Natalie's profile

Natalie's reviews

  5  
Natalie has 84 reviewsacross 12 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Natalie's qualities as told by our client reviews: responsive, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Easy to deal with and got the job done.
6 days ago
Easy to deal with and got the job done.

We were incredibly impressed by Natalie Kay’s exceptional market knowledge throughout the home-buying process. Their deep understanding of market trends and the real estate industry helped us make informed decisions at every stage. We truly felt we had the best realtor guiding us through the process, ensuring we got the best deal on our dream home.

Seller review
 Professional, knowledgable, transparent and hard working.
13 days ago
Professional, knowledgable, transparent and hard working.

At our time of sale, we looked at a few agents to sell our property. We decided to go with Natalie and are 100% pleased with our choice of agent. Natalie was prompt and professional and set things in motion straight away. She kept us informed and went above and beyond to promote our property with the photo shoot, advertising and open homes. We received weekly updates and trusted her to know her market. We are very pleased with our sale and outcome and thank her for her assistance, professionalism and commitment.

Seller review
Best agents in Rushworth area
about 1 month ago
Best agents in Rushworth area

Natalie Kay and Janelle Puppa Real Estate were professional from the outset and always punctual. Tenacious in pursuing the sale of my unique property being in a very specialised market. Highly recommend Natalie Kay if you are selling your historical property.

Buyer review
Agent with a huge heart & awesome personality
about 1 month ago
Agent with a huge heart & awesome personality

Natalie has made buying our dream home so easy, always there on the end of the phone at any time, we couldn’t have asked for a better experience and highly recommend Natalie for anyone looking for an agent with heart!

Buyer review
Excellent experience - smooth & straightforward
about 2 months ago
Excellent experience - smooth & straightforward

Working with Nat has made this sale go smoothly without any hiccups whatsoever. As a buyer's agent, we appreciate Nat's transparency and clear communication, and how easy it was to contact her. It is clear that Nat is highly knowledgeable, experienced and has vendor's best interests in mind too. Thank you Nat, we look forward to working together more often in the future.

Seller review
Excellent in all aspects
2 months ago
Excellent in all aspects

This is the second time iv had the privilege of Nat selling my properties and once again Nat went above and beyond to meet all our needs and achieve a great price. Nat’s local knowledge and expertise makes the whole selling experience a very pleasant one.

Buyer review
Highly recommend if selling
3 months ago
Highly recommend if selling

Natalie went above and beyond for us and made selling our house a breeze. Couldn't recommend her enough. She knows how to get the best money for your house and keeps you in the loop every time there is a update. Made buying and selling our other house effortless

Buyer review
Wonderful agent with great communication
3 months ago
Wonderful agent with great communication

Natalie was fantastic to deal with and gave us the confidence to trust her throughout the process. She's knowledgeable, honest and responsive with great insight into the market, and her professionalism made the experience stress-free.

1 - 12 of 84
SMS
Β© 2026 RateMyAgent