Jay's profile

Jay's reviews

  4.9  
Jay has 110 reviewsacross 16 different locations, showing 12.
about 2 years ago
Exceptional service and result

Jay Carroll provided exceptional service during our recent home sale. His professionalism, expertise, and dedication greatly contributed to the success of the sale. Throughout the process, Jay demonstrated a deep understanding of the market, exceeding our expectations. We were consistently impressed by Jay’s clear communication and prompt responsiveness. He kept us informed at every stage and addressed inquiries efficiently. His transparent communication style gave us confidence throughout the sale campaign. Having worked with Jay before, we’ll gladly do so again and recommend him to anyone seeking a skilled and trustworthy real estate professional.

over 3 years ago
Exceeded all expectations

We used Barry Plant for selling our house as it was Jay Carroll who was the agent who sold us the house a number of years earlier and had made the purchase a good and fair experience. Jay was excellent from start to finish and made everything about the house sale an easy and stress free experience. Jay also got us a price which far exceeding our own estimates! If selling a property in the Ringwood area, Jay Carroll should be the no. 1 choice.

over 4 years ago
Wonderful stress free experience!

After much research and speaking to a number of local agents, we decided straight away to go with Jay after speaking with him. He stood out amongst the competition and we never once regretted our decision. He and his team were fantastic to work with throughout the whole process. Even though we were overseas during the auction, he was very communicative in the lead up and made us feel confident and calm (well as much as one could be prior to an auction!). Not only did he reach our reserve, he was able to surpass it much to our delight. He is a pleasure to work with and I would work with him again in a heartbeat.

almost 5 years ago
Brilliant experience with Jay

During the sale of my house Jay was very professional and an absolute pleasure to deal with. He has a very good knowledge of the area and the market. Jay is also a great communicator and kept me well informed throughout the process. I was very confident of Jay’s ability to manage the campaign and was very happy with the overall process and the result. I highly recommend Jay and wouldn’t hesitate to use his services again in future for both selling and purchasing.

almost 5 years ago
Outstanding Effort by Jay

Jay worked very closely with us and due to our circumstances took full responsibility to prepare our property for sale Jay was alway there for us, proactive and communicated so well throughout the sale process He very professionally undertook the auction and we felt very comfortable through the whole process We highly recommend Jay and his team

almost 5 years ago
Fantastic agent

I could not recommend Jay more highly. His local knowledge of the market is first rate and his communication with me throughout the process was very impressive. His calm, reassuring nature was an asset, particularly as a lockdown was imposed one day prior to my auction. He handled the situation with professionalism and managed to keep me calm, and achieve a fantastic result. Jay is a great guy to work with, and nothing was too much trouble for him. Thank you Jay.

almost 5 years ago
Great experience working with Jay

Jay always kept us in the loop on expectations and changes as we navigated through a lockdown during the sale process. Always a professional and prompt with his communication so we definitely felt we were looked after. He and his team work hard to get the results vendors want. Highly recommend Jay for future sales!

almost 5 years ago
The best agent going around

Jay was incredible to work and we recommend him so highly to anyone selling their homes. Jay was personable, communication was next level and he was incredibly supportive for two very nervous first-time sellers. We spoke to a few other agents and there was no comparison to what Jay brought to the table and every detail was organised from our very first meeting. On auction day, we were blown away with Barry Plant as an establishment. When we arrived there were huge banners, a coffee van and multiple Barry Plant agents ready to sell our property. We are beyond grateful for everything Jay did for us and the amazing result he achieved for our unit in Ringwood.

almost 5 years ago
Seller in Ringwood North!

Jay was very honest and hard working.He was very knowledgeable about real estate in the area.Jay's communication was excellent and he was always available to answer my questions .I got a great price for my property. Highly recommended. !!

almost 5 years ago
Seller of Townhouse!

He showed real interest in what we wanted, how we felt about the marketing plan, and whilst using his market experience, was flexible to our needs. Having watched him at auctions before and during our sales campaign, he works hard to get the best result for the vendor and ensures all interested parties feel valued. I would highly recommend Jay if you are thinking of selling!

almost 5 years ago
Seller in Mitcham

From our first meeting Jay was very impressive, he is knowledgeable, friendly and reassuring. Jay knows his market and was absolutely amazing with the sale of what has been our family home for over 30 years. I would highly recommend Jay as our experience has been 5 star from start to finish. His kindness and reassurance in a stressful time has been fantastic! Thanks Jay for getting an excellent result!

over 5 years ago
Top marks for Jay Carroll

Jay Carroll was completely professional, engaging, knowledgeable and clearly experienced. We sold during the Coronavirus lockdown, but Jay made it as painless as possible and secured a great sale for us in just a few weeks. He assisted at every point along the way, with gardeners, window cleaners etc, was always available, and kept us updated every day. Cannot recommend him highly enough.

1 - 12 of 110
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent