Jay's profile

Jay's reviews

  4.9  
Jay has 563 reviewsacross 25 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Jay's qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, supportive, reliable, responsive, honest, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Reliable local agent
about 2 years ago
Reliable local agent

I have known Jay for a number of years now and he is a reliable and professional agent in town. I would not hesitate to reach out to Jay to buy or sell your home and thank him for supporting to sell my recent investment property. Great agent to work with

Buyer review
Friendly and professional
about 2 years ago
Friendly and professional

Jay was friendly, knowledgeable and professional throughout the whole experience making my journey as simple as it could be.

Seller review
An excellent result
about 2 years ago
An excellent result

I recently had the opportunity to use Cleary Fairbrother to sell my late Fathers home. We selected this agency because Jay was very honest and helpful during the initial inspection and later was very confident in his ability to make the sale. His knowledge of the market secured a sale price well above my estimate. We where kept updated at all times by both phone, email and messages and the professionalism shown was never less than 100% I would recommend Jay without hesitation.

Seller review
Best Agent in town
about 2 years ago
Best Agent in town

Jay is genuine. He handles himself in a professional manner whilst treating you like a person not a sale to be made. He will give you honesty and is readily available to answer all queries. He knows Bathurst and understands the market.

Seller review
Highly Recommend
about 2 years ago
Highly Recommend

Thank you for being so professional, helpful & thoughtful going through the process of selling my mother's house. This is a very stressful thing to have to do, but you guided me through & communicated all the way. So glad I chose this agent.

Seller review
Jay was the very able copilot in my home sale
about 2 years ago
Jay was the very able copilot in my home sale

Jay was very much involved in the sale of my Bathurst home. He provided potential purchaser inspections and hosted ‘open house’ viewings. He provided frank feedback as to the ‘prospects’ of those he met at the ‘open houses’ and those seeking personal inspections. I was very appreciative of that in extravagant advice - very much keeping me grounded. His previous involvement in earlier sales of that same property was also very reassuring. I do not underestimate his contribution to the sale of the property - and thank and recommend him accordingly. Many thanks, Jay!

Seller review
Professionalism plus!
about 2 years ago
Professionalism plus!

Jay was very professional and helpful throughout the process of selling our home. We couldn’t recommend the Cleary Fairbrother team highly enough.

Seller review
Supported right to the finish line!
about 2 years ago
Supported right to the finish line!

Having dealt with Jay previously for a purchase and sale, it was a no brainer to adopt his services again when selling. This time with a bonus in Sandy! Whilst we mostly dealt with Jay, he and Sandy work as a team to show your home with respect and professionalism. We were kept up to date the whole time, directed wisely and with humour. With a unique property in ours to sell, they found the right buyer and supported us right to the finish line!

Seller review
Excellent!
over 2 years ago
Excellent!

Jay was excellent throughout the sale of our house. We are very pleased with our result. Highly recommend!

Buyer review
Absolute Legend and helpful
over 2 years ago
Absolute Legend and helpful

Great agent. Professional and knowledgeable in providing a great outcome. Very helpful. Always available in need or if there is any queries. It was a very smooth process. Highly recommended Jay Cleary.

Seller review
Friendly and professional service
over 2 years ago
Friendly and professional service

This is the second property I have sold with Jay and Sandy at Cleary Fairbrother, and if I find myself needing to sell again, I’ll definitely return. Jay is a friendly and professional agent who provided sound advice and great service to get my house sold. Easy to deal and a great result on my sale. I’m happy to recommend Jay to anyone selling their home.

Seller review
Jay and Sandy actively sourced a buyer for me...
over 2 years ago
Jay and Sandy actively sourced a buyer for me...

Sandy and Jay actively sourced a potential buyer for my property... My property is quite unique (2 units on one title) and therefore mainly of interest to investors and not the usual wider audience. This made things considerably more challenging in the current economic climate, however Sandy and Jay successfully found a buyer and made the entire process very simple and stress-free. I would definitely recommend this team without any hesitation. Thanks Sandy and Jay 10/10 .

133 - 144 of 563
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent