Our profile

Our reviews

  4.7  
49 reviewsacross 22 different locations, showing 12.
Seller review
Extremely experienced agent
over 4 years ago
Extremely experienced agent

Natasha was an excellent agent and we couldn't have asked for more. We were referred to Natasha by friends who had recently sold their home with her. We are initially a bit unsure as Natasha hadn't sold a lot of homes in our suburb in particular. But we thought we would at least get an appraisal and see what she had to say. Our first meeting really impressed us. We could tell she was the best agent for us and one that had our interests at heart. It was obvious that she is not an agent just looking for a quick & easy sale, but one that gets the best outcome for the seller. That proved to be true. Her warmth, energy, professionalism and experience made the selling process a breeze. You can really tell that her negotiating skills are highly developed as we sold our home for well over what other agents had quoted. Nothing was a problem with Natasha and we just felt we had a true professional in our court the whole time. I really can't recommend her enough.

Natasha McElwaine

Natasha McElwaine

  4.7   (49 reviews)
Seller review
Confident and Committed
over 4 years ago
Confident and Committed

From the moment we met Natasha we knew that she was the one to sell our home. Natasha knew the market better than any other agent we met with. Our result shows this, as all the other agents told the price us it was not achievable. Natasha was grounded and her high level of integrity was evident. Thank you Natasha!!

Natasha McElwaine

Natasha McElwaine

  4.7   (49 reviews)
Seller review
Natasha sold our investment property in Maitland
over 4 years ago
Natasha sold our investment property in Maitland

Natasha has a unique skill of being able to balance the needs of clients and buyers in a way that makes all parties feel valued and listened to. She has great communication skills and her friendly easy going personality puts all parties at ease. We found her attentive and delightful to deal with and highly recommend her - particularly if you're selling your home as she will genuinely endeavour to get the best price for you.

Natasha McElwaine

Natasha McElwaine

  4.7   (49 reviews)
Seller review
Extremely happy.
over 4 years ago
Extremely happy.

Natasha was extremely easy to deal with and highly knowledgeable in the field ! Property sold before I knew it with a price tag both parties were happy with ! Super happy with Natasha’s work and will be returning in the future.

Natasha McElwaine

Natasha McElwaine

  4.7   (49 reviews)
Seller review
Excellent service.
over 4 years ago
Excellent service.

Very responsive and professional approach. Was kept fully informed throughout the sale process.

Natasha McElwaine

Natasha McElwaine

  4.7   (49 reviews)
Seller review
Warm, Friendly and Knowledgable
over 4 years ago
Warm, Friendly and Knowledgable

From the initial meeting, I was impressed! Natasha was warm, friendly, and above all knowledgeable. Selling our family home was obviously a very nerve-wracking experience but no question was too silly to ask and she happily answered all my phone calls and kept in touch every step of the way. Natasha was a pleasure to work with and if she's not the one selling your house, you are missing out!

Natasha McElwaine

Natasha McElwaine

  4.7   (49 reviews)
Seller review
Professional advice and very quick sale
over 4 years ago
Professional advice and very quick sale

No words to express our huge gratitude to Natasha and Staff from McElwaine Estate Agents on the professional advice we received for the very quick sale of our property in Berry Park. We were kept in the loop every step of the way with great advice on how to present the property ready for market. Natasha is honest and open without any hidden agendas. We have no hesitation in using and recommending Natasha in the future.

Natasha McElwaine

Natasha McElwaine

  4.7   (49 reviews)
Seller review
No hesitation in recommending McElwaine Estate Agents
over 4 years ago
No hesitation in recommending McElwaine Estate Agents

I bought the property with McElwaine Estate Agents just over four years ago and I found it to be a simple process then and it was just as simple to list it with Natasha four years later! The sale went through within the first week of listing and I'm beyond thrilled with the result! I found working with Natasha and her team to be an enjoyable, collaborative process and they were very open to feedback too. I appreciated the different approach to listing my property as it didn't fall into a common category and the result speaks for itself. Natasha knows her clients and the potential buyers. She took the time to understand what my plans were and who my property would directly appeal to. I was kept updated throughout but not obsessively so. I didn't need to know about every inquiry and trusted Natasha to do what she does best. When a serious offer was forthcoming, I knew the work had been done prior by Natasha and I didn't have to question anything. I have no hesitation in recommending McElwaine Estate Agents-

Natasha McElwaine

Natasha McElwaine

  4.7   (49 reviews)
Seller review
A wonderful experience
almost 5 years ago
A wonderful experience

We had a wonderful experience selling with McElwaine's. All of the staff were professional, friendly and approachable. Thank you!!

Natasha McElwaine

Natasha McElwaine

  4.7   (49 reviews)
Seller review
Very professional, friendly, and always obliging
almost 5 years ago
Very professional, friendly, and always obliging

Thank you so much for selling our property, very professional, friendly, and always obliging in every way. Thank you!

Natasha McElwaine

Natasha McElwaine

  4.7   (49 reviews)
Seller review
Best we've ever worked with in real estate
almost 5 years ago
Best we've ever worked with in real estate

Natasha is the best we've ever worked with in real estate. From the get-go she took very good care of us and held our hand throughout the process. Her suggestions in marketing the property was on point with exactly what todays buyers look for and her 20+ years of experience is evident in her negotiation skills. Even when unexpected situations arise, she was calm and poised and achieved an amazing outcome for us and the buyers. I cannot recommend Natasha and her team enough. Well done McElwaine!!

Natasha McElwaine

Natasha McElwaine

  4.7   (49 reviews)
Seller review
Natasha is amazing
almost 5 years ago
Natasha is amazing

Absolute pleasure to work with. Natasha is amazing at her job, I can’t recommend her highly enough.

Natasha McElwaine

Natasha McElwaine

  4.7   (49 reviews)
1 - 12 of 49
McElwaine Property - Maitland
Contact McElwaine Property - Maitland
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent