Jay's profile

Jay's reviews

  4.9  
Jay has 569 reviewsacross 25 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Jay's qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, supportive, reliable, responsive, honest, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Happy Vendors
about 2 years ago
Happy Vendors

Many thanks to Jay Cleary and Sandy Fairbrother for the professional and friendly manner they showed when offering our Unit for sale. We have bought and sold with Jay and later with Sandy over many years and their knowledge and integrity never fails to impress. We had every confidence in their ability from prior transactions and were not disappointed when they sold the unit within one week at our asking price. We sincerely recommend Jay and Sandy to any prospective buyers or sellers of Real Estate in Bathurst and surrounds. Thank you Jay and Sandy for your excellent service.. John and rosemary seaman

Seller review
Great communication and a fast sale.
about 2 years ago
Great communication and a fast sale.

The sale of our property was smooth and easy. Given the tough market conditions at the moment, Jay and Sandy were able to sell in no time at all and for the price we were asking.

Seller review
Jay Cleary the Agent to Trust
about 2 years ago
Jay Cleary the Agent to Trust

My wife and I engaged Jay Cleary to market and sell a rural block at PEEL for us. From the moment of Jay's services beginning he has been in touch with us every moment of an interest in the block also keeping us updated on the Marketing Process/Progress. Jay has been polite and professional throughout the sale process. Jay has an easy going manner and is very approachable. We would recommend Jay to anyone wanting to either buy or sell within their area of operations.

Buyer review
Stress-free purchase!
about 2 years ago
Stress-free purchase!

We have just bought our Forever Home with Jay. From the moment we met him, we were impressed by his honesty and professionalism. Jay was always quick to help us, and always just a phone call away, no matter the time. We had delays with our finances and Jay was knowledgable and kept us informed of all of our options throughout. Would highly recommend Jay whether buying or selling! Wish we had met him sooner!

Seller review
Brilliant yet again!
about 2 years ago
Brilliant yet again!

We have bought and now sold with Jay and it has been an extreme pleasure to trust him with our property. Jay is knowledgeable of the market as well as the local area, professional and always communicated well with us. Nothing we asked of him was ever too much. We wouldn’t do property with anyone else!

Seller review
Jay gets the job done & done either to or beyond your expectations!
about 2 years ago
Jay gets the job done & done either to or beyond your expectations!

We met Jay after engaging his business partner Sandy over the sale of our home. Jay & Sandy took us through a 2-hour presentation of their business approach to selling & the ideas & resources they suggested would present our home to maximum effect. Jays' knowledge of the local market & his ability to both present & validate statistics & results that complemented the proposed sale of our home, really made us comfortable that we had chosen the right agents. Jays' thoughts & ideas just made sense in terms of what we thought our home was worth & how we thought it should be presented to the market. His skills & those of his partner Sandy work in harmony with each other to provide the collective approach that led to the successful sale of our home. Always respectful of the emotion that can come with selling the family home & always focused on the best outcome, Jay provided strong guidance & support with any uncertainties we experienced & an unwavering confidence in what he believed we would achieve with our home. We would not hesitate to engage Cleary Fairbrother Property again if selling our home. Two good guys to have on your side!

Seller review
Experienced and proactive
about 2 years ago
Experienced and proactive

When we first sat down with Jay Cleary, it didn't take us long to realise he was an experienced and knowledgeable Real Estate Agent. He is amiable and easy to talk to and has a very good understanding of the sale process and the potential pitfalls and how to address them should they occur. We are so glad we went with Cleary Fairbrother. Jay is a motivated and proactive agent and worked hard on our behalf. The level of communication was second to none with regular updates and progress reports. We were informed every step of the way and our sale, although stumbling across a few hurdles, was relatively fast, which was definitely the result of this active team working hard to achieve the result we needed and wanted. We are very grateful to Jay and the team at Cleary Fairbrother and couldn't be happier. We highly recommend Jay and the team at Cleary Fairbrother

Seller review
Great agent
about 2 years ago
Great agent

Jay managing most of the inspections for our property and eventually the process with the buyer. He was very responsive and helped with all details we required. We got a great price and would highly recommend Jay and the team at Cleary Fairbrothers

Seller review
Outstanding Experience
about 2 years ago
Outstanding Experience

I recently had the pleasure of listing my house with Jay from Cleary and Fairbrother Property. From the moment I met with Jay and his business partner Sandy, I could see that I was in the hands of a very professional team. Jay’s strategic approach to marketing attracted serious buyers, resulting in a swift and successful sale. I was amazed at how efficiently he navigated the process, making it seem effortless while achieving outstanding results. Jay’s talent was his negotiation skills. He demonstrated an unparalleled skill in advocating for my interests, ensuring that every detail was carefully considered and negotiated to perfection. Throughout the entire process, Jay maintained open lines of communication, keeping me informed every step of the way. His professionalism, integrity, and dedication to his clients were evident in every interaction, making the entire experience not only successful but also stress free. I highly recommend Jay and the team at Cleary and Fairbrother Property.

Buyer review
Great Purchasing Experience
about 2 years ago
Great Purchasing Experience

We recently bought a house in Bathurst and we couldn't be happier with Jay's service. There is so much at stake when buying a home, and Jay made the process very calming and smooth. He was always ready to help with any questions we had. His communication was outstanding and his manner was extremely professional, yet friendly. We would definitely recommend Jay Cleary.

Seller review
Very professional and good to deal with
about 2 years ago
Very professional and good to deal with

Jay is very friendly and efficient and kept me well informed on what was happening with the property. This was a far better experience than what I had experienced with another larger Real Estate Agency who had the property for well over a year without any success.

Seller review
Best in the business.
about 2 years ago
Best in the business.

Jay is 100% our go to guy for buying and selling homes. This is the 3rd home we have sold through Jay. He is extremely knowledgeable about the current market and is always upfront and honest. He is very friendly and approachable and no question is ever to big or small. We were kept us in the loop the whole way through selling period. If you are looking to buy or sell a home Jay is definitely your person!

121 - 132 of 569
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent