Shelley's profile

Shelley's reviews

  4.7  
Shelley has 23 reviewsacross 11 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Shelley's qualities as told by our client reviews: trustworthy, friendly, stress-free process, honest, responsive, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Fantastic Experience
over 3 years ago
Fantastic Experience

Shelley was amazing, she kept us up to date the whole way through - and was generally really lovely to work with on selling out unit

Seller review
Shelley Bays - Simply the best
over 3 years ago
Shelley Bays - Simply the best

I've dealt with Shelley over a number of years both in the capacity of managing and selling my investment property. She is simply the best. The combination of her energy, proactiveness and expertise means she constantly achieves the desired outcome

Seller review
We had a very satisfying experience selling our unit recently with Shelley Bays
over 3 years ago
We had a very satisfying experience selling our unit recently with Shelley Bays

We knew Shelley since we bought this rental property in 2016. Shelley has an excellent knowledge of the real estate industry in Sydney, and her working attitude is second to none. She always provides her top grade services within a few hours. When we came to the sales campaign, Shelley's advice on marketing and styling was invaluable. She arranged for our unit to be ready for sale quickly and always update us with every open house in time. Shelley’s communication skills are immediately evident and her manner is polite and dignified. I recommend her to any aspiring sellers.

Seller review
Outstanding agent
almost 4 years ago
Outstanding agent

Shelley is an incredible agent. She did an outstanding job with the sale of my property, the whole process was seamless and stress free. Shelley is honest, genuine and will ensure a fair and positive outcome for all involved. I will absolutely use Shelley again for future property sales or purchases and highly recommend her to others.

Seller review
Shelley was amazing.
over 4 years ago
Shelley was amazing.

As soon as we signed up Shelley and Plan A, we had a renovation that needed to be done, and we were out of town. Shelley turned up almost every day to let the trades in and was very flexible. Once the renovation was complete, they found a tenant and handle them with care and honesty. We then had to sell our apartment, and Shelley was again great - as a business they had a unique selling plan, found a buyer and guided us with their knowledge and experience to the sale. Always happy to chat, super fast response either by phone or email.

Seller review
Shelley is the best
over 4 years ago
Shelley is the best

Shelley was excellent, kept us up to-date as different vendors made offers. Kept us in the loop thru the whole process. Went over and above to clean and paint the house once the tenants moved out. Most importantly got the vendors to an offer we couldn't refuse. Will recommend to all my friends who are selling their place. She was almost as excited about selling the place as we were.

Seller review
S.BAYS IS A GRADE!!
over 4 years ago
S.BAYS IS A GRADE!!

From our very first interaction when Shelley took on the rental management of our property we knew we were in safe hands. We were an unusual case as we relocated overseas then came the challenges of the pandemic. At no time was there ever an issue that wasn't attended to straight away and always above & beyond her scope. When it came time to sell our place, it was an easy, and assured decision to go with Shelley, we had seen her in action and had absolute trust in her knowledge of the area, the market and the potential of our property. We then set the record for our complex. Couldnt be happier with the result! 5 stars!!!

Seller review
A terrific experience
over 4 years ago
A terrific experience

Shelley is an excellent agent. I had such a positive experience with Shelley leasing and also selling my property. She kept in close communication every step of the way and I was very confident that she did everything she could to get the best price. She handled every aspect of the sale and made it so easy for me. I couldn’t recommend Shelley more highly.

Buyer review
Extremely transparent and always available
over 4 years ago
Extremely transparent and always available

Shelley was acting for the vendor of a property we purchased. She was extremely transparent throughout the negotiation. If she said she was going to come back with an update by the end of the day, she would. We we’re never left wondering! I highly recommend Shelley!

Buyer review
Easy going, prompt and lovely to deal with
about 5 years ago
Easy going, prompt and lovely to deal with

Shelley was lovely to work with, helping us through the process and was much more pleasant and more transparent than other agents we dealt with. Working both for us and the client to reach the desired outcome. I would highly recommend.

Seller review
Very proactive and professional - could not be happier
about 5 years ago
Very proactive and professional - could not be happier

Had to engage Shelley for a property in Elizabeth Bay after some challenges with the current tenant and agent. She was super impressive - knowledgable, professional, proactive and personable. She took care of everything and made it all very easy. There were a few setbacks along the way, all of which she dealt with aplomb. We got a quick sale at a very good price in line with expectations. I would highly recommend her.

Seller review
An agent with great integrity and the drive to get the best results!
over 5 years ago
An agent with great integrity and the drive to get the best results!

Shelley has been an incredible support and guide through the entire process. Selling a house is a big deal and for a novice I really needed someone I could trust and rely on. Shelley delivered on all fronts. You didn’t feel like a number with Shelley, she made you feel important and the experience was personal and friendly. I felt connected, always being updated at every corner, knowing exactly what was going on. The campaign she developed yielded great results and I couldn’t have been happier. I can’t recommend Shelley, Craig and Plan A enough. You will not regret taking the journey with them.

1 - 12 of 23
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent