Our profile

Our reviews

  4.8  
77 reviewsacross 23 different locations, showing 12.
Buyer review
Very helpful and knowledgeable
10 months ago
Very helpful and knowledgeable

Cindy was helpful and had great knowledge of the local market.

Cindy McGillivray

Cindy McGillivray

  4.8   (104 reviews)
Seller review
Excellent market knowledge,  communication and professionalism.
10 months ago
Excellent market knowledge, communication and professionalism.

Cindy and her team are not only excellent at what they do, but they were kind and caring during this difficult time. Going above and beyond rather than just selling a property. Cindy never faulted in any way, maintaining excellent communication and positive feedback. If you want to sell your property let Cindy sell it. Her local knowledge is amazing.

Cindy McGillivray

Cindy McGillivray

  4.8   (104 reviews)
Buyer review
 Cindy was extremely helpful & professional
12 months ago
Cindy was extremely helpful & professional

We found Cindy to be extremely helpful & professional in assisting us in our purchase always quick to respond to us throughout the process. Would recommend Cindy when purchasing.

Cindy McGillivray

Cindy McGillivray

  4.8   (104 reviews)
Seller review
I felt I could not fault Cindy and staff she was open and honest me continually
about 1 year ago
I felt I could not fault Cindy and staff she was open and honest me continually

Going to McGrath nowra with Cindy was the best descion. She had my property up and running for sale even after hours she still kept me updated . Sold within 2weeks with a price exceeded my expectations. I cannot fault and will continue to recommend her .

Cindy McGillivray

Cindy McGillivray

  4.8   (104 reviews)
Buyer review
Terrific sales agent
about 1 year ago
Terrific sales agent

She was happy to show us through the property whenever we asked. We were very pleased with all the information she gave us about the property and was very helpful.

Cindy McGillivray

Cindy McGillivray

  4.8   (104 reviews)
Buyer review
Good local knowledge
about 1 year ago
Good local knowledge

Good local knowledge. Cindy's insights into the local area were very helpful.

Cindy McGillivray

Cindy McGillivray

  4.8   (104 reviews)
Seller review
Great to deal with and communicates effectively
about 1 year ago
Great to deal with and communicates effectively

Cindy is a delight to work with. As sellers, we felt Cindy looked after our property as her own. This makes a difference considering it takes us 2.5 hrs to visit the property. Cindy checks on it regularly and gives us advise how to make the property more marketable. Cindy also responds quickly and provides updates about buyer inquiries. In the end, Cindy was able to sell the property within our expectations. Thank you Cindy for all your help and support.

Cindy McGillivray

Cindy McGillivray

  4.8   (104 reviews)
Seller review
Market knowledge sound, communication was ok. Professional approach.
about 1 year ago
Market knowledge sound, communication was ok. Professional approach.

Our experience was good. We had an interested buyer before going to market, a credit to Cindy for matching a potential buyer to our property. This interested buyer has now purchased the property.

Cindy McGillivray

Cindy McGillivray

  4.8   (104 reviews)
Seller review
Great Agent couldn't be happier
about 1 year ago
Great Agent couldn't be happier

Cindy from the first call to her inspection of my property, was clear and honest, with her appraisal of my property. Her insight on how to present it was top notch and her assistance in presentation coupled with photos was excellent to say the least. If you have a property to sell or rent Cindy is your agent. I couldn't recommend her highly enough down to the promptness in answering or returning calls from me settling my nerves. Thankyou again Cindy for all your help

Cindy McGillivray

Cindy McGillivray

  4.8   (104 reviews)
Seller review
Incredible knowledge of the area and what she can deliver was spot on
over 1 year ago
Incredible knowledge of the area and what she can deliver was spot on

Everything Cindy said she would do to give our home the greatest chance of being sold at a great price was done and more . Great communications and she went out of her way to service our needs including helping us with things that weren’t even part of her service. This realestate is truly the best agency I have ever had the pleasure of being associated with. Can’t recommend Mcgath and Cindy highly enough .

Cindy McGillivray

Cindy McGillivray

  4.8   (104 reviews)
Buyer review
Great all round experience
over 1 year ago
Great all round experience

From the moment we made the first enquiry about the property we purchased , Cindy was extremely helpful . She was always on time to viewings , very professional in her approach and was across all details of the property. Great communication and always available to answer any questions even outside of normal work hours . Thanks Cindy for assisting us on this journey and our dream .

Cindy McGillivray

Cindy McGillivray

  4.8   (104 reviews)
Seller review
Consistently positive, informed, proactive and communitative!
over 1 year ago
Consistently positive, informed, proactive and communitative!

Selling property and moving house can be highly stressful. In our case we were moving some distance from our property and we constantly appreciated how Cindy and her team did everything to minimise that stress. They were always highly professional and highly communicative, showing a consistently relevant understanding of the property market both broadly and as it applied to our property. Cindy's experience and attention to detail was evident at every stage. We were always confident that the team were conscious of presenting and marketing the property to the best advantage. Cindy was especially organised and efficient in her choice of presentation and maintenance personal. We were always grateful to her and her team for her foresight and quick resolution of any issues that might arise. We are very happy to highly recommend Cindy McGillivray and her team.

Cindy McGillivray

Cindy McGillivray

  4.8   (104 reviews)
25 - 36 of 77
© 2026 RateMyAgent