Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
318 reviewsacross 27 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, reliable, supportive, honest, responsive, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Steven went above and beyond to help us sell our first home!
9 months ago
Steven went above and beyond to help us sell our first home!

My husband and I had a wonderful experience selling our first home with Steven. From the very beginning he was easy to reach, always very responsive to our calls and messages, answering questions or concerns with patience and clarity. Steven was flexible and supportive in helping us sell our home from a distance and purposeful in giving directions for next steps and maintenance needed on our property. He went above and beyond in the weeks leading up to and during the weekend of our first open home, even holding additional walk-throughs early in Sunday morning! We received several high offers and sold our property above what we had originally expected. We are so happy with Steven’s work and recommend him highly.

Steven Garay

Steven Garay

  4.9   (487 reviews)
Buyer review
Pleasure to deal with
9 months ago
Pleasure to deal with

Very professional and also caring. Was a fantastic experience dealing with Steven.

Steven Garay

Steven Garay

  4.9   (487 reviews)
Buyer review
Great communicator, very punctual and professional
9 months ago
Great communicator, very punctual and professional

Steven was a prompt communicator who assisted in explaining specific real estate processes which made buying our first property a little less daunting. We appreciate all the assistance, effort and attention he provided us during our dealings and the integrity and honesty he maintained during the entire process.

Steven Garay

Steven Garay

  4.9   (487 reviews)
Buyer review
Good communicator
9 months ago
Good communicator

Steven was professional and responded promptly to emails

Steven Garay

Steven Garay

  4.9   (487 reviews)
Seller review
The only agent for mcgraths
9 months ago
The only agent for mcgraths

Steven Garay is the only agent I’d recommend in McGraths Hill. My home had been on the market for 7 months with another agent and nothing happened. Steven listed it as an off-market sale and within just 1 week, he sold it for a great price. His communication was next level – always keeping me updated and making the whole process smooth and stress-free. What my previous agent couldn’t achieve in 7 months with multiple open homes, Steven achieved in a week. Don’t hesitate to use Steven – he truly delivers.

Steven Garay

Steven Garay

  4.9   (487 reviews)
Buyer review
Fantastic service
9 months ago
Fantastic service

Great communication, knows the area, good at giving instructions. Easy to chat to.

Steven Garay

Steven Garay

  4.9   (487 reviews)
Seller review
Professional, Personable, Precise
9 months ago
Professional, Personable, Precise

We met Steven Garay 5 years ago when we were searching for our first home. We didn’t end up purchasing from Steven but he left a lasting impression. When it came time to sell our home Steven was the first agent that came to mind. We’re glad we chose Steven as he was able to secure a great result for us, and did it in just 4 weeks! Steven certainly looks the part, but don’t hold his sharp dress sense against him! Spend a few minutes chatting with him and you’ll see he’s genuinely passionate about what he does, knows the local market very well and manages to help both buyer and seller navigate though the process and come out the other side feeling like a winner. Steve acts with professionalism, confidence, personality and integrity. I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend him when it comes to representing your property and would definitely use him again if we ever sell.

Steven Garay

Steven Garay

  4.9   (487 reviews)
Buyer review
Excellent service
9 months ago
Excellent service

Found Steven’s service was excellent from start to finish with clear transparent communication between the agent, vendor & myself. Would highly recommend Steven for anyone looking to buy & or sell.

Steven Garay

Steven Garay

  4.9   (487 reviews)
Buyer review
Expert Guidance Every Step of the Way
10 months ago
Expert Guidance Every Step of the Way

From the very first conversation to the final handshake, Bart was nothing short of exceptional. Selling our home and buying one felt like a daunting task, but he made the entire process seamless, strategic, and surprisingly enjoyable. What stood out: Expert guidance: Bart knew the market inside and out, helping us price our home perfectly and negotiate a good deal on the new one. Clear communication: Every step was explained with clarity and patience. We always felt informed and empowered to make decisions. Unwavering support: Whether it was answering questions or calming our nerves during inspections, they were always there with a steady hand and a reassuring smile. Highly recommended!! Thanks to his dedication!!! If you're looking for someone who combines deep expertise with genuine care, Bart is the agent you want by your side.

Bart Portelli

Bart Portelli

  5   (65 reviews)
Seller review
Professional, great communication, friendly,
11 months ago
Professional, great communication, friendly,

Steven was great with the whole process of selling our house. Great knowledge of the market for McGraths Hill. He gave us great advice preparing our house to go to market. The communication in the whole process was outstanding. He didn't stop there steven has been very helpful advising us in our future search for our retirement home Thankyou Steven

Steven Garay

Steven Garay

  4.9   (487 reviews)
Buyer review
Great communication
11 months ago
Great communication

Steven was great! He was efficient and was always prompt to reply. He was available to allow for extra viewings of the house to accomodate our work hours and had great knowledge of the area. He also walked us through each step when purchasing the property and was in constant communication with us to ensure a smooth process.

Steven Garay

Steven Garay

  4.9   (487 reviews)
Seller review
Outstanding Agent!
11 months ago
Outstanding Agent!

From our first meeting with Bart, he was professional and patient and took the time to explain the local market and relevant marketing strategies to us. Throughout our home-selling process, Bart was incredibly communicative. He promptly answered calls and emails, keeping us informed about every development. We were very impressed with Bart's negotiation skills - using his local market knowledge, he managed to increase the purchase price by almost $90,000 from the first offer made by the purchasers. We cannot recommend Bart enough if you are looking for a great agent! You won’t be disappointed.

Bart Portelli

Bart Portelli

  5   (65 reviews)
37 - 48 of 318
© 2026 RateMyAgent