Nicole's profile

Nicole's reviews

  4.9  
Nicole has 193 reviewsacross 27 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Nicole's qualities as told by our client reviews: responsive, supportive, hard-working, friendly, honest, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Five Stars
over 1 year ago
Five Stars

Nicole has incredible knowledge of the St Kilda/St Kilda East market. She is an excellent negotiator and knows how to get the best price possible. She kept me updated and I felt that she genuinely cared about getting my property sold and making me feel comfortable every step of the way. She’s also just a great human!

Seller review
We highly recommend Nicole if you are considering selling your home.
over 1 year ago
We highly recommend Nicole if you are considering selling your home.

Nicole is extremely professional with exceptional knowledge and expertise of the local real estate market. She guided us throughout the entire process of selling our home, devising a strategy that resulted in the quick sale of our home. She kept us well informed throughout the entire process. We highly recommend Nicole if you are considering selling your home.

Seller review
Nicole and her team were fantastic!
over 1 year ago
Nicole and her team were fantastic!

So professional and lovely to deal with. She went above and beyond to sell my property, we got a great result. I would highly recommend her.

Seller review
Nicole Prime is an outstanding realtor!
over 1 year ago
Nicole Prime is an outstanding realtor!

If you're looking for a real estate agent who is professional, knowledgeable, and results-driven, I cannot recommend Nicole Prime highly enough. Nicole recently helped me navigate the sale of my property, and her expertise and dedication made the entire process seamless and stress-free. From the outset, Nicole impressed me with her deep understanding of the local market in St Kilda and surrounding areas. Her ability to provide clear, data-driven insights gave me confidence in setting the right price and developing a tailored sales strategy. Nicole's attention to detail and proactive communication ensured I was informed every step of the way, which was incredibly reassuring. What sets Nicole apart is her exceptional customer service. She is approachable, friendly, and genuinely cares about her clients' needs. Throughout the process, she took the time to listen to my concerns and answer my questions with patience and clarity. Her professionalism extended to her interactions with potential buyers as well—she was an excellent negotiator who worked tirelessly to secure the best possible outcome. Working with Nicole was an absolute pleasure. She combines expertise with a personal touch that makes you feel valued throughout the process. Whether you're buying or selling, you can trust Nicole Prime to go above and beyond to achieve your goals. I would not hesitate to recommend her to anyone seeking a top-tier real estate professional!

Seller review
I was blown away by the level of detail.
over 1 year ago
I was blown away by the level of detail.

Nicole goes above and beyond to make sure you're happy with the end result. I was blown away by the level of detail. Nothing was a problem, ever. Her Team are just so professional and make the whole process stress free. I'm absolutely wrapped. Thank you. Such an incredible hard working team. Do not go anywhere else, these are your Team. Trust me. The best.

Seller review
Massive thank you to Nicole and her team.
over 1 year ago
Massive thank you to Nicole and her team.

Myself and my husband would like to acknowledge our amazing sales agent Nicole Prime. We just sold our unit off market, in record time. We are so pleased and thankful that we decided to go with Nicole to manage the whole process. Nicole was very professional right from the beginning. Her interpersonal skills and professionalism helped in establishing a rapport from our first conversation. Nicole has a vast industry knowledge and her specific industry insights helped us to confidently make our decisions throughout the process. Nicole kept us updated in every step of the process and ultimately achieved the desired outcome. We would like to say a massive thank you to Nicole and her team.

Seller review
Nicole did an excellent job
over 1 year ago
Nicole did an excellent job

Nicole did an excellent job selling my apartment. She gave me great confidence in mandating her as the agent after having done my due diligence with 6 realtors at different agencies. I live interstate and Nicole helped manage the entire pre sale preparation process and arranged for a stylist to furnish the apartment to accentuate the history and quirkiness maximizing on the unique charm and character of the place. We sold the unit prior to auction for a very good result.

Seller review
Five Stars
over 1 year ago
Five Stars

We just wanted to thank you for doing a great job in selling our property. You achieved a fantastic result and it was an absolute pleasure doing business with you.

Buyer review
Went above and beyond
over 1 year ago
Went above and beyond

Nicole was spectacular- went above and beyond. Top service and knowledgeability of the property- felt really privileged to be dealing with her

Seller review
Nicole was fantastic
over 1 year ago
Nicole was fantastic

Nicole was fantastic, her knowledge and suggestions on staging and marketing got us a quick sale for the price we where after. We would like to highly recommend Nicole and McGrath Real Estate for their professionalism from the beginning to the end.

Seller review
Excellent work.
over 1 year ago
Excellent work.

Nicole made our house sale a positive experience and not too painful at all! We’d been in our home for 30+ years. Nicole was very sensitive to the memories, emotions and the effort it took for us to make the decision and sell. Nicole nursed us through the whole process and was sensitive to our particular needs and situation. Nicole is totally discreet, professional and hard working. I’d be back to her if I was selling again. Thank you, Nicole!!

Seller review
Speedy, friendly and professional
over 1 year ago
Speedy, friendly and professional

Nicole had an excellent knowledge of the local market. Speedy, friendly and professional, I highly recommend Nicole and the team at McGrath.

37 - 48 of 193
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent