Elisa McMahon's reviews
Elisa McMahon

Elisa McMahon

  4.4   (11 reviews)

37 Kent Street

Elisa helped the reviewer sell this property

Elisa McMahon
$2,700,000
37 Kent Street
Hamilton
5
5
2
House

over 3 years ago

totally unprofessional

We received a less than professional experience that resulted in a very stressful campaign. From the start the agent had promised results and nowhere near delivered. The advertising began with a huge life size billboard of herself with no picture of our property. Advertising in the local paper was an extra cost to us and was run on the day of the actual auction. We felt that the agent was always talking about her past sales and wouldn't listen to our feedback or concerns. Constantly we were shut down with the phrase _"I've been doing this for over 20 years and an extremely condescending "This is not my first rodeo." Elisa McMahon communicated with us that a potential buyer who made an offer prior to auction was undeniably agitated with us for not taking the offer. The descriptive word actually used is not suitable to print in this review. We felt that the agent was working more for the purchaser instead of the vendor. Elisa strongly talked us out of going to auction and then had over ten couples turn up on the day. In following her advice and feeling we had no other perspective purchases a sale prior to auction occurred and for a considerable amount less than the agreed. The reserve at our initial meeting was promised and again not delivered. Unfortunately, due to our experience with Elisa McMahon and Adcock Prestige, we will not be requiring the services of this agent in the future and will be strongly advising other vendors who ask for our opinion to look elsewhere to receive a service that is an advocate for the vendor.

S
Seller
Elisa
The sale of a house causes a lot of sellers anxiety, it is a significant transaction. Whilst I empathise with your situation and understand the reasons for you having to sell, the outcome given the circumstances was exceptional. Upon appointment, you advised there were significant issues with the builder and architect. I advised that I would be your local contact to support and did on several occasions providing access to the property for trades and even purchasing 12 bottles of wine for the cellar before the first open home. The fencing was not complete (as per initial photos), work within the property was still being done and the rear fence was not painted until 2 days before Auction. That being said, you instructed me to proceed with the campaign and I said I would do my best to accommodate and work with buyers and communicated the intended high level of finish. The Auction was delayed by one week as the property was still not finished as per your advice. The paper adverts were changed to coincide with that. A comparable listing for your property, two doors down, brand new 5 bedroom home is currently listed for $2.5m, anecdotal advice is that it was passed in for $1.9m at Auction. Your property sold for $2.7m - $200,000 above this. You had substantial time and feedback (from weekly written vendor reports over a 5 week campaign and daily phone calls) to make the decision to sell prior to Auction. The buyers I spoke to on Auction Day at the property did not have the capacity for the purchase. If you have the details of the 10 parties I will cross-reference with my records and provide an update for you. I have a strong reputation in the market for legal compliance, integrity and exceptional results and I intend that to remain.
Elisa responded on 14 Jun 2023

See who was involved in this review

Elisa McMahon
Elisa McMahon

Licensed Real Estate Agent

View profile   4.4   (11 reviews)
EmailSMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent