Jay's profile

Jay's reviews

  4.9  
Jay has 563 reviewsacross 25 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Jay's qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, supportive, reliable, responsive, honest, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Awesome agent
over 5 years ago
Awesome agent

We have just purchased our 2nd home and Jay happened to be the same agent we brought our 1st home off 3 years ago. Jays local knowledge of the Bathurst area shows in all aspects of his work, he is always approachable and available. We found his level of service to be above and beyond. We were lucky to have a 2nd seamless 0urchase with Jay and highly recommended him to all friends and family

Seller review
Look No Further! You've Found THE Best Agent!!
over 5 years ago
Look No Further! You've Found THE Best Agent!!

From the initial meeting at the house through to the final hand shake, Jay Cleary is BY FAR the best real estate agent in the region. Jay's understanding of the market, the knowledge of the area and his confident disposition ensures that any seller (or buyer, for that matter) will have complete satisfaction with the sale (or purchase) of their properties. Jay was always in constant communication with me made the job of selling my home so easy. Jay not only understands the market, but the direction in which property sales are taking. He is not only honest and up-front with his thoughts of how to promoe the sale of my property, but also easily approachable when asked questions as to the steps involved in the sale. Without any doubt I would highly recommend Jay Cleary for any and all who are considering buying or selling in the Bathurst, NSW area. You will not find a more professional, honest person in the field!

Buyer review
Straight up bloke
over 5 years ago
Straight up bloke

Was very straight forward let me know what I needed to know and help me by viewing later after work hours

Buyer review
Outstanding Experience
over 5 years ago
Outstanding Experience

Jay was a pleasure to deal with. He made the often nerve racking experience of buying a home pleasant and fuss free. Would recommend- Honest, professional and patient.

Seller review
Good result in a difficult market
over 5 years ago
Good result in a difficult market

With so many block of land for sale, many within the same estate, this sale was tough going. Jay persisted over an extended period of time to ensure we achieved a sale at a price we were happy with. Thanks again Jay - my first choice agent in the Bathurst region for nearly 15 years!

Seller review
Best in the business
over 5 years ago
Best in the business

Jay has delieved on everything he said he would, and more, from the first meeting I had with both Jay and Sandy they gave me great confidence that they were the right team for our sale, both men are very switched on to the local real estate market and their experienced marketing strategy saw constant inquiries and inspections the day after the property was listed, both Jay and Sandy kept me informed throuout and made the whole process relaxed and stress free. Thank you Cleary Fairbrother for you outstanding service. I will recommend to all.

Buyer review
Jay has been extremely helpful throughout the whole process. Easy to communicate with no pressure.
over 5 years ago
Jay has been extremely helpful throughout the whole process. Easy to communicate with no pressure.

We found Jay to be exceptionally helpful from the very beginning of our home hunting journey. Extremely easy to communicate with and prompt to answer all emails and phone calls. Nothing was a trouble (even walked through mud holding the end of a tape measure) would highly recommend Jay to anyone looking to purchase. Thank you for helping us find our beautiful new home.

Seller review
Amazing!!!
over 5 years ago
Amazing!!!

Jay was awesome to work with! Down to earth, fun and knowledgeable! He kept us in the loop through the whole process and offered advice when we needed it. Highly recommend Cleary Fairbrother Real Estate.

Buyer review
Very pleasant experience
almost 6 years ago
Very pleasant experience

Jay was very attentive and easy to deal with. He made the process as fair and transparent as possible and gained a good result for everyone. Would happily recommend Jay for any buying or selling of property.

Seller review
Excellent service!
almost 6 years ago
Excellent service!

Jay brought us amazing results. The property was sold within 4 days at above asking price. He was very professional.

Buyer review
Good old fashioned service
almost 6 years ago
Good old fashioned service

Since looking for an investment property, Sandy has been nothing but a pleasure to work with. From organising viewings for ourselves and tradesmen, through to completing the sale, every step along the way has been simple. Being able to explain what we were looking for and why and getting honest feedback was appreciated and communication lines are always open with Sandy. Dealing with banks, solicitors and real estate agents is never easy but Sandy made his role straightforward and easy to deal with. Couldn't be happier with the service we received from Sandy and Smile Elite Bathurst

397 - 408 of 563
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent