Shelby's profile

Shelby's reviews

  4.9  
Shelby has 17 reviewsacross 13 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Seller review
Brilliant agent
over 2 years ago
Brilliant agent

Shelby made the whole process of selling our first house pain free. All our questions were answered promptly and she was able to simply guide us through what may have otherwise been an overwhelming process. Shelby then worked efficiently to help us secure a quick sale. We would not only recommend Shelby, we would choose her again if the need arose for us in the future.

Buyer review
Honest Professionalism
over 2 years ago
Honest Professionalism

Shelby was great to deal with throughout the sales process. Communication was clear, honest and quick, and was always done in a professional manner. Thank you again for such an easy and smooth process!

Seller review
Professional, friendly and hard working!
over 2 years ago
Professional, friendly and hard working!

We couldn't be more thrilled with the exceptional service we received from Taylor Hedley Property, particularly our dedicated agent, Shelby Telfer. Selling our first family home was a significant milestone for us, and Shelby's expertise, professionalism and support made the entire process smooth and stress-free. Shelby’s commitment to achieving the best outcome for us was evident from our initial consultation to the final closing. We highly recommend Taylor Hedley Property and Shelby Telfer.

Seller review
Everything was outstanding especially the lines of communication.
over 2 years ago
Everything was outstanding especially the lines of communication.

From the very first point of contact, to the first meeting and everything to the sale closing was outstanding. Shelby's communication with us was excellent and every question we asked was answered promptly. I will definitely use Shelby in the future as i can highly recommend her. She is a wonderful asset to Sam and the team at Taylor Hedley.

Seller review
Genuine and Helpful!
over 2 years ago
Genuine and Helpful!

We recently sold our home through Shelby and Beau at Taylor Hedley Property. We found both Shelby and Beau to be helpful, knowledgeable and easy going. We also considered the buyer when choosing agents as we really value open, friendly communication and agents that are humble and easy to deal with. We highly recommend both Shelby and Beau as a team as they compliant each other well.

Buyer review
Honest and flexible
over 5 years ago
Honest and flexible

Shelby was fantastic. Very flexible and facilitated several inspections. She kept me informed throughout and was very prompt in her communication.

Seller review
Shelby was a delight to work with in every way thank you .
over 5 years ago
Shelby was a delight to work with in every way thank you .

Shelby was a delight to work with in every way while selling our home , I am sure in time Shelby will become one of the top young ladies in the Real Estate Bussiness in Newcastle good luck to you . Jackie

Seller review
Goes above and beyond
over 5 years ago
Goes above and beyond

Excellent experience. Would recommend

Seller review
Best service in Newcastle
almost 6 years ago
Best service in Newcastle

Shelby was absolutely professional and was always available throughout the whole process. I would recommend her every single time

Buyer review
Real realestate
almost 6 years ago
Real realestate

It was a real pleasure to deal with Shelby. What l call a real realestate agent. Relatable personable, and easygoing. Thank you

Seller review
Sale of my property
almost 6 years ago
Sale of my property

I found Shelby very knowledgeable and very helpful in the sale of my house.

Seller review
Professional, with a passion for Real Estate
almost 6 years ago
Professional, with a passion for Real Estate

From our initial engagement right through our sale campaign Shelby was professional with all aspects of selling our family home. Her presentation, timely manner, ability to provide conclusive details after each open home gave us a good understanding of the campaigns progress. Shelby was passionate in selling our home which ultimately resulted in a successful campaign. Her friendly and approachable manner makes a stressful situation manageable, we highly recommend her services and would use Green St for future purchases and sales.

1 - 12 of 17
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent