Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
681 reviewsacross 26 different locations, showing 12.
about 2 years ago
Exceptionally professional, personable and a pleasure to do business with.

Early in 2024, we considered selling a small house in Brighton which had been in our family for almost 40 years. It was a daunting prospect because we'd not bought or sold any real estate during that time. How to begin? Naturally we talked to a few friends in the suburb who had some experience of local agents. There were several good recommendations but we always like to do our own research. We were aware of Nick Johnstone Real Estate through their prominent activity in the Bayside area and, personally, I like their billboard design and had been very impressed by their auctioneers, Nick and Joe, when we'd gone along to watch a few of their auctions. We contacted Nick and invited him to look at our property. It was a good, no nonsense meeting that gave us some confidence in his knowledge and their process. Trust the process, Nick told us; an we did just that. Fees are fees and there's not a great deal of difference from one agent to the other so we decided Nick was our best and preferred option because he has a great manner with people and we're not a push over. We met more of Nick's Brighton team over the next month once we'd signed up and decided on the auction date. Everything they did was spot on, extra special and left nothing behind. Our whole family loved Nick, Katie and Natasha. They are truly genuine straight shooters who cared about us and got us a fabulous outcome on auction day. Nick doesn't do things in half measure - a true professional and lots of fun to work with. Thanks to Nick and his fabulous team at NJRE, you have helped change our lives for the better.

Nick Johnstone

Nick Johnstone

  4.9   (592 reviews)
about 2 years ago
Friendly, communicative and professional

Nick was the selling agent for a property I recently purchased. He was approachable and happy to discuss the process and intricacies of the potential purchase at the outset. Thereafter he was communicative about terms and potential settlements dates etc. On auction day, he was an excellent auctioneer, extolling the virtues of the property and its location without dragging out what is necessarily a stressful event for most vendors and would-be purchasers.

Nick Johnstone

Nick Johnstone

  4.9   (592 reviews)
about 2 years ago
Trusted and driven real estate professional.

Katie is truly an amazing person who takes pride in her profession and is driven to provide the best outcome for her vendor. I cannot thank Katie enough for all the hard work, passion and care she invested in my sale process. Whilst I was overseas Katie and her team ensured that I was kept up to date in every time zone and remained calm and positive throughout the campaign. Katie really went way beyond my expectations, whilst providing clear and concise feedback at all times. I have no hesitation in recommending Katie for your next sale. Thank you so much!!!

Katie Mactier

Katie Mactier

  5   (37 reviews)
about 2 years ago
Genuine, thoughtful, invested and exceeded expectations

We were lucky enough to purchase our property from Rachael and equally as lucky to instantly take her on as our agent to sell our property. Rachael is an absolute superstar and someone whom we have been blessed to work with. The diligence, communication, care, investment and transparency offered by Rachael were both welcomed and reassuring during a stressful time. She guided us through each step with care, kindness and market knowledge, and went above and beyond on multiple occasions. We highly recommend Rachael to anyone who wants to sell their property - we never felt like we were given a sales pitch but instead felt she was genuinely invested in getting a positive outcome for all parties. Thankyou Rachael!

Rachael Cavallaro

Rachael Cavallaro

  5   (20 reviews)
about 2 years ago
Straight Forward, Pulled No Punches and Direct

From my first meeting with Nick through to the sale of property, Nick was direct in his communication and his professionalism stood out. After walking through the property with me he was honest and advised me to sell the property as is, keep the tenants so the rent keeps coming in, do a minimal marketing photo shoot, run a 3-week advertising campaign and auction on the 4th Saturday morning. And that is almost exactly what happened. My property was sold just prior to auction day. The selling price was within the range that Nick had quoted to me. It is quite clear that Nick knows the Brighton and Sandringham market area.

Nick Johnstone

Nick Johnstone

  4.9   (592 reviews)
about 2 years ago
A very impressive and effective operator

Delivered on all fronts in a short period of time, very effective communication skills and professional in all respects.

Jonty Wells

Jonty Wells

  5   (33 reviews)
about 2 years ago
The ultimate real estate professional!

We cannot thank Katie enough for all the hard work, passion and care she invested in us and our sale process since our very first meeting! Katie went above and beyond on every front in the lead up to and during our sale campaign. Working around the clock, always with a smile and positive approach, Katie helped us navigate this process with confidence. As interstate vendors Katie exceeded all our expectations and truly excelled at ensuring our house was prepared for sale to the highest standard in a very tight timeframe. No detail was overlooked and the month long campaign went so smoothly thanks to her hard work and commitment. Professional, confident, honest, compassionate, hard working and an expert at what she does! We highly recommend Katie and her team!

Katie Mactier

Katie Mactier

  5   (37 reviews)
about 2 years ago
Exceptional agent

Jonty is a hard working, responsive, and genuinely kind agent. He was a pleasure to communicate with and especially helpful throughout the whole process. We highly recommend Jonty.

Jonty Wells

Jonty Wells

  5   (33 reviews)
about 2 years ago
Exceptional

Nicks market knowledge was exceptional. His handling of the vendors and my negotiation was fast and painfree. I will definitely use Nick Johnstone again.

Nick Johnstone

Nick Johnstone

  4.9   (592 reviews)
about 2 years ago
Fantastic service!

Great service we loved working with you guys! Excited for our next chapter in our new home :)

Nick Johnstone

Nick Johnstone

  4.9   (592 reviews)
about 2 years ago
Finally sold

I didn’t have a lot to do with Nick but the one we did speak he seemed to know what he was talking about.

Nick Johnstone

Nick Johnstone

  4.9   (592 reviews)
about 2 years ago
Outstanding personalized service !!

After selling property with other agents, Nick and his team were by far the best we had ever delt with. Very understanding of our circumstances our needs and got the result we wanted in 3 weeks. I recommend Nick Johnstone Real Estate to all my family and friends. Nobody does it better.

Nick Johnstone

Nick Johnstone

  4.9   (592 reviews)
121 - 132 of 681
Jellis Craig Nick Johnstone (Jellis Craig Brighton)
Contact Jellis Craig Nick Johnstone (Jellis Craig Brighton)
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent