Our profile

Our reviews

  4.8  
49 reviewsacross 10 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: responsive, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Landlord review
Outstanding Professionalism
over 1 year ago
Outstanding Professionalism

Chisholm and Gamon have been managing my property for several years. I have found them to be proactive and insightful, and importantly complete requests with no fuss. They have a defining difference. That is their knowledge of the Port Melbourne property market. They are also excellent in their dealings with tenants. A special call out to Jess who embodies what a great property manager is.

Chisholm & Gamon Jellis Craig Elwood

Chisholm & Gamon Jellis Craig Elwood

  4.9   (1011 reviews)
Tenant review
Jemma was super helpful
over 1 year ago
Jemma was super helpful

Jemma was super helpful when we were applying for our apartment. Her communication was always prompt and she helped us every step of the way during the application process.

Chisholm & Gamon Jellis Craig Elwood

Chisholm & Gamon Jellis Craig Elwood

  4.9   (1011 reviews)
Landlord review
Wrong advice from agent cost me dearly
over 1 year ago
Wrong advice from agent cost me dearly

Unfortunately, due to the 12 consecutive interest rate rises, I needed to raise rent for my tenant who was currently paying 360 per week. I suggested increasing it to additional 100 per month but guidance from agent was to increase to 500 per week which is in line with the market. I followed their advice and 2 weeks after I received notice that my tenant of 5 years will be vacating. Since then, I have had to spend over 3k in getting new carpets, paints and also leasing fees. It took 3 weeks for it to be rented out and I had to do my own advertising in Facebook as the agent was not getting any success getting anyone through the door. We reduced the rental fee from 500 to 430 which was close to what I originally wanted to increase the price to. If I did not follow their advice, I would have had a happy renter still renting my place and I would not have had lost of 7k of rental income and labor costs and letting fees. Super disappointed with Chisholm and Gamon as their advice left me stressed and out of pocket of 7k!

Chisholm & Gamon Jellis Craig Elwood

Chisholm & Gamon Jellis Craig Elwood

  4.9   (1011 reviews)
Tenant review
Prompt communication
over 1 year ago
Prompt communication

C&G have been very helpful and prompt with their communication and sorting out any issues.

Chisholm & Gamon Jellis Craig Elwood

Chisholm & Gamon Jellis Craig Elwood

  4.9   (1011 reviews)
Landlord review
Very happy with the service
over 1 year ago
Very happy with the service

Very happy with the service

Chisholm & Gamon Jellis Craig Elwood

Chisholm & Gamon Jellis Craig Elwood

  4.9   (1011 reviews)
Landlord review
Review of Herbert St Agent
over 1 year ago
Review of Herbert St Agent

Dear Chisholm & Gamon, All I have to contribute is that if I had a problem with my Agent, I would first address it with the Agent and if needed, discuss it with the Managers. Thank you, Janine

Chisholm & Gamon Jellis Craig Elwood

Chisholm & Gamon Jellis Craig Elwood

  4.9   (1011 reviews)
Tenant review
'An absolute delight'
over 1 year ago
'An absolute delight'

Renting a property through Chisholm & Gamon - and particularly Simone - was an absolute delight. Simone is a considered Property Manager who was both responsive and proactive throughout the tenancy and when repairs were required. Highly recommend!

Chisholm & Gamon Jellis Craig Elwood

Chisholm & Gamon Jellis Craig Elwood

  4.9   (1011 reviews)
Tenant review
'Super responsive, friendly and helpful.'
over 1 year ago
'Super responsive, friendly and helpful.'

Simone was a great property manager. Super responsive, friendly and helpful. We had a great experience and would happily recommend her.

Chisholm & Gamon Jellis Craig Elwood

Chisholm & Gamon Jellis Craig Elwood

  4.9   (1011 reviews)
Landlord review
Chisolm & Gamon has done a sterling job caring for and managing my property for nearly 10 years
over 1 year ago
Chisolm & Gamon has done a sterling job caring for and managing my property for nearly 10 years

I developed a mixed use block of apartments with a retail on ground floor nearly 10 years ago. Since that time the Chisolm * Gamon team, largely led by Samantha Richards has looked after my asset in a proactive and considered fashion. If anything is an issue for my tenants or the asset itself, I am promptly informed about it and presented with sensible solutions to continue to look after the building. When I needed to go to VCAT for a difficult tenant or seek new tenants , they have been proactive in looking after my interests adn ensuring my financial position is sensibly protected. I would have no hesitation recommending SAM and the team to anyone in the Bayside area to look after their property.

Chisholm & Gamon Jellis Craig Elwood

Chisholm & Gamon Jellis Craig Elwood

  4.9   (1011 reviews)
Tenant review
Fantastic experience in Melbourne
over 1 year ago
Fantastic experience in Melbourne

I had a fantastic experience working with Tina in finding my new home. She demonstrated exceptional professionalism and a deep understanding of the real estate market. Throughout the process, she was incredibly responsive, addressing all my questions and concerns with patience and expertise. Chisholm & Gamon Property went above and beyond to ensure that every detail was handled smoothly, making what could have been a stressful experience feel seamless and enjoyable.

Chisholm & Gamon Jellis Craig Elwood

Chisholm & Gamon Jellis Craig Elwood

  4.9   (1011 reviews)
Landlord review
excellent service
over 1 year ago
excellent service

market knowledge is excellent, service is excellent and communications are also good

Chisholm & Gamon Jellis Craig Elwood

Chisholm & Gamon Jellis Craig Elwood

  4.9   (1011 reviews)
Tenant review
Helpful and compassionate
over 1 year ago
Helpful and compassionate

Renee and Samantha and all the other girls have been so very supportive and helpful in my journey to find a new home for my son and I. So understanding and easy to work with. It’s all been very easy.

Chisholm & Gamon Jellis Craig Elwood

Chisholm & Gamon Jellis Craig Elwood

  4.9   (1011 reviews)
25 - 36 of 49
© 2026 RateMyAgent