Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
851 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: responsive, friendly, supportive, reliable, honest, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Great experience
almost 2 years ago
Great experience

We had a great experience buying our property through Rhys. He was very transparent and responsive. We appreciated his genuineness as first home buyers, new to the process of purchasing a home.

Rhys Afford

Rhys Afford

  5   (150 reviews)
Seller review
Awesome thanks
almost 2 years ago
Awesome thanks

We sold our low value property in a difficult market in MLB, but we were left with the thought that Rhys left nothing on the table. We were really happy with the result.

Rhys Afford

Rhys Afford

  5   (150 reviews)
Seller review
Great result and great service
almost 2 years ago
Great result and great service

Pau recently sold a property on me behalf where I had a power of attorney for a long time client. His assistance with all things related to the property sale was excellent as was his consideration of the circumstances surrounding the property sale. I would recommend Paul for anyone looking to sell their property.

Paul McDonald

Paul McDonald

  5   (77 reviews)
Seller review
Amazing estate agent, look no further
almost 2 years ago
Amazing estate agent, look no further

We reached out to Rhys after years with using McDonald Upton as our rental company, so we decided go with them to sell our property. The whole experience with Rhys has been exceptional. Rhys has made this whole process seamless, from organising trades people to staging and finally the sale of our property. We cannot thank Rhys enough, he truely is amazing in all aspects, we highly recommend Rhys if your thinking of selling , as he goes above and beyond.

Rhys Afford

Rhys Afford

  5   (150 reviews)
Seller review
Professional, trustworthy, and delivered results..
almost 2 years ago
Professional, trustworthy, and delivered results..

Working with Simon was an absolute pleasure from start to finish. He was professional, trustworthy, and managed our expectations every step of the way. His expert advice and deep understanding of the market helped us get the price we wanted in just 7 days! Simon made the entire process smooth and stress-free, and we always felt confident in his guidance. We highly recommend him to anyone looking for a reliable, experienced real estate agent.

Simon Cookson

Simon Cookson

  4.9   (85 reviews)
Seller review
McDonald Upton's professional, personalised
almost 2 years ago
McDonald Upton's professional, personalised

McDonald Upton recently helped us with the sale of my mother's Essendon home, a home that had been in the family for almost seventy years. Our initial meeting was with Paul McDonald. He wasn't the only agent approached. Like most of the others interviewed, he showed a professional enthusiasm for the task and a keen understanding of Essendon's Real Estate climate. Unlike the others, his approach was low key, straightforward and for want of a better word, honest. Akin to a trusted family retainer. In other circumstances you'd be happy to call him friend. As the campaign progressed we were continually kept in the loop and it was clear that he, Rhys and the team behind them were hard at it. This was borne out when, on the day of the auction, half of Melbourne turned out for the event. The result was very satisfactory, both for ourselves and, I believe, for the purchaser. Smiles all around. And it must be said Rhys Afford is a very smart young man, he having chosen such an astute mentor. Thanks again McDonald Upton. Job well done.

Rhys Afford

Rhys Afford

  5   (150 reviews)
Seller review
Stellar performance for difficult property
almost 2 years ago
Stellar performance for difficult property

Property was outside Simon’s territory and the put the extra work in so as to achieve an excellent result!

Simon Cookson

Simon Cookson

  4.9   (85 reviews)
Seller review
Outstanding
about 2 years ago
Outstanding

I had the pleasure of working with Rhys Afford from McDonald Upton, and I couldn’t be more satisfied with the experience. From our first meeting to the final closing, Rhys was professional, knowledgeable, and genuinely committed to helping me get the best result. I highly recommend Rhys Afford to anyone looking to buy or sell a home. Their dedication and passion for real estate truly set them apart. Thank you Rhys, for making my real estate journey so enjoyable.

Rhys Afford

Rhys Afford

  5   (150 reviews)
Seller review
Great experience and advice.
about 2 years ago
Great experience and advice.

Paul was excellent to deal with. His communication was perfect keeping us updated with every development. Always optimistic and assisted us with the stress in selling our family home. I would not hesitate to recommend Paul & the team at McDonald Upton to sell your home.

Paul McDonald

Paul McDonald

  5   (77 reviews)
Seller review
I Would Highly Recommend Simon As A Selling Agent In The Moonee Valley Area
about 2 years ago
I Would Highly Recommend Simon As A Selling Agent In The Moonee Valley Area

Simon is a very positive person and his experience, expertise and knowledge were impressive. He always provided prompt feedback after each ‘Open For Inspection’ and he provided helpful advice on preparing the property for sale. I really appreciated the professionalism of Simon and the McDonald / Upton Team.

Simon Cookson

Simon Cookson

  4.9   (85 reviews)
Seller review
Impressive Auctioneer
about 2 years ago
Impressive Auctioneer

Milo always went above and beyond to make sure we were informed and in control of the sale process. His auctioneering skills are quite impressive. From beginning to end, our experience with the entire team was faultless. If you are looking for an agent to get the job done. The McDonald Upton team reign supreme. Thank you Milo and your exceptional people. We would have no hesitation in engaging your services again in the future, you all made an incredibly stressful time much better for me and our family thank you.

Milo Rasinac

Milo Rasinac

  5   (29 reviews)
445 - 456 of 851
© 2026 RateMyAgent