Carl's profile

Carl's reviews

  4.8  
Carl has 102 reviewsacross 11 different locations, showing 12.
over 9 years ago
Carl Payne

Carl has a simple and personal approach as a Real estate agent. We looked for a house for over one year and met a lot of cheesy plastic and dodgy agents. Carl is a genuine peoples person, helpful and informative. We bugged him for random little things and extra visits and he still maintained his helpful character. We are both loving our new house, thank you Carl we appreciate it mate. Robbie and Laura.

over 9 years ago
Exceeding Customer Satisfaction

Over the years I have had experience with Real Estate Agents, some good ,some bad and some very ordinary. However, my dealings with Carl Payne have put some credibility back into the sales process. I found Carl to be very professional at all times during our endeavours to purchase a new home. His knowledge of the area and the houses were extremely good. I would have no hesitation in recommending Carl and Barry Plant Croydon to anyone in the market for a new residence. John Montigue on behalf of Val and June Littlefield.

over 9 years ago
Carl Payne and Ashly Hutson

Carl Payne of Barry Plant Croydon and Ashly Hutson of Lilydale branch recently sold my property in Croydon. During the marketing campaign both Carl and Ashly provided me with regular updates and continually kept me informed throughout the process. They both have a very professional approachand are extremely efficient. They went above and beyond to achieve the best possible result. They were punctual, reliable and most importantly trustworthy, l would highly recommend Carl and Ashly of Barry Plant. Carley

almost 10 years ago
Plumer Street Croydon

On behalf of my mother and family, I would like to thank Carl Payne, Geoff Thompson and the team from Barry Plant Croydon for their excellent service they provided for us on the sale of our family home. Although sad, they made us feel like we were dealing with family. The sale price was well above what we expected which was fantastic. Once again thank you all so much. Job well done!! Cheryl and the Fletcher family

almost 10 years ago
A Knowledgeable, Trustworthy & Diplomatic Agent

Carl is genuine, professional, a great negotiator, relaxed, incredibly patient and trustworthy. Also, highly ethical. Carl sold 2 properties for us as part of a deceased estate during a particularly difficult period. He always returned calls before, during and after hours, and was happy to deal with any minor concern or issue. Carl has a keen understanding of the market, gave very good advice on presentation and other aspects of selling. We are possibly selling property closer to the city soon and would love Carl to be our agent. 5 Plus stars.

almost 10 years ago
Relief and appreciation @ the 11th hour

Carl took on all our requirements and provided the service that we needed to meet these requirements. He discussed the market, the options, the opportunities, the realities. He provided feedback every week on the inspections, on his projections, on his direction, his plans for the following week. He was available for every meeting we requested, he answered every call we made. On auction date, our house was passed in at 2pm. From that time, Carl just accelerated. He started calling people who had visited, people who did not bid at the auction, people who had attended other auctions. He went to his office and kept us informed of his strategy which was to SELL. After 6 hours of wrangling and calling and not giving up Carl sold our home to a person who had not even been present at the auction. The purchaser had been to our home previously but had not made a firm offer. We went from distress and disappointment to complete relief. Carl went above and beyond to make sure that our home was sold. We were very lucky to have him as our agent and that his default setting is not to give up. We sold our home after 3 weeks on the market. He accomplished what we definitely thought was impossible given the results at the auction. He knows his stuff, he told it like it was and he achieved the outcome that we needed.

almost 10 years ago
Fantastic service and advice

I have dealt extensively with real estate agents over 40 years, Carl negotiated on our behalf way above my expectations, was always prompt and quick returning calls, he did this in a difficult situation for a deceased estate where several people were involved. And, he continued to provide assistance once the sale was complete.

about 10 years ago
16 Byron road

The process was very quick and easy thanks to Carl and the Barry plant team. Carl had great communication letting me know everything that was happening and Negotiated very well to get a better then expected price.

over 10 years ago
Carl Payne & Barry Plant Croydon

Thanks Carl and the team at Barry Plant, Croydon for your friendly and professional service! You were efficient in responding to all enquiries and I was very pleased with my buying experience.

over 10 years ago
6 Boronia Ave Croydon South

Very happy with Carl Payne and Barry Plant Croydon. Easy sale and we got the price range we wanted. I would highly recommend Carl and Barry Plant Croydon.

over 10 years ago
Very Fast Sale!

Carl was recommended to me by a family member. I am happy with the way the sale of my Unit was handled. Carl was easy to talk to and very professional in his process. He was able to find a buyer in approx two weeks, who offered me the right price, and I was able to go ahead with my plans to move closer to my family and grandchildren. Thanks Carl for a good job.

49 - 60 of 102
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent