Scott Matthews' reviews
Scott Matthews

Scott Matthews

  4.8   (153 reviews)

8/5 Norton St

Scott helped the reviewer buy this property

Scott Matthews
$672,000
8/5 Norton St
Ashfield
2
1
1
Apartment

almost 4 years ago

Illegally stopped auction midway

My experience with Scott in 2016 was unflattering at best. He was very pleasant and accommodating leading up to the auction. Midway through the auction he, as the auctioneer, stopped it twice, once to let a new bidder, who he had the decency to disclose worked at his office. We eventually purchased $120k more than the reserve price, he disclosed that to us as well. Oddly he only declared the property 'on the market' after our 4th bid, when the bidding started at reserve. Being first homebuyers we didn't think anything of it. My boss at the time, Commissioner of Fair Trading advised it was illegal. Though I ran out of energy to persue it. All in all Scott's underhanded actions at the auction made us feel cheated on the purchase of our first home. Thanks for the opportunity to give you this feedback Scott, despite being several years after the sale. Oh, I did forget that Scott had installed a giant lit up sign despite body corporate by-laws prohibiting advertising. No doubt the original owner had to pay for the sign regardless.

D
Dom
Buyer

See who was involved in this review

Scott Matthews
Scott Matthews

Director / Licensee / Licensed Real Estate Agent

View profile   4.8   (153 reviews)
EmailSMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent