
From 322 reviews overall


Reviews in Menai
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
14 Miller Place Menai
David is the best agent I could have hoped for. He had extensive knowledge of the local area and was very professional in his approach. He went above and beyond to ensure a smooth sale process, and was also very patient and respectful of my requests, including buying fresh flowers for the property prior to inspections. I have no doubt that his actions and those of his team ensured that we met and exceeded our reserve price on auction day. I wholeheartedly recommend David and his team. Thank you!!
Suburb Winner
ratemyagent award
Miranda2026
From 1220 reviews overall



Reviews in Menai
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
202/22 Banksia Road Caringbah
we had been looking for a property in the Shire for many months - Geraldine kept in contact with us - advising of new properties coming up and what we had looked at - she was the only Agent who kept in contact. So that is why we gave our property to Geraldine to sell. Thru the selling process she kept us informed every step of the way.
51 Carvers Road Oyster Bay
We give Geraldine five stars for her outstanding service and knowledge. About a year ago, we had our first conversation with her about selling our property, and she was patient, giving us all the time and space we needed until we were ready. With four kids, open homes weren't easy, but Geraldine kept us calm and reassured during some very stressful moments. We honestly could not have asked for a better agent, and she even helped us purchase our next home as well. Thank you for being a kind person on this journey that you made easy for us Geraldine. Best agent in the Shire by far!

From 1180 reviews overall
Reviews in Menai
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here
Suburb Winner
ratemyagent award
Burraneer2026Reviews in Menai
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
BB 102/18 University Road Miranda
From my first interaction with Donna, I knew it was her face I wanted to see at the finish line when we sold my apartment. And she really held my hand the whole way through our very hard & fast campaign (under 4 weeks from market to record sale!) Donna was incredibly warm, professional, strategic and assured me through every step of the way. Her patience was second to none and once sold, it felt strange not talking to her daily about the market and putting forward ideas and plans. Donna’s network in the Sutherland Shire is expansive, her knowledge of the industry, market and upcoming opportunities incredibly valuable and you can tell from the moment you meet her she is reputable, honest and fair agent to both buyers and sellers. She had a genuine approach to all aspects of the campaign and I felt empowered & informed to make my own decisions, while being guided by an outcomes-driven agent. She moved fast at my request, while still giving plenty of opportunities and space to pivot if we needed. I am truly thankful for Donna & her team - honestly couldn’t recommend her enough.

From 408 reviews overall



Reviews in Menai
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
15 Shade Place Lugarno
James was very informed on the local market and helped me with deciding on the correct price to advertise. He kept in touch frequently and answered all my questions quickly. He made the process very easy for me to handle the sale and his advice was always good resulting in a price way above my expectations.
4/883 King Georges Road South Hurstville
Daniel and his team was professional, responsive and supportive throughout the selling process. Despite a complicated finance approval process, he stayed in regular communication and worked hard to keep the transaction moving forward. We appreciate his efforts and are very pleased with the final result.

From 315 reviews overall


Reviews in Menai
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
5B Carinya Rd Picnic Point
My property was an unusual style and built in both a bushfire and flood zone. Jenny and all involved at Allicance Real Estate did a great job and achieved a good result. This is the 2nd property I have sold through Alliance at Panania and both were very successfull. Thank you Jenny
33 Garnsey Avenue Panania
Theo is an exceptionally experienced real estate agent who made the entire selling process smooth and stress free. From the outset, he kept in close contact, managed every detail, and ensured both myself and my adult children felt informed and at ease. His communication was consistent, clear, and always reassuring. On the day of the auction, Theo went above and beyond by arranging a coffee van, which everyone loved and which helped create a relaxed, welcoming atmosphere. I was extremely happy with the auctioneer he selected and thrilled with the final outcome of the sale. I highly recommend Theo and his team. Their professionalism, dedication, and thoughtful approach truly set them apart. Thank you, Theo.
Suburb Winner
ratemyagent award
Panania2026Reviews in Menai
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
37 Traynor Avenue Kogarah
After hunting for a home for over a year. We can confidently say we knew every agent in the area by first name. Although I was sceptical to begin with following some poor interactions with other agents, Nick was as honest and genuine as they come. He's the kind of local agent that knows every street in the area like the back of his hand (including every sale). Obviously our experience buying with Nick was stellar, moving forward we wouldn't hesitate selling with Nick too
34 Beach Street Kogarah
Nick is a well renowned real estate agent in the St George area whose dedication for his client is unrivaled. My father chose to Nick as his real estate agent as he had achieved a superb price for his friend. We have also purchased from Nick previously and his family run real estate agent has helped us with finding tenants too. Dad had trouble with english and so I was the helper. Nick was superb during the process and Dad managed to achieve an outstanding price. Would recommend =-)
From 148 reviews overall
Reviews in Menai
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
Level 10, 1004/10 Village Place Kirrawee
Lucy was incredible to work with throughout the entire process and she achieved a record sale for our complex. Communication, perseverance and extensive market knowledge were Lucy’s strong points. We would recommend Lucy to anybody looking to sell!

From 194 reviews overall



Reviews in Menai
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
1/2 Mowbray Street Sylvania
Saying that a realtor was "there every step of the way" can sound a little corny but when it came to Troy at Elders Sylvania it was absolutely true. From the moment we decided to sell our townhouse through to contract signing, Troy helped us navigate every situation that came up with professionalism and a smile. No matter what questions or concerns we or the buyers had, he was always just a phone call away, ready with friendly guidance, honest advice, and clear answers. Selling our home could have easily been very stressful, but Troy made the entire process feel smooth and stress-free. His communication was excellent, his knowledge of the market was invaluable, and we always felt supported and informed throughout the journey. We couldn't be happier with both the experience and the result. If you're looking for an agent who genuinely cares about his clients, keeps you informed, and goes above and beyond to make the process as easy as possible, I highly recommend Troy Coleman from Elders at Sylvania.