Jay's profile

Jay's reviews

  4.9  
Jay has 563 reviewsacross 25 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Jay's qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, supportive, reliable, responsive, honest, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Jay Jay! He's your man! if he can't do it! no one can!
over 4 years ago
Jay Jay! He's your man! if he can't do it! no one can!

Jay! My man!!👍 You have gone above and beyond to get the best result for Tim and I, With Super efficiency! We couldn't be happier with your transition from buying to selling with us throughout the many years! Truly professional, You have always been there for us too. It's a bit sad to go and we are really gona miss you Rachel Sandy, and Bathurst! "top spot for raising kids!" Your my good friend for ever now 👍🤣🤣👍 Beer on me🍺 next time I see ya! Love your work & Thanks a bunch! A.&T.Z

Seller review
Positive experience to sell through Jay
over 4 years ago
Positive experience to sell through Jay

Selling a property is a daunting process especially when it is your first time. The time, effort and commitment Jay has put into helping me with all aspects of my sale made the experience a smooth and enjoyable one. From answering lots of questions promptly no matter what time it was, to ensuring that I was always comfortable with the next steps and inspection processes. Jay made sure to not influence any of my decisions but provided non bias advice when asked. Jay’s experience as a real estate agent along with his approachable friendly personality, I believed makes him best in the game and one to trust to get you the best result.

Seller review
Colleen Stephenson
over 4 years ago
Colleen Stephenson

The whole process was conducted with calmness and was stress free. I would recommend the genuinely professional team of Jay and Sandy to anyone wishing to sell their property for the best outcome .

Seller review
Excellent result in volatile market
over 4 years ago
Excellent result in volatile market

Jay Cleary knew where the market was heading and set execellent goals for the sale of my property. From the first discussion to the exchange of contract he was there advising and working for the most wonderful outcome for me. His patience and understanding in my difficult situation was comforting and guiding. The marketing of my property was outstanding with the photos and videos of the highest level attracting the buyer to my property. The respect he paid for my personal decisions and space was outstanding. Thank you Jay

Buyer review
Thank you Jay.
over 4 years ago
Thank you Jay.

Jay continuously worked to find us the ‘right’ property and secured us a beautiful home for our family, which in the current market is not an easy process. Professional, friendly and prompt in returning calls! Huge Thankyou!

Buyer review
Best in the business!
over 4 years ago
Best in the business!

This was our second purchase through Jay. He is professional, personable and genuine. We cannot recommend him highly enough. By far the best in Bathurst. Thank you once again!

Seller review
A fantastic agent
over 4 years ago
A fantastic agent

Jay is a true realestate professional. His knowledge of the Bathurst market is incredible and this is reflected in his honest property appraisals. We have pruchased and sold multiple properties with Jay and wouldn't sell through anyone else.

Seller review
Very Happy
over 4 years ago
Very Happy

Sandy and Jay were very professional men to deal with. They were easy to talk to and I’m very happy with how they managed the sale of my property.

Seller review
Just fantastic
over 4 years ago
Just fantastic

Jay and the team did such a fantastic job throughout the whole sale process and I can’t thank them enough for the outcome achieved.

Seller review
Sale of our house at EGLINTON
over 4 years ago
Sale of our house at EGLINTON

Jay is an amazing person who got us through the sale of our house at Eglinton with a minimal stress. He is very knowledgeable and extremely approachable person and always got back to me with in the day. It was great that both Jay and Sandy work together very well. Nothing was a problem to him. I would highly recommend Jay from Cleary Fairbrother Property To anyone that is seeking to buy or sell their home. Thank you Jay for all you have done .

Seller review
Beyond our expectations
over 4 years ago
Beyond our expectations

Jay went above and beyond our expectations when selling our property, getting us the best possible outcome. Selling a property is daunting enough especially with the market being as competitive as it currently is, but Jay and his co-worker Sandy made it as easy and stress free as they possibly could, nothing was ever an issue and they were nothing but accomodating. I couldn’t recommend a real estate agent more

Seller review
Outstanding
over 4 years ago
Outstanding

From day one Jay kept me informed and guided me through the process! Jays professionalism and knowledge was outstanding. I wouldn’t hesitate to contact Jay in the future when buying or selling.

253 - 264 of 563
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent