Jay's profile

Jay's reviews

  4.9  
Jay has 589 reviewsacross 25 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Jay's qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, supportive, reliable, responsive, honest, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Very happy customer
almost 6 years ago
Very happy customer

Jay's friendly and professional help and care towards my purchasing 25 Macquarie Street was and is much appreciated.

Seller review
Great agent, don't go elsewhere
almost 6 years ago
Great agent, don't go elsewhere

Jay was not my first choice in Bathurst as I was led down the garden path by whom I thought was the best local agent but after a disastrous experience, I decided to switch to Jay and he saved the day. Jay was consistently a pleasure to deal with, always updating as to what's going on with the property and working hard to achieve the desired result.

Seller review
sale of relocatable home in Eglinton
almost 6 years ago
sale of relocatable home in Eglinton

Jay displayed a good knowledge of the product and knew what market to target he always informed me of progress on my sale and had the ability to liaise with all involved from solicitors to brokers , council , purchaser and vendor making for a successful result

Buyer review
Jay found me my perfect home
almost 6 years ago
Jay found me my perfect home

When looking for my forever home. Jay listened to my wants and needs and set off to find my perfect new home. I am so happy to say he found it. He was prompt in the negotiation process and was keeping me updated as things were happening. Jay is a true professional and I am so happy that he found me my perfect home.

Buyer review
Fantastic, pleasure to deal with
almost 6 years ago
Fantastic, pleasure to deal with

Jay was very professional and down to earth he always kept me up to date with how my purchase was going. I would highly recommend Jay to anyone looking to buy and sell a property.

Seller review
Exceeded expectations
almost 6 years ago
Exceeded expectations

From our very first meeting it was clear that Jay and Sandy are industry experts on every level and have integrity in everything they do. The point of difference lies in their easy communication, genuine authenticity and absolute passion. Follow up communication throughout the process is really important to me and Jay had that covered with keeping me informed every step of the way. If you're looking to buy or sell, I cant recommend these two gentlemen enough. Choosing them as your agent makes the whole process smooth and stress free!

Seller review
Communication was the key
almost 6 years ago
Communication was the key

Jay spent alot of time with myself and my partner in the lead up to the sale of my house, which reassured us that we were selling with the right person. He provided very personalised service and we didn't feel like we were just another house on the list to sell like we had with other real estates in the past. By far, his communication was the best part of the experience. I would definitely recommend his services to my family and friends

Buyer review
Buying my dream piece of land.
almost 6 years ago
Buying my dream piece of land.

Buying a property usually is a daunting process as you need to be 100% sure that the property you put your interest on will fit your needs. This process was exciting and comfortable as I had Jay's honest, friendly and professional approach to his work. Jay responded honestly and patiently to all my questions without putting pressure into sealing the deal which gave me the confidence I needed to make my final decision. I am grateful that I had his support in regards of external information related to the land that made process relaxed and enjoyable. Thank you Jay for everything, Beatriz

Seller review
Jay was very professional and knowledgeable and made the process a breeze
almost 6 years ago
Jay was very professional and knowledgeable and made the process a breeze

After enquiring with several agents to list my home, I decided to go with Jay as he was by far the most professional and knowledgeable. Jay explained everything to me and guided me through the process. Nothing was too much trouble, and Jay was always available to answer any questions. After selling my home, Jay listened to all of my wishes and requests and found me the perfect home to purchase. I would recommend Jay to anyone who is looking at buying or selling.

Buyer review
Jay is an outstanding agent
almost 6 years ago
Jay is an outstanding agent

Jay Cleary is an outstanding real estate agent to deal with. He has a friendly and honest approach with all matters and every meeting with him has been helpful, pleasant and reassuring. Jay has extensive knowledge of the Bathurst real estate market and he was efficient and sincere in everything did for us. He was patient, considerate and understanding of our needs and we were impressed with how prompt and professional he was with all matters. It has been an absolute pleasure working with him. His colleague, Sandy Fairbrother, is the same. We are very happy with our experience with Jay and highly recommend him to anyone wanting to buy or sell in Bathurst.

Seller review
I bought a block of land from Jay 6 years ago
almost 6 years ago
I bought a block of land from Jay 6 years ago

Jay has a sound knowledge of the Bathurst housing market. He has always been extremely easy to deal with. He is very professional and always keeps me informed of the proceedings whether it be buying or selling.

Seller review
Great agent
almost 6 years ago
Great agent

After speaking to a few agents, Jay stood out and we were glad we trusted him with the sale. He had great local knowledge, was friendly, honest, reliable and kept us extremely well informed during the process. His communication was excellent and we gained a fantastic result, getting the full asking price in a very quick turn around. Couldn't be happier and would definitely use Jay as an agent in the future

397 - 408 of 589
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent