From 133 reviews overall

David Caldwell
Wilton Lemke Stewart

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Charlestown
Median days on market
18 Kullaroo Road Charlestown
David showed fantastic knowledge of the market in Charlestown, developed a sound strategy which gave us a great result. He shepherded us through all the decisions we needed to make as first time vendors. He was extremely pleasant to deal with, kept us on top of all the pertinent details and was realistic about what to expect. I’d strongly recommend David.
From 305 reviews overall

Kathleen Matinlassi
Kathleen Matinlassi and Co

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Charlestown
Median days on market
81 E K Avenue Charlestown
We recently purchased with Kathleen and after going through what is always a stressful process we chose to also sell our property with Kathleen purely because of her professionalism and accessibility. We cannot recommend her high enough! No question was off limits and she made herself available after hours which was a great help to us. It was obvious that Kathleen would go the extra mile to get the right price and she was motivated to make everyone happy. Kathleen has a special ability to market a house but also not be intrusive or annoying. She is direct and hard working. Ultimately we trusted her though both the purchase and sale. As we wait for settlement Kathleen is still in contact with us sharing options for furniture and going the extra mile. Thank you!
City Top 5
ratemyagent award
Newcastle - Maitland2026Suburb Winner
ratemyagent award
Eleebana2026Suburb Winner
ratemyagent award
Valentine2026From 73 reviews overall
Liliana Innocente
Salt Property Newcastle
From 113 reviews overall

Brooke Degotardi
Stone Real Estate Newcastle
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Charlestown
Median days on market
42 Wakal St Charlestown
Wish I could give more than 5 stars for our amazing experience! Thanks girls 🙏 💕🙌🏻😊 Funnily we hadn’t expected to be so impressed by Brooke … we knew she was the area expert however we planned to get several agents out and decide later. She was the second agent to chat to us and we had two more in mind. But when she left after our appraisal, my husband looked at me and said - wow I think she’s our agent! I agreed. We cancelled the other agents and started planning our campaign with Brooke and her awesome team ( Erin & Mikayla ) I’m not sure if many people are lucky enough to have the perfect campaign from start to finish, but that was our experience. We had complete confidence in Brooke & her team to guide us through a time in our lives that usually is the most stressful but wasn’t at all. How cool is that! We are so grateful for their hard work, dedication and incredible communication skills throughout. The systems these girls have in place to keep you informed seems effortless, but I know it takes time, work, long hours and care. We never once felt out of the loop. Brooke did everything that she said she would do and her team were friendly and professional. We appreciate the endless patience that Brooke displayed with our questions and worries. This helped us to travel through our month long auction campaign feeling confident and actually excited. When we got a fabulous result on auction day (having had 5 registered bidders ) we were so stoked! Brookes well thought out and well executed plan had worked like a treat! It can be emotional moving on from a place you’ve called home, however when the transition is this smooth, it makes you happy to know it was such a success and you can move on with fond memories. A BIG thanks to Brooke, Erin & Mikayla. Our family will miss seeing your smiling faces each week! 🩷