Peter's profile

Peter's reviews

  4.9  
Peter has 377 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Peter's qualities as told by our client reviews: easy to work with, honest, supportive, responsive, friendly, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Peter was professional, pleasant and easy to deal with.
over 5 years ago
Peter was professional, pleasant and easy to deal with.

Peter is well informed and has a solid knowledge of the local and greater Newcastle and Lake Macquare catchment. He had a pleasant and easy manner which helped to make the process a lot less stressful on me, the vendor. He was always professional in his approach and followed through promptly with feedback.

Buyer review
Always friendly and helpful
over 5 years ago
Always friendly and helpful

Pete was always approachable and happy to help with any questions. He was always well-informed and I would highly recommend him.

Seller review
Excellent Agent
over 5 years ago
Excellent Agent

We would recommend Peter Shiels and the Shiels+Co team to anyone considering selling their property. Our property was listed with another agent for four months and during that time we received little interest from buyers with the agent suggesting the price was too high. In comparison Peter was confident our property was priced to meet the market and provided us with suggestions on how to best present our property to prospective buyers. During the first open house we secured a buyer. Peter's dedication and hard work was the sole reason we were able to achieve our sale above expectations.

Buyer review
Experienced & friendly Agent
over 5 years ago
Experienced & friendly Agent

Peter had knowledge in the area we purchased in & was honest about our inclusions of the property buying off plan. He was friendly & professional.

Seller review
Seamless, Transparent and Reassuring
over 5 years ago
Seamless, Transparent and Reassuring

Thrilled with our recent sale of our beloved home. In a frenzied market, Peter was empathetic, reassuring and calm through a challenging time. We will be forever grateful.

Buyer review
Will definitely be using Peter Shiels again!
over 5 years ago
Will definitely be using Peter Shiels again!

On first meeting Peter we found him helpful, supportive and reliable. He is genuine and it was a breath of fresh air dealing with someone that was accountable and communicative with us. Very thankful!

Seller review
Friendly, professional and dependable
over 5 years ago
Friendly, professional and dependable

We have really appreciated Pete's service to us in selling the property. From the outset he has been friendly, understanding, reliable, trustworthy and helpful and has a great knowledge of the property market in the Charlestown area. His advice along the way was always professional and beneficial. Pete is supported by a wonderful team in the office too. Pete achieved a great result for us in terms of a very quick sale at the price we had hoped for. We would highly recommend Shiels & Co to anyone wishing to sell their property.

Buyer review
Market leader - compassion, professionalism and results driven
over 5 years ago
Market leader - compassion, professionalism and results driven

It was a pleasure to purchase our first home through Pete. After actively looking for 9 months, with many encounters with agents, we feel Pete was the market leader in professionalism, communication, and compassion for the vendor as well as interested buyers. While many other agents also share some of these qualities, we saw Pete go above and beyond many times for the vendor we purchased from to ensure they were well taken care of and looked after, as well as ensuring we found the right property for us, after missing out on other properties. If we ever decide to sell, it is a no brainer for us to ask Pete to sell our home.

Seller review
Personal touch makes all the difference
over 5 years ago
Personal touch makes all the difference

Pete made us very comfortable with every step of the sale process, providing us advice, links with tradespeople and stylists and was always happy to answer any questions. His team were very responsive to our questions and kept us informed every step of the way. We were excited to be the first sale for the new agency and we know who to call when the time is right for us again.

Seller review
Above and beyond
over 5 years ago
Above and beyond

Peter did an excellent job selling our property, he was always available to discuss things and answer questions. We had a difficult tenant but Peter handled him well in the process of open houses and the final sale.

Seller review
Total Professional
over 5 years ago
Total Professional

We have used many different agents over the years, and Peter is definitely a 10/10. His professionalism and work ethic are second to none, and he has delivered on everything he has promised. A great price & a short turnaround, Pete was constantly in contact to get the deal done!

253 - 264 of 377
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent