Jay's profile

Jay's reviews

  4.9  
Jay has 589 reviewsacross 25 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Jay's qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, supportive, reliable, responsive, honest, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Amazing service and a highly-supportive real estate agent!
over 4 years ago
Amazing service and a highly-supportive real estate agent!

Jay was an excellent real estate agent for my partner and I. He had in-depth knowledge of the property we purchased and was punctual and prompt when delivering information we needed to know. My partner and I felt incredibly supported and cared for by Jay, and I would recommend him to anyone.

Seller review
Energy and enthusiasm unrivalled!
over 4 years ago
Energy and enthusiasm unrivalled!

We are very happy with our decision to go with Cleary Fairbrother to sell our Bathurst house most recently. Sandy and Jay make an excellent team. Jay, in particular, has an energy and enthusiasm that is unrivalled in the business. Communication was great and we felt well looked after. Jay values relationships with vendors and purchasers and works hard at this. Without doubt, this sold our place, super quickly and at the top of our price guide. We would highly recommend Cleary Fairbrother.

Buyer review
Excellent experience from initial inspection to purchase
over 4 years ago
Excellent experience from initial inspection to purchase

Jay Cleary was an excellent agent throughout the process of our property purchase. From the initial inspection to the completion of the sale, Jay could not have been more professional, helpful and honest. We felt very reassured by his regular communication and authenticity in his dealings with us. We would recommend Jay as an agent and would have no hesitation in working with him again.

Seller review
Sale of Property
over 4 years ago
Sale of Property

Very efficiently and quickly dealt with. Thanks Jay.

Seller review
Friendly, professional service
over 4 years ago
Friendly, professional service

Jay and Sandy were great when we sold our property - friendly, informative and very professional. Happy to recommend them to others.

Seller review
Highly recommended
over 4 years ago
Highly recommended

From the initial appraisal Jay inspired confidence and I felt relaxed leaving the sale in his hands. He was consistently available and proactive throughout the process and very pleasant to deal with, and his optimism was reassuring! Jay set a more ambitious price target than other appraisals I received and was able to deliver on it. Thanks Jay.

Seller review
Highly professional and determined!
over 4 years ago
Highly professional and determined!

We really appreciated Jay’s ambition and conviction for what was possible for the sale of our home. We trusted him and the Cleary Fairbrother Team to bring us a great result, and the outcome that they were able to achieve speaks volumes. We know Jay worked tirelessly in the background to garner interest and excitement and we really appreciate the thoughtful approach that was taken to sell our home.

Seller review
We are thrilled ...
over 4 years ago
We are thrilled ...

We are so thrilled with our experience of selling our 2 houses with Jay and Sandy. Sold 3-4 months apart, the first house sold in 2 days and the second in 3 days, each of them above the asking price. Jay and Sandy are professional agents and it all went so smoothly. We were able to upgrade to our 'forever home' in the sunshine. Thanks to you both and your team.

Seller review
Leading Real Estate Agent
over 4 years ago
Leading Real Estate Agent

We can't thank Jay enough for his ongoing support during & after the sale of our property. Jay's professionalism, constant communication & dedication to selling our house in a time sensitive manner is a true testament to him & his team.

Buyer review
Professional, fair and reliable
over 4 years ago
Professional, fair and reliable

Jay always presented and communicated professionally during our purchase, and always acted in a fair and transparent manner. Highly recommended.

253 - 264 of 589
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent