Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
671 reviewsacross 26 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: supportive, friendly, reliable, responsive, honest, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Our home of over 40 years
almost 10 years ago
Our home of over 40 years

Having reached a stage in life where we needed to downsize and concentrate on relaxation and good health, the marketing of our home required the services of someone we could talk to and communicate with and feel at ease with - and that is what Paul & Penny delivered in spades. Throughout our marketing period, they both impressed our family with their dedication and commitment to finding the right buyer for our home. Professional and impressive - they are both truly successful individuals who place their client's needs above their own. Paul Witney and Penny Hancock will certainly be hearing from our friends and family for help with their future property needs. Thanks Paul and Penny.

Paul Witney

Paul Witney

  4.9   (333 reviews)
Seller review
Shane knight
about 10 years ago
Shane knight

This is the second house Jay has sold for me, I would strongly recommend Jay for anyone thinking of selling.

Jay Hinde

Jay Hinde

  4.9   (327 reviews)
Buyer review
feed back for Jay
about 10 years ago
feed back for Jay

Hello I could not answer Market Knowledge as we had looked around . Jay Has very good communication skills. He it all that he could to help us. I have suggested that feed back should to sent after people have had a chance to settle in and are not bogged down with packing... also this would not let me exit if I didn't answer two question very annoying !! which does not add to the experience as time is valuable !! so question 1 I rated low because it did not apply !! and on that note I did not appreciate the sale price being advertised !!!

Jay Hinde

Jay Hinde

  4.9   (327 reviews)
Seller review
Thank you Paul & Penny
about 10 years ago
Thank you Paul & Penny

The advice that Paul Witney and Penny Hancock gave us in the process of selling our home was invaluable. They made sure that we understood how to present the house in its best possible light, so that it would appeal to the widest range of potential buyers. And most importantly they gave us the confidence to secure the price that they felt reflected the true value of our home. We are very grateful to both of them. Paul & Kerry West

Paul Witney

Paul Witney

  4.9   (333 reviews)
Buyer review
Highly recommended.
about 10 years ago
Highly recommended.

Jay did a great job selling our house last year and when he let us know there was something we might be interested in buying we were excited to take a look. Jay was always approachable and willing to spend time with us when needed. He is polite and professional and dealing with him has been a pleasure.

Jay Hinde

Jay Hinde

  4.9   (327 reviews)
Seller review
Couldn't be happier
about 10 years ago
Couldn't be happier

Jay was the Real Estate agent responsible for the sale of my Deceased Estate Bateau Bay house in April 2016. His professionalism, enthusiasm, and communication at every point exceeded my expectations.

Jay Hinde

Jay Hinde

  4.9   (327 reviews)
Seller review
Paul worked hard to sell our home with communication, negotiation & knowledge selling our home.
about 10 years ago
Paul worked hard to sell our home with communication, negotiation & knowledge selling our home.

Paul communicated with three generations (living in our house) while selling our home. Paul is a polite, patient and explained many of our annoying questions, sometimes out of work time. Paul & his staff were tenacious in their belief/effort, our home would sell with Paul finding our perfect new home in the same area - thank you!

Paul Witney

Paul Witney

  4.9   (333 reviews)
Seller review
Reliable Hard Working Agents
about 10 years ago
Reliable Hard Working Agents

Paul Witney and Penny Hancock are reliable hard working agents. You get two agents for the price of one!! At the first meeting they gave us a considered market price range for our property. During the first open home they had a buyer make a firm offer. They continued with careful negotiation with the buyer and us and closed the deal at a reasonable price within the range. We were very happy with the complete process which was conducted professionally. Strongly recommend Paul and Penny to anyone in the market to sell.

Paul Witney

Paul Witney

  4.9   (333 reviews)
Seller review
Thank you Jay
about 10 years ago
Thank you Jay

We took a long time deciding to sell .. Jay's follow-up was regular, but never pestering, always friendly. His suggestions about marketing a rundown property, but one with considerable potential, were spot-on. He is meticulous in follow-up and keeping us abreast of the sale process. Highly commend his advice and excellent service.

Jay Hinde

Jay Hinde

  4.9   (327 reviews)
Buyer review
Purchase of Bateau Bay Property
about 10 years ago
Purchase of Bateau Bay Property

I have met Paul on a number of occasions at a variety of properties. I found him to be knowledgeable about these properties and the area. He is able to identify strong points to a property and possesses a good sense of humor together with good communication skills. I also found he was generous and sincere in offering help and assistance to an out-of-area buyer. Negotiations on the purchase of my new property were conducted in a friendly and courteous fashion and completed in a very timely and satisfactory manner. I would like to thank Paul for all his assistance in completing this transaction.

Paul Witney

Paul Witney

  4.9   (333 reviews)
Seller review
Great Result
about 10 years ago
Great Result

Paul was excellent to deal with and helped us achieve a great result in a timely manner. Always available, great communication.

Paul Witney

Paul Witney

  4.9   (333 reviews)
Buyer review
Knowledgeable
about 10 years ago
Knowledgeable

This is the second time we have bought a property off him. This last one was a fixer upper and his assistance with Trade contacts was out of this world. We know what it would have cost us with our trades people and found that all his contacts were around the same price range. I had dealings with other agents up in the area and have not been as satisfied as I have with him.

Jay Hinde

Jay Hinde

  4.9   (327 reviews)
553 - 564 of 671
Ray White Bateau Bay | Killarney Vale
Contact Ray White Bateau Bay | Killarney Vale
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent