Tony's profile

Tony's reviews

  4.9  
Tony has 334 reviewsacross 31 different locations, showing 12.
over 2 years ago
Tony is an exceptional agent. He is client centred, diligent, focused, enthusiast and knowledgeable.

Tony displayed a genuine interest and enthusiasm that translated into a great outcome for our family. We had a fabulous location and a dated home. He worked hard at reaching out to possible buyers, ensured that agency costs reflected that commitment. Researched and reviewed the potential value Of the property. Marketed and engaged with all possible clients stating clearly the hopes we as vendors had. He was friendly, compassionate and followed through with what he said he would do. Stood by us as the auction played out and celebrated with us the house sold above the base price. If you are looking for a supportive, not over the top agent he is the person to lead the team

over 2 years ago
Super friendly and personable

Tony was super helpful throughout the buying process, ensuring I was kept up to date on all the details in the lead up to the auction. He had professionalism in managing the buyer and seller side and ultimately we had an outcome we were happy with and the sellers seemed happy too.

over 2 years ago
The best agent we've dealt with, and we've dealt with a lot! Sincere, knowledgable, invaluable!

Our story before meeting Tony: We had been looking for our first home for about 12 months before we finally found this gem and secured it at auction. Throughout the 12 months we would inspect 2-5 properties a weekend, we looked at more properties and met more agents than I could count. There were some good agents we encountered over that time. However, if I'm honest we'd also been burnt by agents who'd withheld information until the last minute, strung us along and set us up with unrealistic expectations, wasting our time and money. After 12 months of searching, we had lost hope that we would be able to purchase our first home without really compromising on what we wanted. Then we finally met Tony and it was a godsend. Tony has been the best agent we've dealt with, and trust me we've dealt with a lot! Why our experience with Tony was so great: - His calm, sincere and professional energy made us feel completely at ease throughout the whole process. - He was extremely attentive - always happy to take however much time was needed to check in and answer questions at inspections or over the phone, whenever needed. - He shared his experience and knowledge to ensure we were able to make informed decisions, regarding the property, the street, the suburb, and the purchase process. - Through his genuine care and attention, he built a relationship with us and understood our needs, so he could support us thoroughly throughout the buying process. Without having read any of his numerous glowing reviews at the time, I knew that he had sold this property multiple times, and had repeat business from the same people. It showed me his customers trusted him and now I understand why. He told us that he would be in our corner and he was - we can finally say, thanks to Tony, we are homeowners and we didn't make any compromises!

over 2 years ago
Highly recommended real estate agent!

We recently had the pleasure of working with Tony on the purchase of our new home. Tony possesses an in-depth knowledge of the local real estate market and took the time to listen attentively to our needs and preferences and guided us through the home-buying process. He provided us insight into the potential of the properties we had viewed and in particular the property we purchased.

over 2 years ago
A Satisfying Home Sale Experience

Working with Toni Licastro on the sale of our property in Burwood Heights was an exceptional experience. Our home held decades of memories, as it was where we had grown up, and saying goodbye was undoubtedly emotional. Toni's empathetic approach made a significant difference throughout the process. Toni's thoughtful guidance and support helped ease the emotional challenges of parting ways with our cherished home. Toni's professionalism and market expertise were evident at every stage. His strategic approach and effective communication not only simplified the selling process but also yielded results that left us thoroughly satisfied. We are grateful for Toni's dedication, and we highly recommend him to anyone seeking a real estate agent who not only understands the market but also cares about the personal journey of selling a home.

over 2 years ago
Wonderful service.

I had a fantastic experience working with Tony throughout the property purchase process. Tony’s friendliness and prompt responsiveness made the entire journey smooth and enjoyable. His commitment to excellent communication greatly contributed to a positive and efficient home-buying experience. I highly recommend Tony’s services to anyone in need of a reliable and personable real estate professional.

over 2 years ago
Unrelenting, in the best way possible.

From our first meeting with Tony Licastro, we were given complete transparency, respect and the highest level of professionalism that carried throughout the entirety of our campaign. Tony is the type of agent to never take the foot off the accelerator in order to attain the best results. He is simply the type of agent you want on your side.

over 2 years ago
Extraordinary service provided

After doing a great deal of homework, we chose Tony to assist in the sale of our mum’s home. What was apparent was the care and understanding through this challenging Life event. Tony ensured communication through every step and whilst he went to great lengths to explain our options, we were never pressured to go in a direction we were not comfortable to go (the point of difference to other realtors). The lead up to auction day was very well prepared including the introduction of Sebastian our auctioneer a couple of days before. This was critical as we had put our family home of 63 years in both Tony and Sebastian’s hands. As a team, Tony and Sebastian ensured we got what we had hoped for. I am so grateful we went with this team. Anyone would do well with either but will succeed with both Tony and Sebastian!

over 2 years ago
Tony was amazing, he went above and beyond all my expectations and received a great result.

Tony is an amazing agent who went above and beyond all my expectations. Tony worked very hard and achieved a great result on Auction Day with Sebastian Bonacorso. Tony was informative every step of the way with updates and feedback, reserve meetings and organising tradespeople and styling etc to make my unit look amazing. Well done Tony!

over 2 years ago
OUTSTANDING AGENT!!

From my experience with Tony in selling my unit was exceptional. He reported to me after each open home and kept me well informed throughout the process. On auction day the auctioneer and whole team from Elders were very professional and I sincerely thank Tony and his team for an outcome that exceeded my expectation. I have no hesitation in recommending Tony.

over 2 years ago
Thank you for my new home Tony !!

Tony Licastro has been exceptional to work with when buying my new property. Tony made the very stressful process of buying a new property extremely easy. He went above and beyond to support and guide me every step of the way. His professional, transparent and patient demeanor made what can be a very stressful time into an exciting and very pleasant experience.

61 - 72 of 334
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent