Sheldon's profile

Sheldon's reviews

  5  
Sheldon has 22 reviewsacross 7 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Seller review
He has great communication
29 days ago
He has great communication

Sheldon is a unicorn of a real estate agent (REA). He does exactly what he is asked. He is always on time. He has great communication. He is smart and helpful in his suggestions. He sold our house for a very high price in a super short time frame with absolutely no hiccups from start to finish. Hire Sheldon if you want to sell your property smoothly, profitably and without the slimy feeling that most REAs give you.

Seller review
His knowledge of the market and strategic plan helped us to sell for far more than we originally
3 months ago
His knowledge of the market and strategic plan helped us to sell for far more than we originally

Sheldon approached us with a strategy we wouldn't usually consider, but all of his predicted outcomes with the strategy came to fruition. His knowledge of the market and strategic plan helped us to sell for far more than we originally thought we could get. Sheldon and his team went above and beyond assisting us in our move. Highly recommend.

Seller review
He is passionate about doing a good job and worked really hard
5 months ago
He is passionate about doing a good job and worked really hard

My husband and I had the pleasure of selling our house with Sheldon this year. Choosing an agent was a lot more stressful than I had anticipated, we met with a few to make sure we were making the right choice, we have no doubts we did. Sheldon is friendly, honest and hard working. He is passionate about doing a good job and worked really hard to guide us confidently through the selling process. His market knowledge was outstanding. He was openly communicative and went above and beyond!

Seller review
5 star agent
5 months ago
5 star agent

Selling our house felt like such a breeze with Sheldon. Seriously down-to-earth and super easy to work with. Sheldon took all the stress out of the process and made everything crystal clear. If you want a realtor who keeps it real and gets the job done, look no further!

Seller review
Extremely diligent
7 months ago
Extremely diligent

Sheldon was really great to deal with and was extremely diligent. I actually trusted him and I don’t usually trust real estate agents haha. He sold our investment property off market and it was the most stress free process. We tried to sell the same property the year prior and couldn’t get what we wanted for it, but Sheldon did the job without even having to take it to market. Highly recommended!

Buyer review
Better real estate agent.
7 months ago
Better real estate agent.

Sheldon was fantastic to work with when we purchased our property through him in Scarborough. Very knowledgable on location and process with above and beyond service answering all calls and texts almost immediately, even when we unknowingly contacted him whilst he had taken a day off. Great bloke, even better real estate agent. Highly recommend.

Seller review
Made the whole process seamless
7 months ago
Made the whole process seamless

Sheldon was professional, efficient, and made the whole process seamless. He negotiated the sale of my home with precision and achieved a fantastic result. Highly recommend for anyone wanting an agent who truly delivers.

Seller review
He went above and beyond
8 months ago
He went above and beyond

Sheldon sold an investment property for us and he was great. He went above and beyond and brings a very positive energy to everything he does. He made the process as easy as it could be, coordinating the staging, building inspections, landscapers etc. His prompt reporting on enquiries received, meant we always felt well informed, he was always available. Sheldon also actively sought back up buyers until the sale was unconditional. We would not hesitate to recommend his services.

Buyer review
Incredibly knowledgeable
8 months ago
Incredibly knowledgeable

Sheldon is incredibly knowledgeable of the local real estate market. Extremely helpful in everyway.. I would highly recommend him in selling your home. Very Professional and such a nice guy.

Seller review
Great communication in all aspects
9 months ago
Great communication in all aspects

It was great working with Sheldon and the team at Cullen & Co. The whole process went smoothly and great communication in all aspects. Would recommend to anyone!

Seller review
Good natured person
10 months ago
Good natured person

Sheldon is a most likeable, good natured person who exhibits a wide knowledge base of the real estate industry. He offers commonsense advice and realistic ideas with presentation. When my circumstance changed a day and a bit prior to an inspection Sheldon took it in his stride, arranged others to inspect on the same day and achieved a sale for me above my minimum price. All this occurred in a 48 hour period. I would recommend Sheldon to any person wanting to sell

Seller review
Delivered beyond expectations
10 months ago
Delivered beyond expectations

Cameron Cullen and Sheldon Pitama were exceptional throughout the entire property process. These two professionals delivered beyond expectations—thorough in their preparation, transparent in their dealings, and clear-eyed in their advice. They worked hard, stayed tenacious when it counted, and kept communication clear, consistent, and reliable. A standout team—professional, driven, and absolutely committed to the outcome. Highly recommended.

1 - 12 of 22
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent