Jay's profile

Jay's reviews

  4.9  
Jay has 110 reviewsacross 16 different locations, showing 12.
over 6 years ago
Extremely helpful

Jay maintain an open and regular communication through out the selling process, honest, negotiated my property to get the best outcome. I'm very happy with his service and would definitely recommend.

over 6 years ago
Exceptionally hard-working & honest

Our experience selling with Jay and Barry Plant was an exceptionally positive one. Jay and David went above and beyond to secure the best offer for our property and always followed up with calls at times that suited our busy lives. Thanks again for all your support Jay & David!

over 6 years ago
A knowledgeable and reassuring guide for those who want to sell

We cannot recommend Jay Carroll highly enough if you want to sell your home in the Ringwood and surrounding areas. We interviewed 2 other agents who had admirable qualities, but we were struck with Jay's local knowledge, but most importantly had worked out the best way to market and sell our home. We were very glad we chose Jay to sell our home! We found Jay quite affable and very humble to deal with, and always answered our queries and worries promptly. His marketing strategy was tailored to sell our large home perfectly and his negotiating skills to close the sale was excellent. We couldn't be happier with our result. Kudos Jay and the team.

over 6 years ago
Outstanding Service & an Excellent Outcome

Jay was very understanding and had a great knowledge of the market. He is great with people, a great communicator and the consummate professional. He is open, friendly, pragmatic and outcome focused. Jay and his team liaised closely with us throughout the campaign and helped to achieve a great outcome. I have no problems in recommending Jay and the Barry Plant team to anybody looking to sell their house.

almost 7 years ago
Very helpful, great communication

Jay is probably one of the most hard working person I've ever met. Jay has been always very helpful with my questions and requests. The best experience is the communication, easy and straight forward. Thanks a lot to Jay!

almost 7 years ago
Brilliant agent, outstanding experience

Jay is a complete professional & working with him was an absolute pleasure. We were thrilled with the end result & felt entirely supported through the whole process. Couldn’t recommend him more.

almost 7 years ago
THANKS JAY !!!

Firstly l would like to thank Jay on his professional manner dealing with myself and potential buyers. He answered all of my questions and my phone calls in a prompt manner and nothing was a hassle, he always kept me in the loop with viewings and kept me informed at every turn which resulted in the smooth sale of my unit ... thanks again Jay ! Jay and Barry Plant would be my first choice if l was to sell or buy in the future !

almost 7 years ago
Outstanding Service

Jay took the stress out of selling and kept me informed the whole way through the selling process. Highly recommend him

almost 7 years ago
Such an easy experience of selling a property with Jay at the helm.

Extremely easy sale for us because of Jay's professionalism. He took charge from the first meeting, explaining every step. His support, advice, follow ups and care was outstanding. With Jay handling the sale, all we had to do was sit back and let it happen.

about 7 years ago
Great service, friendly and professional

Jay had a great knowledge of the locality and the possible target market for my apartment. The sale of the apartment had many irregularities to negotiate and Jay was able to achieve a sale in a reasonable timeframe given the circumstsnces. Although it did not achieve the price I would have liked, given the downturning market and the circumstances surrounding my sale, he did a great job. Would recommend him to anyone considering selling.

about 7 years ago
We found Jay to be a very pleasant young man who certainly knows his field and was always courteous

Jay was always polite in his mannerism, always prompt with returning calls to us. His advice in setting up our house was very welcome and he explained exactly how he was going to handle the selling and kept us informed of every open day results so we knew exactly how the selling of the house was progressing. We thank him for his effort and success in the selling of our house and wish him well in the future.Yours sincerely Thelma & Joe Licheri.

about 7 years ago
Above & Beyond selling with Jay Carroll

Please scroll down to the end to read full Review: Thank You Jay for your commitment to sell my 2 bedroom unit in Ringwood East. The property was in the hands of another agent for a few months and then they left the company. At first I had a little apprehension having a new agent but you quickly made a connection with me when you gave me updates after each viewing, even when no one attended the openings. I appreciated your honesty. Also your patience with me asking numerous questions helped me to put my concerns at rest. Selling the unit was a little slow but only because there was so many on the market for buyers to choose from. Nevertheless, you continued with enthusiasm to forge ahead to sell my 2 bedroom unit in Ringwood East and help me achieve my heart's desire to move to Sunshine Coast near my family. You went above and beyond, helping me change the presentation of some rooms for better photos. For example removing the long desk from the window and moving the bookshelf from in front of the window to another spot in the same small room, made the room look bigger and allowed more light into the room. Another suggestion you gave me was to remove the carpets from all living areas to show the lovely floating boards. Thank You Jay and I would highly recommend you to sell all properties. Your professionalism, knowledge and commitment in all aspects of selling my unit was greatly appreciated. I felt that you gave me the same committment to selling a 2 bedroom unit as to selling a multi-million property. That's dedication! You went above and beyond what my expectations for what a salesman does to sell a property. Good luck with selling more properties. You’re the best!!

25 - 36 of 110
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent