Carly's profile

Carly's reviews

  4.9  
Carly has 93 reviewsacross 24 different locations, showing 12.
about 5 years ago
A pleasure to deal with

During a difficult year in 2020, Carly sold two houses for us in two different suburbs with two different price ranges. Both houses were sold within a week of going on the market. Throughout the process of selling both houses Carly was exceptionally professional and easy to deal with. I have dealt with other agents in the past that have left me feeling underwhelmed with their performance. Carly on the other hand was always a pleasure to deal with. I highly recommend her services.

about 5 years ago
No nonsense style.

I cannot say enough about Carly’s professionalism and knowledge. Carly has high integrity and is very conscientious and tenacious. One of the qualities I respected was Carly’s no-nonsense style. She gets to the point quickly yet professionally. She listens. She is responsive to questions, responding immediately. She shows great attention. I have the highest level of confidence in her and feel she would be able to accurately assess any situation and figure out an effective solution. Jenn & John

over 5 years ago
Highly Recommend

Highly recommend Carly for her sales knowledge and professionalism. She supported me in every facet of our sale. Her guidance and emotional support was just what I needed . She was contactable and updated me regularly. Her encouragement and experience enabled us to get a great sales result.

over 5 years ago
Highly Recommend

Carly was exceptional in all that she did for us to sell our property. We have highly recommended Carly to our family and friends based on her professionalism, quick, unbelievable results and her clear, prompt communication.

over 5 years ago
Nothing was ever a drama

Carly was fantastic to deal with in the buying process. Nothing was ever a drama and the stress all went away when you are dealing with a good real estate agent. Would recommned Carly and McGrath to anyone and I'm sure it's not the last time we cross paths.

over 5 years ago
Such a Pleasure

Carly's Knowledge of the market was exceptional, with informative constant communication , she made the process so simple. It was such a pleasure dealing with Carly.

over 5 years ago
Exceptionally Professional

During a difficult year in 2020, Carly sold two houses for us in two different suburbs with two different price ranges. Both houses were sold within a week of going on the market. Throughout the process of selling both houses Carly was exceptionally professional and easy to deal with. I have dealt with other agents in the past that have left me feeling underwhelmed with their performance. Carly on the other hand was always a pleasure to deal with. I highly recommend her services.

over 5 years ago
Fantastic to deal with

Carly was fantastic to deal with in the buying process. Nothing was ever a drama and the stress all went away when your dealing with a good real estate agent. Would recommend Carly and McGrath to anyone and I’m sure it’s not the last time we cross paths

over 5 years ago
Friendly and Honest

Carly’s exceptional knowledge of the area ensured that she achieved our results by attracting the right group of buyers to our property, she managed multiple offers, left no stone unturned and successfully exceeded our expectations pre auction. Her professional, friendly and honest approach made our journey pleasurable and the reason why we would have no hesitation in asking Carly to assist us again in the future and highly recommending her to others looking to sell.

over 5 years ago
Enthusiastic, Professional without hidden agendas!

Carly’s approach was professional, enthusiastic, and without any hidden agendas. She was always honest, available, responsive, and her knowledge about the current real estate market was second to none. We got multiple offers within the first few days of being on the market, and sold for above asking price in just two weeks. Actually, our sale established a new price record for our pocket of the suburb! We couldn't have been happier or more impressed with the service we received from Carly!

over 5 years ago
Genuinely Grateful

Carly is a fantastic Sales Agent to work with, I am genuinely grateful for all her hard work and honest approach. Carly is a true professional with a great knowledge of the Newcastle property market and I was provided with clear and regular insights during the sale process. I was kept very well informed during the process through clear and regular communication. Carly regularly went above and beyond for me during the sale of my home and I couldn’t have asked for more!

over 5 years ago
Very Professional

Nothing was too much trouble for Carly, She is very processional in all that she does.

37 - 48 of 93
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent