Nicole McCarthy

Nicole McCarthy

Licensed Real Estate Agent at RT Edgar Rye
  •   4.9   (166 reviews)

About Nicole

Nicole is a real estate professional who has a passion for property and people. Her years of experience with interior design; construction project management and property presentation enables Nicole to provide a unique combination of skills which support both vendors and buyers. By consistently demonstrating her ability to connect with people and establish nurturing relationships, Nicole has established a solid reputation built on respect; values and trust with her clients. Her unsurpassed fundamental understanding of the importance of property presentation ultimately ensures that her clients receive outstanding results every time. Nicole offers a service well above the highest standards of professionalism, conveying the crucial ingredients of communication and negotiating which are both her forte. Nicole is married to Hayden with four children, and has lived on the Peninsula for 18 years. Outside of Real Estate Nicole enjoys time with her family & friends.

Nicole's reviews

  4.9  
Nicole has 166 reviewsacross 14 different locations, showing 6.
Review Nicole
over 2 years ago
Informed & very efficient

Nicole was great to deal with. Her knowledge of the area and efficiency in communication allowed us to make an informed decision. Thanks Nicole!

over 2 years ago
Excellent

Nicole is lovely to deal with, from the moment we began our journey with her, she always went above and beyond for us. Cannot thank Nicole enough for her professionalism, hard work and ongoing support! Her local knowledge & recommendations were very helpful. Highly recommend Nicole. 🤩

over 2 years ago
10/10 - A breath of fresh air!

We have dealt with many real estate agents over the years and Nicole is a breath of fresh air and an absolute pleasure to deal with. From the onset Nicole always made herself available and was quick to follow-up, nothing was ever too much trouble. At all times we felt fully informed on both the property and local market. She also has a keen eye for detail and has a lot of tips on building/design ideas to pass on. Nicole is friendly, pro-active and honest with her feedback. She created a scenario which helped make the buying process as stressfree as possible. Big thank you to Nicole!

over 2 years ago
What can I say...the best!

Thank you just doesn't seem enough for the effort Nicole put into the sale of our investment property, she definitely went above and beyond! We couldn't thank her enough!

over 2 years ago
Purchase of home in Rye

From the moment we contacted Nicole about our interest in relation to the property to the date of settlement, nothing was a problem she was amazing. Her knowledge of the area, professionalism, honesty and dedication is unsurpassed. She was wonderful to deal with and we would most definitely recommend her to anyone whether it be to purchase or sell on the peninsula. She was wonderful and took the stress out of what would normally be a very stressful time, for that we thank her very much.

Show all 166 reviews

Nicole's properties

Nicole has 1 property for sale and sold 1 property in the last 12 months, showing 2, sorted by most recent activity

SoldNov 2, 2025
For Sale
$490,000 - $539,000
7 Korowa Street
Rye VIC 3941
Land
Show all 2 properties
EmailSMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent