Natalie's profile

Natalie's reviews

  5  
Natalie has 89 reviewsacross 12 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Natalie's qualities as told by our client reviews: well-prepared, responsive, dedicated, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
The hardest working agent around!
9 days ago
The hardest working agent around!

Natalie absolutely could not of done more for us selling our home. Nat has gone above and beyond the entire time our home was for sale. Nat always reassured me, through all my emotional highs and lows. She works tirelessly for her vendors and gets the best possible results. Nat's communication keeping us in the loop every step of the way really helped with this whole process. We truly appreciate every weekend you gave up for us showing our home sometimes multiple times in a day and every late night you spent still working and following up with calls. Thank you so much Nat not just an incredible agent but lucky enough to call my friend now too!

Buyer review
Beyond Compare
16 days ago
Beyond Compare

During a process that could be disconnected and transactional, Nat rises above to provide an unrivalled level of service. With each step, Nat authentically connects with you, ensuring the partnership flourishes through sincere trust and deep respect. Nat possesses an exceptional ability to leverage her deep real estate knowledge while also communicating in a manner that is accessible, detailed and purposeful. In Nat, you have a phenomenal individual who employs consistently high-levels of communication, bringing peace of mind as you travel your real estate journey. As a family, we cannot recommend Nat highly enough. She is relatable, dependable and most importantly, an outstanding member of our local Tatura community.

Seller review
Excellent Real Estate Agent
25 days ago
Excellent Real Estate Agent

Tatura is so lucky to have a Real Estate Agent like Natalie Kay. She goes above and beyond anyone would ever expect She loves her job and shows it so many ways If it wasn't for Natalie working so hard with other Agents and Conveyancers our sale would not have got across the line, she has a great personality and relates to your situation with compassion and dedication If you are thinking of selling give Natalie a go, she will work so hard for you

Buyer review
Natalie goes above and beyond in every sense. She is undoubtedly the best in the business.
about 1 month ago
Natalie goes above and beyond in every sense. She is undoubtedly the best in the business.

Natalie went above and beyond to ensure the entire process of purchasing this home was as smooth and stress-free as possible for our grandfather. She wore many hats throughout the process, going far beyond what was expected to ensure everything was taken care of and that we had nothing to worry about. More than just helping him purchase a home, Natalie has played a huge part in bringing our grandfather back home after 10 years of living interstate. For our family, that means more than we could ever put into words. We will be forever grateful to Natalie for her dedication, compassion and everything she has done for our family. She has truly made this journey incredibly special, and we could not recommend her highly enough.

Seller review
Fantastic realestate knowledge.
about 1 month ago
Fantastic realestate knowledge.

Natalie was very professional, Always very punctual, Keep us informed of any enquiries, Very good negotiation knowledge. I would recommend her to anyone wanting to sell their property.

Buyer review
Easy to deal with and got the job done.
about 2 months ago
Easy to deal with and got the job done.

We were incredibly impressed by Natalie Kay’s exceptional market knowledge throughout the home-buying process. Their deep understanding of market trends and the real estate industry helped us make informed decisions at every stage. We truly felt we had the best realtor guiding us through the process, ensuring we got the best deal on our dream home.

Seller review
 Professional, knowledgable, transparent and hard working.
about 2 months ago
Professional, knowledgable, transparent and hard working.

At our time of sale, we looked at a few agents to sell our property. We decided to go with Natalie and are 100% pleased with our choice of agent. Natalie was prompt and professional and set things in motion straight away. She kept us informed and went above and beyond to promote our property with the photo shoot, advertising and open homes. We received weekly updates and trusted her to know her market. We are very pleased with our sale and outcome and thank her for her assistance, professionalism and commitment.

Seller review
Best agents in Rushworth area
3 months ago
Best agents in Rushworth area

Natalie Kay and Janelle Puppa Real Estate were professional from the outset and always punctual. Tenacious in pursuing the sale of my unique property being in a very specialised market. Highly recommend Natalie Kay if you are selling your historical property.

Buyer review
Agent with a huge heart & awesome personality
3 months ago
Agent with a huge heart & awesome personality

Natalie has made buying our dream home so easy, always there on the end of the phone at any time, we couldn’t have asked for a better experience and highly recommend Natalie for anyone looking for an agent with heart!

1 - 12 of 89
SMS
Β© 2026 RateMyAgent