had done. Jay has an easy going nature and although can have a joke he knows his business. He gave us an estimate in a changing market. Jay was five hundred dollars off what we got. Very impressive in a changing market.

Seller review
The Right Choice
over 3 years ago
The Right Choice

We knew after our first meeting with Jay, we were in safe hands. The knowledge and guidance he shared with us in preparation for the sale was well received. We were very happy with Jay's professionalism and commitment to selling our home.

Seller review
What a total legend.
over 3 years ago
What a total legend.

I contacted Jay to get an appraisal on my home and I was impressed with him from the very beginning. Jay was professional friendly and honest. He was upfront about what the value of my home would be, the fees involved and how they would market my home. He answered all my questions and reassured me that as I had already purchased another home interstate that he and his associates would do everything they could to ensure my home sold in a timely manner to enable me to have settlement in time for my purchase to be completed. My house sold one day after they listed it and at the very price I was told I would probably get for my home. To say I was impressed was an understatement. Jay is a total legend. He was approachable, compassionate and made the whole process effortless and easy. I would thoroughly recommend Jay to anyone contemplating selling their home. His knowledge of the area and the market was amazing and he was professional and friendly throughout the whole process. He made me feel like he valued my time and was also respectful of my situation. They say selling your home is one of the most stressful times in your life but Jay ensured that my sale from start to finish was a walk in the park. Thanks Jay as I said, you sir are a legend. I am a very happy vendor and I would highly recommend you to anyone.

Buyer review
Incredibly helpful for first home buyers
over 3 years ago
Incredibly helpful for first home buyers

Jay Cleary has been fantastic in helping us buy our first home. He is nothing short of helpful, professional, knowledgeable and caring; and is a true asset to the real estate world. He ensured we felt calm in the up and down process of purchasing our first home, and was essentially at our finger tips with every message, call or request we had. We would truly recommend him and Cleary Fairbrother to everyone.

Seller review
Sale of Property in Bathurst NSW
almost 4 years ago
Sale of Property in Bathurst NSW

Jay has excellent communication skills and great industry knowledge. I was kept in the loop at all stages of the sale and felt comfortable with the process. I have had an excellent experience selling through Jay, would recommend his agency to anyone.

Seller review
Good experience
almost 4 years ago
Good experience

Very good to deal with always kept me updated on how things were going and on different ways to market the house

Buyer review
A Great Experience
almost 4 years ago
A Great Experience

Jay made buying our house such a great experience. From the very first phone call Jay went out of his way to line things up for us. He went above and beyond with his communication throughout our buying experience. During our viewing of the house he was around to answer our questions but gave us plenty of privacy to let my partner and I discuss things. Jay is someone we would look to buying/selling a house with in the future.

Seller review
Valuable Service
almost 4 years ago
Valuable Service

Jay has been experienced and professional since him selling me this house in 2011. I had no hesitation in allowing him the opportunity to sell my house and he acted in a professional and experienced manner during the quite short marketing period.

Buyer review
Buyer of house
almost 4 years ago
Buyer of house

Very professional, great communication. I would highly recommend to everyone

Seller review
EXCELLENT RESULT
almost 4 years ago
EXCELLENT RESULT

Excellent result achieved by Jay in my property sale. Marketing was excellent and progress reports kept me well informed. Jay's interpersonal skills shone through in his dealings with prospective buyers, the resident tenant and of course me, the vendor. I would recommend his agency, Cleary and Fairbrother to anyone contemplating the sale of their property.

Seller review
Exceptional Service from Jay and Sandy
almost 4 years ago
Exceptional Service from Jay and Sandy

Selling our first home was a process we had never done before. Jay and Sandy worked very closely together and shared their market knowledge, experience, expertise and professionalism within the field and the result was above and beyond any expectations we ever had. Jay walked us through every step of the way and answered any queries and questions we had instantly. Our recommendation to go with Cleary Fairbrother Property Real Estate is 5/5. We’re extremely grateful for Jay and the team, the whole process made our experience very positive.

193 - 204 of 563
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent