Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
221 reviewsacross 15 different locations, showing 12.
about 9 years ago
When you know...

James and the team at Buxton know the area well, but most importantly the know how to treat people. They took a very stressful time for my partner and I, and turned it into a simple process with a joyous outcome. Thanks JC

James Karantonis

James Karantonis

  4.7   (72 reviews)
about 9 years ago
Great work

James did a fantastic job at selling the property in Chadstone. He went above and beyond with the open homes, was always happy to take a call, and was extremely honest and transparent throughout the whole process. I would highly recommend James and hope to work with him again one day in the future.

James Karantonis

James Karantonis

  4.7   (72 reviews)
about 9 years ago
Ashwood Drive

James did a great job of negotiating an off market transaction, he went the extra step and completed the deal quickly and smoothly. I have bought and sold with James and could recommend him highly! He covers all the details, and provides great follow up. Thanks James.

James Karantonis

James Karantonis

  4.7   (72 reviews)
over 9 years ago
Above and Beyond

We strongly recommend the services of James Karantonis and Jesse Mathews. They are both highly professional and incredibly knowable of their industry and target markets. We were extremely impressed with the efficiency of our sales campaign, which resulted in offers that exceeded our expectations. James and Jesse ensured attention to detail from beginning to end. We couldn't have asked for a more positive experience. We wouldn't hesitate to call on their services in the future.

James Karantonis

James Karantonis

  4.7   (72 reviews)
over 9 years ago
James and Joys Team work

Updates, communication, integrity by Buxton team was obvious and much appreciated

James Karantonis

James Karantonis

  4.7   (72 reviews)
over 9 years ago
I'm glad I chose Buxtons!!

Before selling my family home, I interviewed several agents from different agencies. When I met with James Karantonis and Rachel Aston from Buxtons Ashburton, I knew instantly that they were the agents for me - they were knowledgeable, professional yet friendly, and listened to me when I conveyed what I wanted in regards to marketing and the sale of my home. I was not disappointed! James and Rachel work very well together as a team - as a vendor, this means you have two quality agents working for you. Their market knowledge of the area was unrivalled, James' negotiation skills exceptional, Rachel's regular communication appreciated and valued, and their professional engagement with potential buyers outstanding (I know this because I attended an open home and saw them in action...). Their combined skills and efforts resulted in not only my house selling a mere two weeks after going on the open market, but also in the sale price being above our reserve. Rest assured you are in good hands if you choose James and Rachel.

James Karantonis

James Karantonis

  4.7   (72 reviews)
over 9 years ago
James Karantonis sale of 16 Lavidge Road Ashwood

James was very informative, keeping us fully aware of how things were progressing throughout the campaign on a weekly basis, both from a market perspective as well as potential buyers. James ensured he was fully familiar with the history and potential positive aspects to purchasing the property which he used to create an extremely appealing and enticing introduction at the auction. James made sure we were fully aware of what could occur, best and worst case scenarios, on the day and how he would proceed in each of these circumstances. At the auction James was articulate, clear and passionate, and set it up to optimise every chance of success. He was thorough in his presentation and determined in pursuit of strong bidding during the auction.

James Karantonis

James Karantonis

  4.7   (72 reviews)
over 9 years ago
A big big ''Thank You' to James Karantonis - such a great agent

I would like to say a big 'Thank You' to James Karantonis and Andy Shi from Buxton Camberwell. They are really absolutely great! James and Andy helped me to sell my unit in Glen Iris. They are so efficient, so helpful and so professional. They arranged someone to renovate part of the unit at a low cost and completed these work just in 4 days. Just after this small renovation job at a really low cost, the unit looked a lot better. And then the unit was sold at a very great price just in 10 days. My husband and I are very happy and impressed by the outcome. I believed that James is a very competent agent, that is the reason why I contacted him to ask him selling my unit. Now I should say James and Andy are actually even better than what I expected. They are really fantastic, so competent, and also very professional and friendly. I will definitely recommend James Karantonis and Andy Shi from Buxton to all my family members and my friends.

James Karantonis

James Karantonis

  4.7   (72 reviews)
over 9 years ago
Selling Experience

I've previously purchased three properties, but never sold one. After a few meetings to determine the best agent to sell my unit, I was immediately impressed with not only the knowledge and obvious experience James had, but also with his personable nature, the generosity of his time to discuss how the whole process works and his willingness to talk through the best selling strategy for my property. This, coupled with a very strong understanding of the market in the area, Buxton's strong presence in this market and the reach that Buxton has with prospective buyers, made it an easy choice in the end. And given the well run marketing campaign and ultimately a very satisfying result on auction day, I definitely believe it was the right choice.

James Karantonis

James Karantonis

  4.7   (72 reviews)
over 9 years ago
Wow, a great result.

James and his wonderful team made a very difficult time so easy with their professional but very personal attention to detail. Their excellent presentation brought wonderful results for our family. Definitely five stars from us.

James Karantonis

James Karantonis

  4.7   (72 reviews)
over 9 years ago
Sale of property

From our first meeting with James, Billy and Zack, it was clear that they were honest people and knew the market well. We wanted an agent that was going to give us genuine feedback about our house and how the campaign was going, and James and the Buxton team were able to meet our needs. They kept us up to date with reports, feedback, and how open inspections were going. On auction day, about 6 Buxton team members assisted with the sale of our house and successfully achieved a price we were happy with. Keep up the good work, James and the team!

James Karantonis

James Karantonis

  4.7   (72 reviews)
over 9 years ago
Thanks James

We did our homework before signing with James to sell our family home. It was clear that James was No.1 in our area so the decision was not hard. We were impressed by James confidence and communication skills. He is surrounded you a great team at Buxtons. Thanks to Rachel who put in a big effort. Also, the Buxton team on the day of the auction worked so hard to get a good price for us. We'll done James and team.

James Karantonis

James Karantonis

  4.7   (72 reviews)
181 - 192 of 221
© 2026 RateMyAgent