Jay's profile

Jay's reviews

  4.9  
Jay has 569 reviewsacross 25 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Jay's qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, supportive, reliable, responsive, honest, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Professional and easy
almost 5 years ago
Professional and easy

Our end-to-end experience was made simple and successful with Jay's expert guidance and support to our needs. Thank you all

Seller review
Sale of 3 Ironbark Close Kelso
almost 5 years ago
Sale of 3 Ironbark Close Kelso

A friend recommended Jay and Sandy to me, they assisted her in buying her first home Jay and Sandy came and reviewed my house and agreed to list my house for Sale. They kept me informed on the progress of my house sale during the time my house was on the market. I was not living in Bathurst at this time and I felt fully supported and confident I was being looked after Thank you Jay and Sandy fir successfully selling my house

Seller review
Selling of my investment property
almost 5 years ago
Selling of my investment property

Jay was more then helpful. Very clear and concise, explained the whole process front to back. He kept me in the loop through the whole sale process and achieved a quick result which is what I was looking for. The best part was it sold for the money he recommended and personally I didn't think he could get. 10 stars all round

Buyer review
Very good Agent
almost 5 years ago
Very good Agent

Very good Negotiation skill and take care of both parties, Win - Win

Seller review
Professional with good market knowledge
almost 5 years ago
Professional with good market knowledge

More than happy with the service that was provided to me. Jay is easy to talk to & kept in touch with updates throughout the whole process. Jay was very professional and informative and I feel he went over and above to make sure all went well. I have no hesitation in recommending Jay to anyone who is looking to sell their property.

Seller review
Friendly Service and Prompt Response
almost 5 years ago
Friendly Service and Prompt Response

We dealt with Jay Cleary during the sale campaign of our property and were delighted with his friendly attitude and great communication. We are certain these traits were also experienced by potential buyers that Jay showed through our property, and we were ecstatic with the result. Many thanks to Jay Cleary and Sandy Fairbrother at Smile Elite. What a great team.

Buyer review
Great Service
almost 5 years ago
Great Service

Working with Jay to purchase our property was very easy despite some challenges of purchasing during covid. Jay kept us informed as we moved thru the process.

Buyer review
The Process Was Smooth Sailing
almost 5 years ago
The Process Was Smooth Sailing

Jay was a pleasure to deal with and made what can be a stressful time a calm smooth experience.

Buyer review
The Process Was Smooth Sailing
almost 5 years ago
The Process Was Smooth Sailing

Jay was clear and consistent with communication and efficient when it came to managing the paperwork. Thanks very much for making it such an easy process.

Buyer review
Professional
almost 5 years ago
Professional

Jay was very easy to deal with, openly communicated with us and explained each step and the likely timeframes for when feedback would be provided. He didn't rush us or apply pressure to this very important decision.

Seller review
Fantastic service
almost 5 years ago
Fantastic service

This was the third house we have sold with Jay and once again he went above and beyond to secure a smooth sale and excellent price for our home. Jay always provides fantastic expertise, knowledge and service. We would gladly recommend him to our friends and family.

Buyer review
Jay was great
almost 5 years ago
Jay was great

Jay was great, he kept us up to date with the sale process and was able to answer any questions we had.

289 - 300 of 569
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent