Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
200 reviewsacross 30 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: great negotiation, honest, reliable, responsive, supportive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Very professional
about 1 year ago
Very professional

My experience with Caroline Selka has been a very impressive operator, knowledgeable, thorough and professional.

Caroline Selka

Caroline Selka

  4.9   (120 reviews)
Buyer review
Excellent service.
about 1 year ago
Excellent service.

Caroline Selka was knowledgeable, professional and friendly during the purchase of our apartment. She made the process a stress free experience for us and we recommend her to anyone who requires an agent with an excellent knowledge of her area.

Caroline Selka

Caroline Selka

  4.9   (120 reviews)
Seller review
Positive and Proffessional
about 1 year ago
Positive and Proffessional

Maria was very helpful throughout the whole process and was a great negotiator esspeccially during a challenging market in 2021. Her positivity and professionalism brought a good outcome for all parties

Maria Magrin

Maria Magrin

  4.9   (155 reviews)
Seller review
Very professional agent
about 1 year ago
Very professional agent

Caroline Selka sold my unit at Camperdown some time ago. I was impressed by the professionalism of Caroline and her team and the service I received. Her tips on presenting the unit helped me get a good price. Donald Campbell

Caroline Selka

Caroline Selka

  4.9   (120 reviews)
Seller review
Outstanding service and results – Maria is the best!
about 1 year ago
Outstanding service and results – Maria is the best!

I cannot speak highly enough of Maria Magrin. Selling my apartment with Maria was a smooth and positive experience from start to finish. Her professionalism, deep market knowledge, and dedication were evident every step. Maria guided me through the entire process with clarity, warmth, and expert advice. Her hands on approach, from coordinating the styling and plants to overseeing photography, ensured my property was presented at its absolute best. The team at Belle Property Pyrmont were also fantastic: responsive, supportive, and highly professional. If you're looking for an agent who brings both expertise and genuine care, choosing Maria is one of the best decisions you can make.

Maria Magrin

Maria Magrin

  4.9   (155 reviews)
Buyer review
Outstanding service, comprehensive local knowledge & great attention to detail.
about 1 year ago
Outstanding service, comprehensive local knowledge & great attention to detail.

Above says it all. However the ongoing contact with an update or two each year has been greatly appreciated. We have all had less than satisfactory experiences with buying & selling property. Caroline was professional & personable. Definitely a keeper!

Caroline Selka

Caroline Selka

  4.9   (120 reviews)
Buyer review
Wouldn't recommend
about 1 year ago
Wouldn't recommend

Noel is professional and got us a good deal on our apartment, however a lot of information provided by him turned out to not be true. We also went into a dispute with vendor which turned out was easy to resolve, but due to Noel's conduct it dragged out the settlement and ended up costing everyone additional money.

Noel Lucas-Martinez

Noel Lucas-Martinez

  4.5   (21 reviews)
Buyer review
Definitely the worst Real Estate agent experience I have ever had
about 1 year ago
Definitely the worst Real Estate agent experience I have ever had

This agent sold me this property while also managing it from a rental perspective. On the transfer of ownership, literally the morning of completion, they decided to end their management and pass it to me without any forewarning or discussion. Once we agreed they would continue to manage they were woeful. Not only would it take weeks to get answers to emails, but I was also billed multiple times incorrectly and on one occasion even agreed to a purchase for the property (drying machine) by the tenant for which I would apparently pay half - all of which done without any consultation with me or permission to do so. The final nail was finding out that the landlord insurance they had arranged for me still had the previous owners details on the certificate, which meant I was effectively not covered and completely exposed. I called a meeting to hand over all management to me and for them to explain their shortcomings. They spent the whole meeting blatantly lying despite me providing pages of emails proving their incompetence and outright lies. Noel, as the principal, just sat there playing dumb and added zero value. If would NEVER recommend this agent to anyone for either managing a sale of a property or managing an investment property.

Noel Lucas-Martinez

Noel Lucas-Martinez

  4.5   (21 reviews)
Buyer review
Amazing Communication and Friendliness!
about 1 year ago
Amazing Communication and Friendliness!

Mia was great in organising a time to visit the property, and answered any questions that we had and beyond, before and during the process of purchasing.

Mia Grech

Mia Grech

  5   (6 reviews)
Seller review
Navigating the Real Estate Maze With Caroline Selk
about 1 year ago
Navigating the Real Estate Maze With Caroline Selk

Working with Caroline was an absolute game-changer in our property journey. From the first meeting, she demonstrated deep market knowledge, professionalism, and a genuine commitment to our needs. Whether it was answering late-night questions, negotiating with confidence, or guiding us through a tough market, Caroline made the entire process smooth and stress-free. What stood out most was her honesty and transparency—qualities that are often hard to find in the fast-paced world of real estate. She wasn’t just trying to close a deal; she focused on finding the right fit. She know the market inside-out, kept things real, and fought hard to get us the best deal. Super responsive, no pushy sales vibes, just straight-up solid service. If you're buying or selling, She’s your go-to.

Caroline Selka

Caroline Selka

  4.9   (120 reviews)
Buyer review
Noel was exceptionally easy to deal with. He...
about 1 year ago
Noel was exceptionally easy to deal with. He...

Noel was exceptionally easy to deal with. He was calm and professional and instilled in me a confidence, honesty and integrity that doesn’t often get associated with real estate agents!

Noel Lucas-Martinez

Noel Lucas-Martinez

  4.5   (21 reviews)
37 - 48 of 200
© 2026 RateMyAgent