Penny Timothy

Penny Timothy

  •   5   (21 reviews)

About Penny

Penny Timothy has a well-deserved reputation as one of the leading agents in Elizabeth Bay / Potts Point. Penny has an in depth knowledge of the local area and an innovative, businesslike approach to marketing. The results can be seen in Penny's record-breaking sales across the spectrum of property styles in this eclectic village, including multi-million dollar terraces and whole floor apartments. Penny understands the needs of owner-occupiers and investors alike. Penny has a unique combination of dedication and professionalism, combined with a gift for identifying the potential in every client’s property. As a resident owner, Penny has served as both Treasurer on a Strata Body Corporate in Potts Point and as a Company Title Board Member in Elizabeth Bay. Property is Penny’s great passion and on a personal level she has renovated and sold several homes and is an active participant in the running of the Art Deco building where she lives in the heart of Elizabeth Bay. https://www.pennytimothy.com/

Penny's reviews

  5  
Penny has 21 reviewsacross 5 different locations, showing 6.
Review Penny
Seller review
Exceeded our expectations
7 months ago
Exceeded our expectations

Penny achieved a price for our Unit that was above our expectations. She is extremely knowledgeable of the Potts Point / Elizabeth Bay property market. Not only that but she was fantastic to deal with and her suggested approach to the selling campaign was highly successful. We absolutely recommend Penny to anyone wishing to sell their property.

Seller review
An excellent experience
over 4 years ago
An excellent experience

I would urge anyone considering selling to speak first to Penny Timothy. She had an excellent knowledge of the value of my property and exactly where it sat in the marketplace and a clear sales strategy that was well communicated from the outset. She delivered exactly what she promised, and more. The marketing process was smooth and she had great recommendations when I required legal advice. Penny is very easy to deal with, experienced and professional, and I had utmost trust in her to get the best price for my property, which she delivered. She is highly recommended.

Seller review
A remarkable sales campaign with an excellent result.
about 5 years ago
A remarkable sales campaign with an excellent result.

Penny did an exceptional job in selling my apartment at auction. Her skills, knowledge, professionalism and sincerity are truly exceptional. She dedicated her full attention and energy to my cause, resulting in unexpected numbers of interested groups at inspections. She achieved a sale price well beyond my expectation. Thank you Penny. Gordon King.

Seller review
Supported from start to finish
about 5 years ago
Supported from start to finish

Could not recommend Penny highly enough. Acutely aware of the property market in Potts Point and an excellent and honest communicator. This was the first property we have sold and Penny helped us feel informed and supported the entire way through the process. Also helped us achieve a beyond expectations sale price with considered and expert negotiation.

Seller review
Tough property in a tough market
over 5 years ago
Tough property in a tough market

What impressed me about Penny was how positive and proactive she was in selling my property. Other agents only saw negatives, while at the same time telling me how wonderful a real estate agent they are. The property was sold off market with zero marketing expenses. Penny proactivity put the property on her website (including doing the photos), organised open for inspections for any time and improved the appearance of the property. Highly recommended.

Seller review
Penny Timothy gets excellent results. Three cheers for her
over 5 years ago
Penny Timothy gets excellent results. Three cheers for her

Ms Timothy was the epitome of professionalism in selling 12/103 Victoria Street. This was a difficult time for me as the property belonged to my late partner and Ms Timothy was most understanding of the circumstances. I was most impressed by the analysis that Ms Timothy provided of the market and the particularities of this part of the eastern suburbs; of her negotiating skills in dealing with possible buyers and the time and energy she was prepared to expend in selling the property. I am happy to recommend her as a splendid agent: honest, knowledgeable and hard working. Nothing was a trouble and that attitude is so important when one is selling a property.

Show all 21 reviews

Penny's properties

Penny has 6 properties for sale and sold 26 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

For Sale
Price not available
31/117 Macleay Street
Potts Point NSW 2011
1
1
Apartment
For Sale
Price not available
1/40a Bayswater Road
Rushcutters Bay NSW 2011
1
Studio
SoldApr 20, 2026
$910,000
27/67 MacLeay St
Potts Point NSW 2011
1
1
Apartment
For Sale
Price not available
63/8 Birtley Place
Elizabeth Bay NSW 2011
2
1
Apartment
Show all 32 properties
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent