Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
26 reviewsacross 10 different locations, showing 12.
17 days ago
Tony is an amazing Agent!

I recently purchased a property with the assistance of Tony Licastro, and I couldn't be happier with the experience. From the very beginning, Tony was professional, knowledgeable and genuinely committed to helping me find the right property. He was always available to answer my questions, kept me informed throughout the entire process and made what could have been a stressful experience feel smooth and straightforward. What really stood out was Tony's honesty, responsiveness and dedication. He went above and beyond to ensure everything was handled efficiently and that I felt confident at every stage of the purchase. I highly recommend Tony Licastro to anyone looking to buy or sell property. If you're after an agent who genuinely cares about his clients and delivers outstanding service, Tony is the person to call. Thank you again, Tony!

Tony Licastro

Tony Licastro

  4.9   (334 reviews)
18 days ago
Integrity, professionalism and deep knowledge of the Inner West market

We recently purchased our home in Croydon Park through Tony, and we couldn't be happier with the experience. From our very first inspection through to settlement, Tony was friendly, professional, and transparent in every interaction. Purchasing a home can be a stressful process, but Tony made it as smooth as possible by keeping us informed, responding promptly to our questions, and communicating openly throughout the transaction. What stood out most was their honesty and integrity. At every stage, we felt we were being provided with clear and accurate information, which gave us confidence in making such an important decision. He treated both us and the vendor with respect and professionalism, creating a positive experience for everyone involved. We genuinely appreciated their approachable manner and commitment to ensuring the purchase progressed smoothly. We would have no hesitation in recommending Tony to anyone looking to buy or sell a property and would gladly work with them again in the future.

Tony Licastro

Tony Licastro

  4.9   (334 reviews)
19 days ago
Very trusting and great communication.

Tony was excellent at guiding us on how we should market our property to get the best result. We feel that he did a fantastic job and we are extremely happy with the outcome.

Tony Licastro

Tony Licastro

  4.9   (334 reviews)
20 days ago
Exceptional professionalism

Tony consistently delivers exceptional results and has a remarkable ability to make things happen. His professionalism, expertise, and unwavering commitment set him apart. Throughout the entire process, we felt genuinely supported and confident in his care, and we couldn’t be happier with both the experience and the outcome.

Tony Licastro

Tony Licastro

  4.9   (334 reviews)
25 days ago
Purchasing a property

We had missed out on a property beforehand and when the one next door became available Tony was straight on the phone to us..suffice it to say that with Tony’s assistance we purchased it almost immediately..Tony was great from start to finish and we look forward to seeing him once we build our new home..

Tony Licastro

Tony Licastro

  4.9   (334 reviews)
26 days ago
A true professional, honest, transparent and truly knowledgeable

Working with Gavin was an absolute pleasure. He looked after all there was to look after and always kept us in the loop. He was in absolute control of selling our property, and we followed the suggestions with great success. The advice and market knowledge were spot-on. He was always available to answer any questions we had which made the whole experience stress free. All of his hard work achieved a fantastic sale result. We were completely impressed with his professionalism.

Gavin Sanna

Gavin Sanna

  4.9   (152 reviews)
about 1 month ago
The best in the business!

I had a great experience working with Tony. He was professional, responsive and supportive throughout the process, and helped me secure the property with confidence. I really appreciated his guidance and would happily recommend him.

Tony Licastro

Tony Licastro

  4.9   (334 reviews)
about 2 months ago
Sincerely recommend Tony Licastro as a real estate agent

We have known Tony for over 10 years, and he has always been genuine, reliable, and very professional. He recently helped us sell our property, and we were very happy with the final result. However, what stood out most to us was not just the price, but the entire process. Tony was extremely attentive and thoughtful throughout the sale. He consistently acted in our best interests, communicated clearly, and made sure every detail was handled properly. What we really appreciated is that he treated our property with the same level of care and attention, even though it was not a large or high-value listing. There was no difference in effort or respect. His honesty, responsibility, and long-term approach to relationships are what make him stand out. He genuinely cares about both buyers and sellers, and that is rare in this industry. We are very grateful for his support and would not hesitate to recommend him to anyone looking to buy or sell a property.

Tony Licastro

Tony Licastro

  4.9   (334 reviews)
2 months ago
Very Happy with the Result

Tony kept me informed every week after open home inspections We ended up selling prior to auction which was a smart move I’m very happy with the result !!! I will always use Tony when considering selling….Thank you Tony

Tony Licastro

Tony Licastro

  4.9   (334 reviews)
2 months ago
Shining results

Tony Licastro definitely knows his stuff. Instead of promising prices in this tough market, he concentrated on strategies of how to get the best price and market our property with brilliant results. He was always so positive. Thanks Tony We highly recommend Tony

Tony Licastro

Tony Licastro

  4.9   (334 reviews)
2 months ago
Brilliant service

We are so glad we chose Tony to sell our second home. He has guided us and produced fantastic results. There was never a time where we were not sure what was going on, Tony always kept us informed and was confident in everything he did. It’s very hard to recommend someone these days, but we highly recommend Tony Licastro. We truly trust him.

Tony Licastro

Tony Licastro

  4.9   (334 reviews)
2 months ago
Frank Como & the team at Elders did an amazing job

Frank Como & the team at Elders helped me sell my property in Croydon Park. Frank did an amazing job with the sale he kept us informed every single day with what was going on. The team got us record price in Croydon Park for a 2 bedroom semi detached house thanks to Sebastian the auctioneer Frank Como and the team. Frank also helped me find another property in Earlwood which I thank him and the team once again for the help. If you are considering buying or selling Frank Como will get you the best results for you. Regards Guy

Frank Como

Frank Como

  4.9   (69 reviews)
1 - 12 of 26
© 2026 RateMyAgent