Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
1259 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Buyer review
Couldn't recommend her more!
4 days ago
Couldn't recommend her more!

There is genuinely no one I would trust more when buying a home than Su Reynolds. Buying a house is such a huge financial and emotional investment, and having someone kind, honest and genuinely supportive makes all the difference. Su was incredibly fair to both us as buyers and the sellers, always making sure everyone felt informed and cared for. She brought so much warmth and integrity to what can be a stressful process. We're grateful to have had her by our side. Couldn't recommend her more!

Su Reynolds

Su Reynolds

  4.9   (371 reviews)
Buyer review
Very personable
6 days ago
Very personable

Very personable, fair in the negotiation and helpful throughout the process.

Su Reynolds

Su Reynolds

  4.9   (371 reviews)
Seller review
I would certainly recommend Su and her Team.
6 days ago
I would certainly recommend Su and her Team.

Su Reynolds was awesome in her knowledge of the market and recent shift in values. Her attention to our needs was thoughtful and timely as my sister and I were selling as POA's and live interstate. Nothing was too much trouble for Su and her entire team. I would certainly recommend Su and her Team.

Su Reynolds

Su Reynolds

  4.9   (371 reviews)
Buyer review
Highly recommended
10 days ago
Highly recommended

Su made buying a house in Byron Bay as smooth as could be. Having served the local market for 36 years (and with myself having 7 years of local knowledge) it was a pleasure not to have to put up with any hard sell tactics. Su was especially helpful in managing the negotiations with the seller in as transparent a way as possible enabling me to lock in a deal within 2 days of viewing the house with a "win-win" result for the buyer and seller. Highly recommended.

Su Reynolds

Su Reynolds

  4.9   (371 reviews)
Seller review
Su is committed ,and shows her passion to her work
10 days ago
Su is committed ,and shows her passion to her work

We had the pleasure of Su assisting us with the selling of our property. Su always showed integrity and respect for us as the clientele. Su is very professional and extremely trustworthy within her role.Always going above and beyond . Su is committed ,and shows her passion to her work during this transition. We were very satisfied with what Su done and provided for us in selling our home.

Su Reynolds

Su Reynolds

  4.9   (371 reviews)
Seller review
She has a great team that ensures that everything is taken care of
10 days ago
She has a great team that ensures that everything is taken care of

Su is a local who has worked in this industry for as long as we have lived in the area. It made perfect sense to call her to assist us with the sale of our property in Suffolk Park. Su knows the market well and has the experience and skill to negotiate a favourable outcome. She has a great team that ensures that everything is taken care of. Her communication exceeded my expectations as I was kept informed every step of the way. She is a specialist who is true to her word. I highly recommend her.

Su Reynolds

Su Reynolds

  4.9   (371 reviews)
Seller review
Seller of a unit in Byron Bay, NSW
13 days ago
Seller of a unit in Byron Bay, NSW

Sharon knows the market based on many years experience. I should have listed to her from the start with her price guidance on my property. It was a difficult market to sell into, but Sharon kept the listing active, and varied the promotion and price with my agreement. I was consulted, listened to and kept informed along the way and eventually we achieved success.

Sharon McInnes

Sharon McInnes

  4.8   (87 reviews)
Buyer review
Buyer of a unit in Byron Bay, NSW
13 days ago
Buyer of a unit in Byron Bay, NSW

Sharon was an absolute pleasure to work with from the first inspection right through to exchange. She knows the Byron market inside out, answered every question honestly, and made sure I had the full picture before making any decisions. Professional, genuine and easy to trust. I’d happily recommend her to anyone buying or selling in Byron Bay.

Sharon McInnes

Sharon McInnes

  4.8   (87 reviews)
Seller review
Seller of a house in Brunswick Heads, NSW
about 2 months ago
Seller of a house in Brunswick Heads, NSW

Sharon is the consummate professional. She is authentic, loves her work, and understands the psyche of sellers and buyers. Through all stages of of the campaign I could see that she focussed on a win-win for the seller and buyer, ensuring buyers’ needs aligned with the property, thus reporting only on genuine buyers! Also clear was Sharon’s team play with Paul Prior (sales partner) and an impressive inhouse marketing team which provided information and insights throughout the campaign 🦄👍😊

Sharon McInnes

Sharon McInnes

  4.8   (87 reviews)
Seller review
Seller of a house in Mullumbimby, NSW
2 months ago
Seller of a house in Mullumbimby, NSW

Extremely helpful throughout all the phases of selling my home. Made me feel comfortable with market knowledge and insight. Sharon was very punctual and reliable from start to finish. I would highly recommend her !

Sharon McInnes

Sharon McInnes

  4.8   (87 reviews)
Buyer review
Buyer of a house in Brunswick Heads, NSW
3 months ago
Buyer of a house in Brunswick Heads, NSW

Sharon made this process easy :-). As you might know, and we know from past experiences, buying a house can be stressful and sometimes even heartbreaking. Sharon helped us avoid those challanges and made the experience as pleasant and smooth as can be, Thank you Sharon!

Sharon McInnes

Sharon McInnes

  4.8   (87 reviews)
Seller review
Genuinely helpful & Friendly
3 months ago
Genuinely helpful & Friendly

Comprehensive knowledge of the market. Genuinely helpful & Friendly Along with Anna Gilham, they conducted 16 property inspections very efficiently & subtly. Extensive data base. My wife & I cannot speak too highly of both Su & Anna.

Su Reynolds

Su Reynolds

  4.9   (371 reviews)
1 - 12 of 1,259
© 2026 RateMyAgent