Paul's profile

Paul's reviews

  5  
Paul has 30 reviewsacross 11 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Paul's qualities as told by our client reviews: honest, supportive, friendly, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Paul was an absolute standout to work with.
5 months ago
Paul was an absolute standout to work with.

During a very stressful and constantly changing process, he was consistently supportive and reassuring. His clear communication and genuine care made a huge difference — he always checked in, offered guidance, and took the time to ensure I felt confident and informed. His calm, empathetic approach eased the pressure and turned a challenging experience into a far more positive and manageable one.

Buyer review
Buyer of a apartment in Cheltenham, VIC
6 months ago
Buyer of a apartment in Cheltenham, VIC

Paul was great! Sale well conducted and fair. Kept us in the loope as we progressed and seamless settlement. Great stuff. Thanks Paul

Seller review
An outstanding result!!!
6 months ago
An outstanding result!!!

My brother and I had an outstanding experience with Paul Allica from Ray White Bayside. Paul’s professionalism and market knowledge kept us confident throughout. He was approachable, responsive, and truly invested, making the process seamless. We were thrilled with the final price, which far exceeded our expectations. Paul is a great guy to work with and we highly recommend him. He’ll definitely be our first call for our next property!

Buyer review
Buyer of a apartment in Highett
6 months ago
Buyer of a apartment in Highett

Paul is a great communicator and professional. He has knowledge but also backs up what he promises, which is refreshing! I was super disappointed that I had missed out on a property due to it going for a higher price, and Paul was right onto it and found me a “better” apartment in the end. It’s been a smooth and still communicative transition so far. Super happy with my dealings with Paul

Seller review
Seller of apartment in Highett
6 months ago
Seller of apartment in Highett

Paul was indomitable. We put in an initial enquiry to sell our Highett 2 bedroom 2 bathroom apartment, just wanting to get a feel for the process, and he had potential buyers on the phone immediately. These potential buyers then materialised into off-market inspections, and before we even listed the property online we had sold for an amount with which we were ecstatic. Whole thing took 2 weeks from our first call. Paul also really cares about getting it right for the buyer. Paul is your man.

Seller review
Professional, reliable and incredibly approachable
7 months ago
Professional, reliable and incredibly approachable

We had an amazing experience selling our home thanks to our real estate agent Paul. From the beginning he was professional, reliable and incredibly approachable. He always made himself available, even working after hours, to ensure everything went smoothly and to achieve the best possible result for us. His communication was excellent throughout the entire process. He kept us informed at every step and made what could have been a stressful time feel easy and relax. We highly recommend Paul.

Buyer review
Buyer of a unit in Highett
7 months ago
Buyer of a unit in Highett

I only met Paul briefly prior to auction, but he was warm, friendly, professional and knowledgeable. Since I’ve bought the house, he’s been very helpful in answering any questions and always quick to respond. I highly recommend him.

Seller review
Seller of a apartment in Cheltenham, Vic
7 months ago
Seller of a apartment in Cheltenham, Vic

Paul worked day and night to get our property sold. He regularly gave feedback and updates so we always knew where we were at. Happy with his work and happy with the result. Thanks Paul.

Seller review
Selling with Paul was an absolutely fabulous experience, especially as I was feeling overwhelmed!
7 months ago
Selling with Paul was an absolutely fabulous experience, especially as I was feeling overwhelmed!

I cannot recommend Paul Allica, highly enough. From the very beginning, he was professional, proactive and incredibly knowledgeable about the local area and market. His expertise and savvy approach gave me immediate confidence that I was in trustworthy and capable hands. He went above and beyond in organising high-quality trades to ensure my property was presented in its very best light. Every contact he recommended was reliable and delivered excellent work, which made the preparation process seamless and far less stressful than I had anticipated. Throughout the campaign, he organised many inspections and maintained consistent, clear communication. He struck the perfect balance — keeping me informed every few days with updates and requests, without ever overwhelming me. His communication style was genuine, sincere and supportive, and I always felt respected and heard. What truly stood out was his transparency and integrity. His negotiation skills were strong, honest and transparent, and he carefully worked through all possible outcomes with me so I had time to process each step and make informed decisions. I never felt pressured — only fully supported. The turnaround from listing to sale was impressively quick, yet at no point did I feel rushed. He remained calm, professional and strategic throughout the entire process. If you are looking for a communicative, knowledgeable, trustworthy and highly capable agent who genuinely cares about achieving the best result for you, I would wholeheartedly recommend him. I am a very grateful seller.

Seller review
Seller of a apartment
8 months ago
Seller of a apartment

Paul achieved a great result for me, he listened, was transparent and communicated throughout the whole process. He was also very knowledgeable about the area and did not leave a stone unturned.

Seller review
Seller of a apartment
8 months ago
Seller of a apartment

Seemed to have an extensive knowledge of the market. He’s a clear and confident communicator. Clearly a dedicated hard worker who consistently kept us in the loop and responded to queries promptly. The high level of enthusiasm and confidence meant that we could trust him with the sale.

13 - 24 of 30
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent